Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think my brothers abusing the system

95 replies

bhgnrpusbpilates · 09/04/2026 16:33

or is he entitled to do this.

I will cut a long story short my brother late 30s, volunteered redundancy end of last year ( completely voluntary, so chose to be unemployed) and went travelling for a bit, he came back recently and i overheard him telling someone now its the new tax year he is going to claim new JSA as he can for 6 months as its not means tested (ie redundancy payment wont be taken into account), and probably just go off travelling again.

We have always been raised in a household where you work end of , and my mum is first to call anyone else for abusing the system ( my brother is the favourite so perhaps i'm being a bit bitter)

but i don't agree with this at all, I wasn't massively happy with him for making himself redundant from a decent job just because he felt like it ( i too have a decent job but the R word terrifies me ) I think decent jobs are hard to come by these days , and its not like hes in his 50s, he graduated during the credit crunch so took him a while to get such a good opportunity.

My parents are annoying me by saying oh well good for him hes entitled to it etc etc but I just know if it was me doing it they would be going mad

sorry rant over and feel free to tell me i should get my head out my #### and live a little.

OP posts:
IDontHateRainbows · 10/04/2026 22:07

XenoBitch · 10/04/2026 22:05

That is how CB JSA works.
Hate the game, not the player.

That's exactly what I said, it's the system not the individual.

ThunderCatsHooo · 10/04/2026 22:14

Why are you so bothered, it's his life. JSA is peanuts as far as I'm aware and I think you have to show proof you are looking for work, and attend meetings, you can't claim it from outside the country. So I'm not sure what you are getting so worked up about, I'm sure he will return to work when his money runs low. Leave him to live his life.

ImFinePMSL · 10/04/2026 22:17

TillyToeTaps · 09/04/2026 16:43

@LassiKopiano24 Isn’t it the business of the person paying tax into the welfare system which is giving him JSA?

No.

I also pay tax, and don’t give a fuck who applies and qualifies for welfare. I may need it at some point further in my life.

TillyToeTaps · 10/04/2026 22:22

Well I do give a fuck about someone who consciously evades employment and expects me to work to pay the tax for their JSA. That isn’t need. It’s choice.

XenoBitch · 10/04/2026 22:27

TillyToeTaps · 10/04/2026 22:22

Well I do give a fuck about someone who consciously evades employment and expects me to work to pay the tax for their JSA. That isn’t need. It’s choice.

Erm, OP's DB took up voluntary redundancy. Look up what that means before you get your knickers in a twist.
And because he was working, he can claim NC JSA, which means he can be a billionare and still claim UC... but be aware that the UC claim is just about £100pw, and he will have to prove he is looking for work for the same hours as a full time worker.

ImFinePMSL · 10/04/2026 22:37

TillyToeTaps · 10/04/2026 22:22

Well I do give a fuck about someone who consciously evades employment and expects me to work to pay the tax for their JSA. That isn’t need. It’s choice.

Steve Coogan Shrug GIF

.

Uhnoseriouslyy · 10/04/2026 22:38

If your brother claims JSA he would need to attend appointments. Some can be weekly.

TillyToeTaps · 10/04/2026 22:42

Isn’t he intending to travel?
How does that fit in with
he will have to prove he is looking for work for the same hours as a full time worker.
?

Silverbirchleaf · 10/04/2026 22:52

Can I add, that you don’t actually need much evidence of jobs you’re looking for. Just say you’ve applied to x, y and z, and looked at Indeed website. When dh applied, he didn’t find it a difficult or demanding process, and he went from fortnightly to monthly meetings.

Franjipanl8r · 10/04/2026 22:54

Taking redundancy and claiming JSA is pretty shit, whatever he says to sound positive and make himself feel better.

Flyingkitez · 10/04/2026 23:35

Op this is going to come back to bite him. Travelling is lovely but the money will run out and he may regret not trying harder to find another decent job. Like others have said I do not think job seekers allows for him to be out of the country he needs to be applying and interviewing for work. Your parents are a separate issue they treat you both differently and you know he is the favourite.

ImGoneUnderground · 11/04/2026 00:43

SunshineOnARainyLeith · 09/04/2026 16:35

If he's on JSA he'd presumably have to be available for work and in the country.

If he is claiming JSA he has to be in the UK - his claim would be closed even if he went out of the UK for a day (he could then reclaim on his return). He has to be available & prove he is looking for work & attend appointments at the Jobcentre in order to qualify for JSA / New Style JSA. If he doesn't let them know that he is not in the UK, then he could be prosecuted for committing benefit fraud. (& more in depth checks are being done these days).
(UC has different rules, & is means tested, you are allowed to go abroad for up to a month - but also different qualifying criteria, such as savings/ investments etc).

nevernotmaybe · 11/04/2026 02:30

Thats not how voluntary redundancy happens, he didn't just get a random cushy resignation for no reason.

They were going to be making people redundant, he could have been one and was in the firing line, and if he was he would have got less. But he would been offered a bit more to make the process easier for the company.

