Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family discussion on parenting has me totally confused

27 replies

OrangeChips1 · 26/12/2025 08:49

A and B are siblings
C is married to B

A&Bs parents were fairly strict around things like sugar, crisps, screen time.

C really appreciates the impact this has had on B.
C had completely unrestricted access to sweets, crisps, screens etc and when he was older alcohol too.
He thinks this makes it much harder for him to regulate as an adult, his nervous system being used to and looking for the "highs".
C wishes he'd had more boundaries as a child like B did.

But speaking to A, it turns out the same parenting had the opposite impact, and when A became an adult he overindulged in sugary drinks, computer games etc until he realised for himself 10-15 years later the impact it was having on his health.

B didn't ever feel overly restricted and understood the reasons why the rules were in place, and was never particularly bothered by sweets/screens etc as an adult, but clearly A did feel overly restricted and rebelled.

It just made me totally confused about what the right thing to do is as parents! Ultimately made me realise that no matter how we are parented, there are some things that we just need to take responsibility for as adults and on the flip side we can't look to our parenting as a way of trying to mitigate every pain point or self reflection a child might have to do in the future. It made all the thinking we did around sleep training vs co sleeping , nursery vs SAHM etc etc seem a bit pointless, and ultimately "we probably messed something up so here are some skills on how to find resources to help yourself" is the most helpful thing.

OP posts:
OrangeChips1 · 26/12/2025 21:21

Nucleus · 26/12/2025 14:38

I had 'the same' upbringing as my siblings. In reality, it was very different. My father viewed me as my mother's responsibility and was only interested in my brothers, but it was never in your face obvious. For example, he privately educated my brothers; my maternal grandmother paid for mine. So on the face of it, we got the same, but in reality we didn't.

Even in death he is still dividing us - bequests to my brothers, but the things he has left for me were not his to give; they are mum's so I will get nothing unless she chooses to give me anything.

My brothers see him as having been a kind and benevolent father/grandfather and cannot recognise how different my experience of superficially identical parenting has been.

Where one sits in the birth order, and the sexes of children also impacts regardless of whether one of your parents is an arsehole or not.

Gosh yes that's definitely going to bring different results as the children will feel completely different about their childhood!

OP posts:
SarahAndQuack · 26/12/2025 21:22

OrangeChips1 · 26/12/2025 21:19

That's a good point re example! A and Bs parents are regulated themselves, they can receive a box of chocolates and it's still sitting there uneaten 6 months later! But there is a lot of trauma in the family in general which may play a part in the binging as @mindutopia mentioned

I wonder how helpful the term 'regulated' is here?

My mum has no sweet tooth. Just doesn't. She was also very against us having sweets as children.

I would not conclude she is a 'regulated' person: it's simply that she actually doesn't want this stuff. She'd have a box of chocolates unopened for years, because while she'll eat one on occasion, they're not really her thing.

A parent who imposes their preferences on a child and dresses them up as morally desirable forms of restraint isn't teaching that child to be 'regulated'. They're just being weird.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread