Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pet related dilemma

26 replies

GreenCaterpillarOnALeaf · 01/02/2026 12:02

My DD is 6 and she has a cat. I didn't intentionally get her the cat, Miss Kitty Kat was my cat originally but she really bonded with DD and over the years DD had taken over feeding her, brushing her, picking out toys for her and pretty much everything bar cleaning the litter tray. DS is 4, soon to be 5 and he is now saying he wants his own cat. The problem is he’s not really responsible enough for a cat. Also I don’t think Miss Kitty would like a new sibling. DS has been saying it’s unfair ect and I see his point, but a pet isn’t about what’s fair, it’s a living creature.

DH say we should just rebrand Miss Kitty Kat as a family cat but I don’t really think that’s fair on DD, her and the cat have a bond and she sleeps in her room ect. So even if we could make her a family cat, it would be in name only.

My idea is to get DS a smaller pet, he loves bugs so I was thinking a pray mantis or something like that. I would need to do more research and find something appropriate for him, and he would definitely need support taking care of any animals, but that’s fine. The issue with this is whatever small pet he has would need to be in his room preferably or somewhere Miss Kitty couldn’t get at it - because she would eat it.

Honestly I didn’t really see this coming but I feel like I probably should have - one child having a pet of course the other one will be jealous! I’m just glad DD2 is too little to get in on this.

YBU - rebrand Miss Kitty Kat as a family cat
YNBU - consider getting DS a smaller pet of his own (if you have any suggestions I would love to hear them).

Any alternative ideas welcome as well I’m in a pickle with this

OP posts:
WelcometomyUnderworld · 01/02/2026 14:43

If it’s your daughter’s cat, would she be the one deciding when to put it down if it took ill next month? Is she one who researches the right insurance, takes it to the vet, arranges its vaccinations, buys its food?

If your DS prefers his Dad to you does he cease to be your son? And then Dad has to take on all the care to the exclusion of you?

You are a family, and anything living in your house is part of that family. The cat belongs to your DS as much as it belongs to your DD and as much as your DH belongs to you. It’s silly you ever branded the cat any other way.

If there is more room in your family for another living creature, then by all means add another. But if it’s just to be “fair” to someone who was recently a toddler, it feels like a silly move.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page