Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to take the cat back?

30 replies

SummerBreeze1980 · 28/01/2026 21:05

I'm writing this on behalf of a friend.

My friend through no fault of her own was made homeless by a private landlord. She was moved into a homeless shelter with her 2 children. She could not take her pets. Through work, a colleague suggested an older lady who would care for her cat until she could have him back.

After a year they were moved to a temporary flat which also does not allow her to have her pets. She has now been there a year. So the cat has lived with the lady for 2 years. During this time my friend has provided all his food/treats/flea and worming treatment and taken him to the vets when necessary and paid. She visits him weekly with her daughter.

The issue is that the lady has of course got very attached to the cat and likes to treat him with food. She buys him wet food pouches and gives him a lot of not particularly healthy treats. The cat is now very overweight, has health problems and does not go outside. My friend has tried to kindly and gently address this with the lady while being incredibly grateful that she took the cat in and she knows the lady is not doing this out of malice, but just because she loves the cat.

She took the cat to the vet recently and they have said he is severely overweight. He weights double what he should. He can't groom himself properly and damage has been caused to his joints and fur. His teeth are also in a bad state as the lady has stopped giving him the dry food my friend supplies as naturally the cat holds out for the wet pouches and other treats.

My friend is at a loss as to what to do next. She is considering bringing the cat to her flat as he doesn't go outside now, even though this is against the rules and it is unlikely she will have a permanent home anytime soon. However, she knows the lady is very attached to the cat and would probably be lonely without him.

If anyone could give any advice as to how to deal with this it would be much appreciated.

OP posts:
Contrarymary30 · 29/01/2026 17:40

The cat is getting both.. dry from the ops friend and wet from the elderly lady . Being overweight is better than being traumatised by being given to a shelter .

SummerBreeze1980 · 29/01/2026 17:48

EvangelineTheNightStar · 29/01/2026 16:16

Is your friend paying the woman anything for the catsitting? She has now been there a year. So the cat has lived with the lady for 2 years. During this time my friend has provided all his food/treats/flea and worming treatment and taken him to the vets when necessary and paid. well she should shouldn’t she? It’s her cat!

Yes, of course she should. I just wrote it out to be clear about the situation. This was why I said I didn't think it was fair to just relinquish the cat as some have suggested. No, she is not paying her for cat sitting. The lady was happy with the arrangement and offered to look after him. As I said I think she was lonely so the chance to have a cat with all expenses paid appealed to her.

OP posts:
SummerBreeze1980 · 29/01/2026 17:50

BadgernTheGarden · 29/01/2026 16:30

So I assume the owner is no longer buying food or treats? I don't think wet food pouches are intrinsically particularly bad, what brand is it?

She has been but now the lady has said she isn't giving it to the cat anymore and has 4 unopened bags she won't buy anymore for the mean time.

OP posts:
SummerBreeze1980 · 29/01/2026 17:51

Contrarymary30 · 29/01/2026 17:40

The cat is getting both.. dry from the ops friend and wet from the elderly lady . Being overweight is better than being traumatised by being given to a shelter .

The lady isn't giving the cat the dry food anymore.

OP posts:
SummerBreeze1980 · 29/01/2026 17:52

BadgernTheGarden · 29/01/2026 16:30

So I assume the owner is no longer buying food or treats? I don't think wet food pouches are intrinsically particularly bad, what brand is it?

Sorry, it is the cheap pouches which contain very little meat. They are not good for the cat as their main diet.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread