Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this at least in part is in response to my weight loss

55 replies

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:22

Hi. So my dsis is having a tummy tuck/liposuction abroad next week and I can’t help but feel that partly this is due to the positive response (from others) that I’ve had with regards to my own weight loss. I know that might sound crazy and that I’m self absorbed but let me explain.

Ok so my sister is 5 years older and although we get on for the most part and we have a laugh when we get together she can be difficult to as she is clearly competitive despite trying her best to hide it. I am not in the least bit competitive and I have never gone out of my way to make her feel inferior in fact I am the one with anxiety, low self esteem and struggle to see my self worth so she really has nothing to worry about.

Anyway back on point. Like I said she’s always been competitive when it comes to various things and one of those things sadly is weight. We have both yo-yo’d with our weight throughout the years but I was always the bigger one until now. I however finally got my act together when I turned 40 and in the 18 months since I quiet smoking, went back to work and lost 7st in weight. All massive and what I thought to be positive changes. Dsis seemed fine with my weight loss until I got to a certain size and she realised I had lost a fair amount and then she started with the comments. Off the top of my head she has said things such as “oh you look incredibly drawn in your face so don’t lose anymore” “your legs really are like twigs” “you really need to eat more” then she’s asked me multiple times how much I weigh, asked me what size clothes I’m in and then scoffed like she didn’t believe me, and when I (stupidly) told her once how much I weighed she said not a chance you look so much smaller than that and tried to convince me to jump on her bathroom scales!

There are many more comments that I’ve endured but I can’t remember most of them but I do remember feeling upset and once she even made me cry once I got home. At one point I stopped making as much effort to see her as I couldn’t be doing with all the questions and comments about my weight. I didn’t see her for a few weeks and I thought nah don’t be silly she’s my dsis so I went round to her house for a cuppa and I was barely through the door before she told me that she’d booked this surgery abroad. I honestly didn’t know what to think but then later thought you know what you’re crazy. Usually I don’t judge what others do and won’t offer an opinion unless it’s asked for but wow just wow.

She is the type of person who will never be happy with what she sees in the mirror so it’s a completely pointless surgery. I doubt I’ll ever be 100% happy with my body even though I’m slimmer but you know what that’s fine. I‘m fitter from exercising and in general my health has improved and I don’t feel the need to put myself through voluntary surgeries. I know people are different and they can do whatever they chose but still I can’t help but think my dsis would benefit more from spending her money on therapy to address her body/confidence issues than on a potentially dangerous and unnecessary surgery.

And what’s more she’s going abroad completely on her own. I can’t go with her as I have work and dc to care for but to be fair I wouldn’t want to go even if I could. She’s going to be an absolute nightmare to care for afterwards but she has her dh for that. Christmas week though however when we all get together her new body is all I will hear about! Oh and just to add icing onto the cake she decided not to tell our parents about her surgery and has lied to them telling them she’s going on holiday to Spain for the week. What’s worse is she’s sworn me to secrecy too! I mean I know it’s not place to tell anyone and I won’t but come Christmas when my dsis is (somewhat) up on her feet again and she decides to share her “secret” with our Dp’s their next question they’ll ask after asking my dsis if she’s gone mad (I can hear my df now) is did I know about this, and what do I say, no?

OP posts:
FuzzyWolf · 01/12/2025 19:27

Nobody on here will know why she is doing it. You’ve obviously written it with a bias slant to support your theory but it might not have anything to do with you.

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:32

I’ve not written it with bias at all. Everything I wrote in my post is factual as in it actually happened. Like I said i usually don’t care what people do. My SiL had a breast lift and reduction a couple of years ago and my friend has a tummy tuck and repair as she had c-sections with big babies and muscle damage. I didn’t give two hoots as it was their choice like it is my dsis’s choice except she is the only one who has made me feel sh*t about my weight loss and overall health improvement. So yes it does make me wonder if her choice to have surgery is partly to do with the fact she’s jealous of my progress.

OP posts:
Thinkingaloud85 · 01/12/2025 19:36

I think she might not be the only competitive one…

Newsenmum · 01/12/2025 19:36

Almost definitely but I suppose does jt matter? Getting that kind of surgery is a big
risk especoally abroad. How did you lose the weight? Has she tried the injections? She doesnt sound particularly nice tbh.

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:39

How am I being competitive? I decided almost two years ago due to being told I was pre diabetic to turn my life around. I’ve done that slowly but surely at a pace i was comfortable with and thanks to that I have no loose skin and I’m far fitter than I used to be and can run around after my kids more and do things I just couldn’t manage well previously. I’m happy with my own progress and proud of my achievements.

