Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give DD more independence?

45 replies

Kimchi55 · 30/11/2025 18:23

DD is 9 (10 in 2 months time) and she has started not wanting to pop out to the shop with me if we need the odd thing, or if I need to put a load of washing on at the launderette (launderette is across the road, you can see it from our window, and the shop is on the corner of the road).

I've allowed her to stay at home recently, and she has a way of contacting me if need be, although she often stays doing whatever it is she was doing when I left - a few times she has video called or text me while I'm there (nothing wrong, just wanted to) but not every time.

She's happy and comfortable with this and it was her pushing for it.

I timed myself on my phone a few times and the shop trip takes an average 7-10 mins, so not long at all. Launderette is similar as I go and put the wash on and then I'm back home until it's time to bring stuff back to dry/put stuff in tumble drier etc. She was always moaning about having to go there and back and back again and back again with me!

Anyway, my ex her dad, who barely sees her, has got wind that I've been doing this and has kicked off at me. He says I'm a neglectful parent who is putting his daughter at risk and I clearly don't care about her safety and should be reported to social services etc.

I pointed out that her school (5 mins walk away), actually allow the Year 5/Year 6 children to walk to and from school on their own. DD doesn't yet, I usually let her walk ahead of me and walk behind right now, unless she sees a friend up ahead on the way then she runs up to them and off they go. It's 0.2 miles!

She went to a friend's house after school and said friend lives a few houses up the road of the school and walks home alone, so DD walked with her to her house.

Anyway, he's basically said that only parents who don't care about their children let them do that and any decent parent would be walking them to school or driving them.

My argument is that in Year 7 the majority of children won't be wanting their parents walking them or getting the bus anymore and they need to build up some responsibility, trust, and independence over the coming years rather than being thrown in at the deep end. He basically said that even in secondary school they should be getting picked up by parents.

He's then gone on to say that I'm putting her in danger and the country isn't safe for her (I believe he's fallen into dangerous territory here as his words are "aren't safe for white women and girls"!!) and that if anything happens to DD because I left her alone at all then he will "avenge her" and "happily sleep on a blue mat for the rest of his life" - this is a threat to kill, no? It isn't the first time he's said he'll spend the rest of his life in prison if anything happens to her in my care.

So, AIBU in leaving her alone for 10 mins or in believing in fostering independence as they move up towards secondary?

And... What am I supposed to do about her dad?

OP posts:
Overnightoats1 · 01/12/2025 17:56

I have a very sensible 9 year old who I leave at home for 10/15 mins while dropping his brother at the bus stop in the mornings. It really depends on the child - but if they know the rules - no cooking , no opening the door while you are out and she has a way of contacting you- no problem at all!!

MonaChopsis · 01/12/2025 18:03

OP he's just trying to control you. Tell him his views are noted and then totally ignore him. I did similar with DD (now nearly 16) when she was 9, as did many of my friends. I think although there are some 9 year olds that couldn't be left they are the exception rather than the rule.

DrEmilyCrabtree · 01/12/2025 18:15

I started doing this when ds was about 9.5. At 10 he started walking home from school alone (5 minutes walk, no main roads). Most of his friends were similar. I knew that he would be getting a school bus (30 mins ride) for secondary so needed to get him ready for that. There is no way I could have taken him and picked him up (other than appts or when he was late out), as I have to take dd to school and can't be in 2 places at once.

I can't imagine SS taking this seriously. They have far more going on

SemiRetiredLoveGoddeess · 01/12/2025 19:27

You Ex makes out like you live in a War Zone WTF!.

You sound like a good sensible parent to me and obviously a caring mother.

Dont let your idiot Ex bully you
He sounds like a real piece of work.

Just ignore him

bookworm14 · 01/12/2025 19:35

Your suggestion is perfectly fine and your ex is a (racist) arse. My DD age 10 goes to school, the park and the corner shop by herself with her brick phone (and we live in London zone 2 so probably an area your ex would view as a crime ridden hellhole!). It’s good for them to have a bit of independence at that age.

