Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you be a magistrate?

217 replies

Netcurtainnelly · 03/01/2026 15:03

There's a big volunteer recruitment drive for magistrates at the moment?
Does it interest you?

OP posts:
NewWinger · 03/01/2026 23:57

Netcurtainnelly · 03/01/2026 21:06

Did you have to visit a prison?

I did, yes.

I’d done a couple of years there as a volunteer some 4-5 years earlier; at that time it was run down and quite grim, but was so much improved those few years later. I still wouldn’t want to end up there, but it’s useful to see, as we can send people to custody.

ResusciAnnie · 04/01/2026 00:03

FIL was one and he’s one of those awful self-appointed ‘pillar of the community’ types so on the basis that it attracts that sort of people, no I couldn’t face it!

BoredZelda · 04/01/2026 00:07

MsFogi · 03/01/2026 16:05

I just don’t understand why people are expected to work for free in crucial roles such as magistrates, school governors etc

Me neither.

FoxtrotSkarloey · 04/01/2026 00:13

I’d be very interested in doing this but based on what I’ve read, I couldn’t afford to plus because my Dad worked overseas his company paid for private education. So I’m not really that “type” but on paper I am. Never mind.

Onemorechristmas · 04/01/2026 07:40

Squirrelchops1 · 03/01/2026 16:32

Magistrates do have a legal advisor at all times...when you're in court.
If you sit in family court you get the bundle to read about 48 hours ahead of the hearing.
There are various different strands within criminal so I'm not sure if there are any specific courts where they might get papers ahead of time too.

Is it not really upsetting, sitting as a family magistrate? I imagine lots of badly treated children being removed from parents and put into care

GettingGo · 04/01/2026 08:18

Whats the minimum age? 18? Can a year 13 do it?

HighStreetOtter · 04/01/2026 08:22

I’d be interested for sure.

Simonjt · 04/01/2026 08:29

tsmainsqueeze · 03/01/2026 16:02

No i would not do it .
I have known 2 women - unconnected, who were magistrates and they were two of the vilest people you could ever meet and not that intelligent either , actually just thought of a 3rd nicer but not someone i would want judging me.
I think a certain type of 'self important ' people are attracted to this role ,not the kind of group i would want to be part of.

We had an awful neighbour growing up who was a magistrate, he was also the headteacher of a local school. He was an incredible snob who regularly complained about having to live next to a brown family. He was found to have stolen thousands of pounds of public funds and lied about his son being a heroin addict and a criminal (exposing himself to children) to give him a job. It was extremely satisfying when he was charged as people had been reporting him for years.

Interestingly not a single press report mentions his role as a magistrate, nice bit of supression in the press.

Itsmetheflamingo · 04/01/2026 08:33

Onemorechristmas · 04/01/2026 07:40

Is it not really upsetting, sitting as a family magistrate? I imagine lots of badly treated children being removed from parents and put into care

But that’s an important job that someone has to do.

Squirrelchops1 · 04/01/2026 08:42

Onemorechristmas · 04/01/2026 07:40

Is it not really upsetting, sitting as a family magistrate? I imagine lots of badly treated children being removed from parents and put into care

We don't sit on many public law cases, in fact hardly ever and I've never known magistrates do a final hearing of this sort, so no, it's not an issue. Care proceedings get pushed up to a Judge.

We sometimes sit on Special Guardianship applications but they're usually uncontested so parents are agreeing with the guardian looking after their child/ren.

What's more heartbreaking is parents who cannot put their own stuff aside to focus on the needs of their child. They can be so wrapped up in 'winning' over what is best for the child.

IfIwasabluebird · 04/01/2026 08:47

kitt I wonder how UC would deal with it. Would a benefit recipient be penalised for earning less money on those days? I'm almost tempted to give it a go to give them a headache calculating it.

Ineffable23 · 04/01/2026 09:31

ResusciAnnie · 04/01/2026 00:03

FIL was one and he’s one of those awful self-appointed ‘pillar of the community’ types so on the basis that it attracts that sort of people, no I couldn’t face it!

But isn't this even more of a reason to do it? If you think the wrong sorts of people are in these roles, surely that makes it even more important to try and get a wider range of people to take these roles on?