OP posts:
Applespearsandpeaches · 01/12/2025 19:40

Does it matter? For someone who claims not to be competitive you seem very invested in her decisions. You sure you aren’t enjoying the attention and “beating” her at something? You sound a bit cross she might get slim but won’t have put the work in that you think you have.

She’s a grown adult, she’s allowed to decide to get surgery. Personally I think cosmetic surgery abroad is an absolute minefield, but she’s allowed to make unwise choices for whatever reason she likes, even stupid ones like being jealous of you. If you’re so unbothered about being competitive then just wish her well and concentrate on yourself. If she comments on your body just tell her she’s being rude and you don’t want to hear it.

Thinkingaloud85 · 01/12/2025 19:42

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:39

How am I being competitive? I decided almost two years ago due to being told I was pre diabetic to turn my life around. I’ve done that slowly but surely at a pace i was comfortable with and thanks to that I have no loose skin and I’m far fitter than I used to be and can run around after my kids more and do things I just couldn’t manage well previously. I’m happy with my own progress and proud of my achievements.

Because you have just made a post all about how you think your sister is only getting weight loss surgery because you are now thinner than she is.

So what if she is? Why does it matter?
You, as you have just outlined, are very happy with your weight loss and current shape. So just be happy, not dwelling on your sister’s choices.

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:42

I lost it simply by eating sensibly, by not restricting anything but eating in moderation. I joined the gym any dh already attended and he helped me with training and encouraged me to go with him early morning before work. I have tried and failed before at diets as I cut everything out and essentially felt like I was punishing myself. It’s taken me 40 years but I finally learned that lesson and went easier on myself which has obviously worked so I’m happy.

OP posts:
bevelino · 01/12/2025 19:43

Thinkingaloud85 · 01/12/2025 19:36

I think she might not be the only competitive one…

This

Newsenmum · 01/12/2025 19:43

So what is your concern/reason for this thread? Are you worried by her choices?

MrsPrendergast · 01/12/2025 19:43

Dear me. You really don't like your sister do you? And yes, you DO seem very competitive

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:43

It matters to me because I feel it’s a drastic and impulsive decision plus believe it or not it does worry me that she is putting herself through what can be a risky surgery made even more risky by getting it done abroad. I mean why not spend the extra few grand and have it done in this country where it’s much safer.

OP posts:
DarkSunrise · 01/12/2025 19:44

Ok, you realise that this is absolutely none of your business?

Fair enough if she was asking you to care for her, but she has a DH so not your circus not your monkeys.

It’s her body and her money, it doesn’t matter if it’s a mistake - it’s her mistake and nothing at all to do with you.

If your parents ask if you knew you say “yes, she asked me not to discuss it and I respected her wishes”.

She of course shouldn’t be making rude comments about your weight loss but really the best way to deal with that is to say “I’m very happy with how I look” <big smile> and walk away. Her issues are hers and nothing to do with you.

If she wants compliments post op for goodness sake give them to her - what does it cost you?

Time to be a grown up.

BurnoutGP · 01/12/2025 19:45

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:32

I’ve not written it with bias at all. Everything I wrote in my post is factual as in it actually happened. Like I said i usually don’t care what people do. My SiL had a breast lift and reduction a couple of years ago and my friend has a tummy tuck and repair as she had c-sections with big babies and muscle damage. I didn’t give two hoots as it was their choice like it is my dsis’s choice except she is the only one who has made me feel sh*t about my weight loss and overall health improvement. So yes it does make me wonder if her choice to have surgery is partly to do with the fact she’s jealous of my progress.

You obviously care a lot about what other people do

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:45

Honest answer, I love my sister but I don’t always like or agree with the way she behaves especially when previously she has gone out of her way to make borderline nasty comments and made me doubt myself.

OP posts:
lljkk · 01/12/2025 19:46

If OP is directly asked "did you know about this" then OP shouldn't be asked to lie about having knowledge. All the rest reads like so much drama...

Anywherebuthere · 01/12/2025 19:46

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:32

I’ve not written it with bias at all. Everything I wrote in my post is factual as in it actually happened. Like I said i usually don’t care what people do. My SiL had a breast lift and reduction a couple of years ago and my friend has a tummy tuck and repair as she had c-sections with big babies and muscle damage. I didn’t give two hoots as it was their choice like it is my dsis’s choice except she is the only one who has made me feel sh*t about my weight loss and overall health improvement. So yes it does make me wonder if her choice to have surgery is partly to do with the fact she’s jealous of my progress.

It's also possible it's nothing to do with you and she's realised she needs to do something for herself.

I know someone who sounds like you. She's done well to lose weight and getting healthy. But she now seems to think everyone else is in competition with her, she just seems to want the attention on herself all the time. She doesn't accept that people and their choices don't revolve around her.