Job seekers still requires job seeking, up to weekly appointments (sometimes 2 weeks), and work diaries, and all the rest. He isn’t getting anything while off travelling - well he could use up his two 7 day periods of sickness self certified and travel instead I suppose, but that's all you get per year so 14 days of not having to do anything and a holiday with small weekly payments.

monday1983 · 11/04/2026 07:33

IDontHateRainbows · 10/04/2026 22:01

It is a corrupt system if someone can receive 200 grand from their employer onna friday and claim from the tax payer the following Monday.

Why should the tax payer give someone in that situation a penny?

It's not corrupt at all. If someone worked for years and paid into the system they should be entitled to something and its only like 90 fir 6 months.
Lods of people do fuck all their all life claiming UC , working cash in hand or pretending to be single mothers,never intending to work and then still get pension credit in retirement for doing nothing, well that is corrupt.

Snakebite61 · 11/04/2026 12:41

bhgnrpusbpilates · 09/04/2026 16:33

or is he entitled to do this.

I will cut a long story short my brother late 30s, volunteered redundancy end of last year ( completely voluntary, so chose to be unemployed) and went travelling for a bit, he came back recently and i overheard him telling someone now its the new tax year he is going to claim new JSA as he can for 6 months as its not means tested (ie redundancy payment wont be taken into account), and probably just go off travelling again.

We have always been raised in a household where you work end of , and my mum is first to call anyone else for abusing the system ( my brother is the favourite so perhaps i'm being a bit bitter)

but i don't agree with this at all, I wasn't massively happy with him for making himself redundant from a decent job just because he felt like it ( i too have a decent job but the R word terrifies me ) I think decent jobs are hard to come by these days , and its not like hes in his 50s, he graduated during the credit crunch so took him a while to get such a good opportunity.

My parents are annoying me by saying oh well good for him hes entitled to it etc etc but I just know if it was me doing it they would be going mad

sorry rant over and feel free to tell me i should get my head out my #### and live a little.

Let him go for it. Our politicians are the biggest benefit cheats/claimants going.
If they think screwing the system is ok, why can't he?

GinandGingerBeer · 11/04/2026 12:56
  1. He’s won’t be entitled to it if it was voluntary redundancy. His employer will be contacted to verify the terms of the redundancy.
  2. He can’t claim it if he’s overseas as he has to attend either weekly or fortnightly.
  3. Even if he was back in the country he might not get it depending on how long he’s been out of the country. so basically he’s talking out of his arse and hadn’t done any research.
Carnationbloom · 11/04/2026 13:53

monday1983 · 11/04/2026 07:33

It's not corrupt at all. If someone worked for years and paid into the system they should be entitled to something and its only like 90 fir 6 months.
Lods of people do fuck all their all life claiming UC , working cash in hand or pretending to be single mothers,never intending to work and then still get pension credit in retirement for doing nothing, well that is corrupt.

This! With bells and whistles on.

it really annoys me when people think that those working, particularly those on higher incomes, should be excluded from the very system they have supported with their tax. Further, for those outraged by someone with voluntary redundancy claiming this, this is perfectly allowable as long as they have made sufficient NI contributions in the relevant years as this isn’t a ‘benefit’ it is in effect getting your own money back! The other reason to claim is because it keeps your NI up to date - ok with women who are full time child carers in the home getting an unearned NI credit? Then why would you begrudge this to someone made redundant?

what the OP’s brother could do is travel for a period, then come back and claim and as long as his NI contributions are still recent enough, he could still claim. It’s not an open ended payment, it’s not given unless you have paid in so it’s not depriving other tax payers of anything.

Carnationbloom · 11/04/2026 13:58

GinandGingerBeer · 11/04/2026 12:56

  1. He’s won’t be entitled to it if it was voluntary redundancy. His employer will be contacted to verify the terms of the redundancy.
  2. He can’t claim it if he’s overseas as he has to attend either weekly or fortnightly.
  3. Even if he was back in the country he might not get it depending on how long he’s been out of the country. so basically he’s talking out of his arse and hadn’t done any research.

You are incorrect. Voluntary redundancy is classed the same as compulsory redundancy. This is from the gov website: Benefits you could get
If you’ve lost your job, including through voluntary redundancy, you might be able to get:

  • New Style Jobseeker’s Allowance (JSA) if you’re under State Pension age, unemployed or are working less than 16 hours a week on average, and have made enough National Insurance contributions, usually over the last 2 to 3 years - your savings and partner’s income will not affect how much you get

Jobseeker's Allowance (JSA)

Jobseeker's Allowance (JSA) is an unemployment benefit you can claim while looking for work - how to apply online, New Style Jobseeker's Allowance (JSA), eligibility, rates, rapid reclaim, JSA interview, when payment can be stopped

https://www.gov.uk/jobseekers-allowance

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 12/04/2026 12:27

Is it still JSA where you live? It's Universal Credit here. Has been for at least 3 years.

IDontHateRainbows · 13/04/2026 20:14

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 12/04/2026 12:27

Is it still JSA where you live? It's Universal Credit here. Has been for at least 3 years.

Its both..they run in parallel you can choose which to apply for. So if you have assets, JSA

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread