Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 year old DD wants to live with his dad

12 replies

Juke90 · 08/12/2025 20:47

So, out of nowhere tonight my son is demanding to live with his dad and he said he hates me. My children see their dad every other weekend and this weekend has been particularly fun I think, I can’t afford to do the things that he does with them as I have them most of the time. Part of me is glad that he loves his dad and part of me is wondering what I am doing wrong?

OP posts:
Sillysoggyspaniel · 08/12/2025 20:53

He's five, and fun things are fun. You're not doing anything wrong. I'd just empathise and get him to write down things he wants to do with his dad when he sees them so that he has his thoughts and plans ready - like when they want a toy in the shop and you say to take a photo for their Xmas ideas list.

Endofyear · 08/12/2025 22:23

I know it's hurtful but you're not doing anything wrong. It sounds like your little one misses his dad, every other weekend is not very often. Could you talk to your ex about maybe seeing the kids a bit more? Don't take him saying he hates you to heart - he doesn't. He's probably tired out after a busy weekend and confused and upset at his own big feelings that he's too little to articulate properly.

JoannaTheYodelingCowgirl · 08/12/2025 22:48

YANBU youre not doing anything wrong
Perhaps your ex is a soft touch/the 'fun' parent who lets him get away with everything but youre the one who does the parenting

If you two are amicable, make sure youre on the same page when it comes to boundaries and parenting

BulliedSS · 08/12/2025 22:49

Does his dad want to have him more?

CinnamonBuns67 · 09/12/2025 09:31

Probably more of a simple case of the child wants to see their Dad more which is normal. EOW isn't much and whilst I can definitely appreciate there's circumstances where more is not possible. If theres a way that Dad can have the child more then that should be seriously considered and spoken about between you and your ex.

Juke90 · 09/12/2025 09:43

We are not on good terms at all. He introduced another woman really quickly and it has just been a constant battle to be honest. We can’t communicate as he has blocked my number. He knows that he can see them whenever he likes though

OP posts:
BulliedSS · 09/12/2025 09:49

JoannaTheYodelingCowgirl · 08/12/2025 22:48

YANBU youre not doing anything wrong
Perhaps your ex is a soft touch/the 'fun' parent who lets him get away with everything but youre the one who does the parenting

If you two are amicable, make sure youre on the same page when it comes to boundaries and parenting

Or maybe things are more structured and financially secure at Dad’s? We don’t know.

OP if you can’t communicate with your ex, there’s not much you can do but reassure your son and tell him you’re happy for him to see his dad more. It must be hard for you and I’m sure you’re doing nothing wrong.

Juke90 · 09/12/2025 09:53

His dad lives in a 1 bedroom flat and they sleep on airbeds. Yes he takes them for fun days out but I deal with all the other side of it.

OP posts:
MumbleBumbleAppleCrumble · 09/12/2025 11:11

When my parents divorced, Mum had me the majority of the week - music practice, after school activities, the majority of home work - Dad had me one week night, every Friday night, and every other weekend. It was fun at Dad’s we did fun things and he treated me. I loved him totally and he was a great Dad (and did do proper parenting) but it was probably closer to going to the grandparents than the real realities of being parented. So my poor mother took the brunt of the crap bits - making me do homework and practice things and go to school.

Added to that, deep down I felt like Dad had abandoned me. I imagine, however good parents are at managing separation, this always happens. So there was always a part of me who thought he might do it fully. Especially when he remarried and they started talking about starting a family. I felt like the forgotten one. (And, I say again that this was the case even though he was pretty wonderful as a Dad and talked to me, was a constant presence, made me feel always wanted).

Mum got the hard reality. The upset and the anger. But it wasn’t that I wanted to attack her, it was because I was a child and I was terrified. And, because it was so desperately hard for her, I also got her anger too. It must have been so hard for her. But, a child can never know. It often takes until their twenties after all for a child to really appreciate that parents are people with feelings and lives and desires and emotions. Children are wholly selfish, even the most caring and lovely ones. The universe revolves around them.

And too, children love treats and glamour and fun. To this day I still feel incredibly guilty that, when I was about five, I told my local grandparents that for the holidays I was going to visit my ‘favourite’ grandparents. They were my favourites because they spoiled me. My other grandparents were my constant, they supported me, and helped raise me really. But they were, in their constancy, less glamorous and fun. I spent years trying to make up for that. And they knew how much I adored them, but I still hate that five year old me did that.

Not advice I’m afraid. Just some sympathy to you and my memory of being a child through a similar situation. It must be so very hard.

StruggleFlourish · 09/12/2025 12:08

Juke90 · 09/12/2025 09:43

We are not on good terms at all. He introduced another woman really quickly and it has just been a constant battle to be honest. We can’t communicate as he has blocked my number. He knows that he can see them whenever he likes though

You can't communicate because your ex-husband has blocked your number. But, he knows he can see him at any time. The man knows he can see the sun at any time or the sun knows that he can see the father anytime? (Sounds like the man is holding all the cards here.) when you're co-parenting, and you're arranging drops off some pickups and other things, it doesn't make sense to me to have your number blocked.
No communication? Yes, but in this case, makes no sense at all. What if there was an emergency?

Dad gets to play the fun parent. You only season every other weekend, they get to sleep on blow up air mattresses which at 5
seems fun And they probably have different food and go out and do different things. So yeah, at that age, you got one parent who is the stable one who makes sure that you have bath and proper bedtime and eat your vegetables and clean your room and put away your toys and say please and thank you and you have the other one will let you do whatever you want.

You would hate to lose primary custody of your son but if he did go live with his dad, very soon, sleeping on the floor on an air mattress would get tired and more than likely the man would not be able to successfully parent your child anyway, he said that he has another partner? They'd get tired of this really quick. And your son would realize pretty fast that he did not have the love support stability and life that he had with you even if you can't always be the fun parent.

I know the statement hurts, but you do know that your ex-husband is shamelessly just trying to buy your son's affection by showing that he's more fun because he doesn't have to shoulder the responsibility of care. Anybody can be fun fun fun when you're 5 years old and you only see them every other weekend.

Juke90 · 09/12/2025 17:21

StruggleFlourish · 09/12/2025 12:08

You can't communicate because your ex-husband has blocked your number. But, he knows he can see him at any time. The man knows he can see the sun at any time or the sun knows that he can see the father anytime? (Sounds like the man is holding all the cards here.) when you're co-parenting, and you're arranging drops off some pickups and other things, it doesn't make sense to me to have your number blocked.
No communication? Yes, but in this case, makes no sense at all. What if there was an emergency?

Dad gets to play the fun parent. You only season every other weekend, they get to sleep on blow up air mattresses which at 5
seems fun And they probably have different food and go out and do different things. So yeah, at that age, you got one parent who is the stable one who makes sure that you have bath and proper bedtime and eat your vegetables and clean your room and put away your toys and say please and thank you and you have the other one will let you do whatever you want.

You would hate to lose primary custody of your son but if he did go live with his dad, very soon, sleeping on the floor on an air mattress would get tired and more than likely the man would not be able to successfully parent your child anyway, he said that he has another partner? They'd get tired of this really quick. And your son would realize pretty fast that he did not have the love support stability and life that he had with you even if you can't always be the fun parent.

I know the statement hurts, but you do know that your ex-husband is shamelessly just trying to buy your son's affection by showing that he's more fun because he doesn't have to shoulder the responsibility of care. Anybody can be fun fun fun when you're 5 years old and you only see them every other weekend.

I know ex loved it this evening when my son asked him if he could live with him, he just said we will speak about it next week. My 8 year old is completely different she is fed up of his new gf being there and said he cares more about her than them. It’s hard not to take it personally but I know I shouldn’t

OP posts:
Haveyouanyjam · 09/12/2025 22:53

Myself and my husband are still ‘together’ but live separately. I’m the main and default parent and my DD4 prefers me for nearly everything. But she will still say occasionally she wants to live with her dad. She cries when she is apart from me and I know it’s not true, it’s just her trying to exert control and also expressing the love she has for her dad. They are little, trying to make sense of a complicated situation. Don’t take it personallyZ

Also, it’s easy to be the fun parent. If your DS loves you despite you having to do all the boring day to day stuff, you know it’s you he loves and not the stuff.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page