SpectacularlyLost · 01/12/2025 19:46

It seems you are holding some resentment there. Maybe better for you to reset and refocus on yourself, on sll you have schieved and will achieve. Her actions and what she thinks are not under your control, so maybe healthy to try not take it personal. Do your thing and let her do hers. She is abviously affected by your change, bt has not been very supportive it seems. The way her words resonated with you seems you value what she thinks, but why should you? It's just her opinion, not the truth. Let go, be happy for her and go hit the gym. Life's too short for this shit my friend

PatThePenguin · 01/12/2025 19:47

FuzzyWolf · 01/12/2025 19:27

Nobody on here will know why she is doing it. You’ve obviously written it with a bias slant to support your theory but it might not have anything to do with you.

Bias?

The OP has given herself an absolute SAINTHOOD! 🤣🤣

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:48

I have been the grown up and the better person throughout all her negative and unwanted comments. I’ve brushed them off, tried to change the subject when she insists on asking more questions about my weight. I distanced myself from her for a while as I was getting fed up of the comments and she didn’t message me once. It’s is usually me that makes the effort so when I do go the extra mile to make the effort and then all she does is comment negatively about my weight loss well it stings a bit.

OP posts:
Thinkingaloud85 · 01/12/2025 19:49

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:43

It matters to me because I feel it’s a drastic and impulsive decision plus believe it or not it does worry me that she is putting herself through what can be a risky surgery made even more risky by getting it done abroad. I mean why not spend the extra few grand and have it done in this country where it’s much safer.

So why is your post all about you and your weight then?

You didn’t ask: ‘Help me to discuss weight loss surgery with my sister’.

Instead you said: ‘My sister only wants lipo because I’m thinner than she is, and this is how I did it and I’m so happy and proud of myself’.

Dutchhouse14 · 01/12/2025 19:51

Ok so her insecurities may well have been triggerred by your weight loss, new job and stopping smoking. Those are huge achievements - congratulations!
Her comments weren't kind.
But I do think you are also being judgemental perhaps a bit unsupportive.
I do think someone needs to go with her .A friend of mine went to Turkey for cosmetic surgery and I thought she was mad but she'd done the research found an excellent surgeon and the
results were amazing .
But the recovery was long and painful,she was discharged to a hotel room pretty quickly,needed regular lymphatic drainage , whilst in Turkey hospital arranged someone to visit her in the hotel to do this but she needed to source someone at home and recovery was hard and painful,it went well but she was in a lot of pain whilst recovering .
So your sister will need support.

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:52

@Anywherebuthere Honestly nothing could be father from the truth. In real life as in face to face with friends and family I don’t bring my weight up unless they do and to be honest I’d rather they didn’t bring it up as i don’t feel comfortable and would rather not discuss it. My dsis knows this yes she has pushed and pushed me in the past. As an introverted quiet person the last thing I want is to be noticed believe me. I just want a quiet life and not be made to feel like my own dsis is in constant competition with me.

OP posts:
WhereIsMyLight · 01/12/2025 20:00

Maybe she has done this because she’s envious of the attention you’re getting. Maybe she hasn’t. What is clear is you both have issues around your body. This means you are both likely to be projecting your own insecurities onto the other person and you are both sensitive to comments/actions of others. Maybe the comments were determined to hurt you, maybe the comments were a result of your sister’s insecurities. It doesn’t matter.

Let your sister live her life. You live yours. You work on being happy in yourself. If your sister says something you don’t like, say you find that language hard to deal with at the moment and it’s not putting you in a good space. If she then continues, then yes she’s an arsehole.

Applespearsandpeaches · 01/12/2025 20:01

Tulloch · 01/12/2025 19:52

@Anywherebuthere Honestly nothing could be father from the truth. In real life as in face to face with friends and family I don’t bring my weight up unless they do and to be honest I’d rather they didn’t bring it up as i don’t feel comfortable and would rather not discuss it. My dsis knows this yes she has pushed and pushed me in the past. As an introverted quiet person the last thing I want is to be noticed believe me. I just want a quiet life and not be made to feel like my own dsis is in constant competition with me.

So don’t be in competition with her. You can’t compete against people who aren’t competing.

Honestly you just sound pissed off you’ve been a good girl and lost weight the way you perceive to be “the right way” and you think she’s cheating or getting one over on you by going for the “easy” option. But it’s really up to her - if she’s happy with the risk and expense she’s taking then who are you to say your way is the only way?

You sure you’re not upset she might end up slimmer or or get more attention than you? Because I really can’t understand why else you’ve made her surgery all about you.