Newnameonthisthread · 04/01/2026 09:38

AmberSpy · 03/01/2026 16:28

That's interesting - I thought magistrates had a legal adviser at all times, is there still significant preparation and research needed on top of that?

I’m a crime magistrate. There absolutely no prep time required, very little small print and I’ve never had to refer back to law.

Newnameonthisthread · 04/01/2026 09:43

Itsmetheflamingo · 03/01/2026 22:22

Yes I would love to. But I have a job, so not yet

I do it alongside a full time, intense job. It’s very doable, and your employer has to give you time off.

Kendodd · 04/01/2026 09:45

InTheNotswolds · 03/01/2026 15:44

I wanted to some years ago but was told that my colour, accent and education ruled me out. Shame really.

Who told you that?
And what colour and accent is ruled out?

GCSEBiostruggles · 04/01/2026 09:45

I heard about this on Womans Hour last month. Logged in and no vacancies in the entire of Kent but a couple up near Manchester and Birmingham. They need to sort their website out.

Newnameonthisthread · 04/01/2026 09:45

PixellatedPixie · 03/01/2026 16:48

I have very seriously considered this role as I am keen and have time to volunteer and I have a UK law degree. I didnt ever complete a training contract so I’m not a solicitor but I did very well in my degree and love law. I’m white but not British - (South African), under 45 and did not go to private school.

The only thing that has put me off is that I have wondered if it is dangerous and negative. I can cope with dealing with the darker elements of life but worry it’s a depressing job.

I’ve never once felt in danger as a crime magistrate for what it’s worth.

YearoftheHorse60 · 04/01/2026 09:46

Do you have a link to your old AMA that we can read through, @NewWinger ? I'm interested.

MaarvaCarassi · 04/01/2026 09:57

What’s the thinking behind this being a voluntary role, rather than a paid role? I suppose I’m
thinking that this immediately skews the volunteer population.

ohfook · 04/01/2026 10:00

Springonway1 · 03/01/2026 15:16

There was an article about this last year. They are looking for people of colour, people under the age of 50, people who are in "blue collar jobs" ie not white collar, people who are disabled. No private school. If you don't tick any of those boxes don't bother applying.

Such a shame as (for example) its people who may have retired at 55 or 60 that have the free time to be magistrates as their kids may have all grown up.

An acquaintance of mine is a magistrate. My understanding is the majority are either retired or have a wife to pick up the slack because of the time it consumes. I don’t think it’s massively suited to working parents with young families which will obviously rule out a lot of people they’re hoping to recruit.

GCSEBiostruggles · 04/01/2026 10:11

Springonway1 · 03/01/2026 15:16

There was an article about this last year. They are looking for people of colour, people under the age of 50, people who are in "blue collar jobs" ie not white collar, people who are disabled. No private school. If you don't tick any of those boxes don't bother applying.

Such a shame as (for example) its people who may have retired at 55 or 60 that have the free time to be magistrates as their kids may have all grown up.

Ah that rules me out then - private school.
Funny though as I imagine we are the largest group of available women in the age range not having to work, that could afford to give the time...

MaarvaCarassi · 04/01/2026 10:35

GCSEBiostruggles · 04/01/2026 10:11

Ah that rules me out then - private school.
Funny though as I imagine we are the largest group of available women in the age range not having to work, that could afford to give the time...

Edited

I think the poster said it was ticking one of the boxes that rules you in, rather than the opposite.

GCSEBiostruggles · 04/01/2026 10:47

MaarvaCarassi · 04/01/2026 10:35

I think the poster said it was ticking one of the boxes that rules you in, rather than the opposite.

Edited

"No private school."
I think that means no private school, given the context of blue collar workers only etc?

Either way the website says all of Kent and South East are fine and don't need any so it is area specific where they have shortages.

NewWinger · 04/01/2026 10:51

YearoftheHorse60 · 04/01/2026 09:46

Do you have a link to your old AMA that we can read through, @NewWinger ? I'm interested.

Here you go, @YearoftheHorse60 - but just to say I was quite inexperienced then. I think most of the answers are still okay, but I perhaps answer a couple differently with more experience.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/AMA/4653590-new-magistrate-ama?page=1

Swipe left for the next trending thread