ComfortFoodCafe · 01/12/2025 20:14

Its fine. We live in a very small village, ds has been allowed to go out by himself since he was nine. He has his phone with a tracker on. I haven’t left him at home though other than a few minutes, but only because him & his older brother would probably aruge if I wasn’t there.

Roopdedoop · 01/12/2025 21:27

My daughter’s younger than yours and I have run to the shop directly across from our house once or twice when we have had no milk for breakfast and she’s not dressed yet. Takes me less than 2 mins and she can see the shop from the window. Some would probably think I shouldn’t but I know she’s sensible enough to just sit and wait 2 mins for me to come back. When she is in year 5 I think I’d be fine with 5-10 mins if it was needed for something

Anyusernamewilldo8963 · 01/12/2025 23:03

I have a social worker involved with my family (disability social worker that we got after fleeing domestic violence) and i do the exact same as you do with my 10yr old (with SEN so arguably the same age as your DD albeit technically a year older as closer to 11yr) and the social worker has no issue with it. No one can get in, she can get out. She knows not to touch the cooker etc and she also video calls me if she wants/needs to. Our rule is if I phone she has to answer and if she doesn't then she comes to the shop with me in future (again similar distance, end of the street i can see the shop from the house) and i also usually find her right where i left her. Tell ex to crack on with reporting you by repeating the same line over and over to every threat of social services "you do what you think is best" don't engage apart from this one line rinse and repeat. Any threats of violence log with the police

LaurieFairyCake · 01/12/2025 23:12

You don’t need to argue Confused You just don’t reposed or say ‘thanks for your unsolicited opinion, do feel free to report me to SS’

dont bother arguing

HereintheloveofChristIstand · 01/12/2025 23:31

Considerlentils · 30/11/2025 18:31

Why not just bring her? Hardly onerous and a bit of fresh air is always a good thing

Because she doesn't want to go. She would rather carry on with what she is doing at home, playing, watching tv, craft etc. Not turning the oven on or playing with matches. Can't blame her.

Catbakingbiscuits · 02/12/2025 05:15

What you are doing sounds perfectly fine and will go towards building strong independence. At your DDs age I was doing this and minding my toddler sister for 10-20 mins! ( I’m old lol)
Ignore your unhinged ex and be glad you are well rid. No social worker in their right mind would take any heed of this kind of “report”
I would build in sending her to the shop for you too for milk etc if it’s safe.

MrsJeanLuc · 02/12/2025 08:42

I also think you are doing everything right OP.

The thing to consider is not:

  • what will my daughter get up to if left home alone for 10 mins,

but:

  • what if something happens to me while I'm out of the house

Say there was some sort of accident and you couldn't come straight home - what should she do?

Natsku · 02/12/2025 09:09

Building up independence by starting small like this is perfect OP, you are doing a sensible thing that helps your DD develop her independence and confidence in herself. Your ex is talking nonsense but the implied threat worries me a bit, do you think its just talk or is he violent?

Owl55 · 02/12/2025 11:02

He’s just doing /saying anything to undermine you and it’s working! Try not to let him undermine your parenting . If you are really concerned speak to NSPCC for advice , I don’t think you are doing wrong , he sounds a horrible man who wants to make your life harder .

sunflowersblooming · 02/12/2025 12:37

My child (same year group but already 10) stays home for up to an hour alone and walks herself to and from school - she’s happy and comfortable, sensible, can contact me, we have plenty of neighbours we know (she often plays at the houses of two of them). I think we are encouraging her independence and school allow it (the walking home alone) so can’t think we are neglectful!

Hopingtobeaparent · 02/12/2025 14:43

Wingingit73 · 30/11/2025 18:31

Nothing wrong in what you're doing. Seek legal advice re her father. He sounds mentally unstable.

This. You’re the one who should be calling SS on him!!

Cakeandusername · 02/12/2025 14:55

Ignore dad. Building up in small age appropriate ways is being a good parent. Chauffeuring everywhere until they are 16 or 18 does them no favours at all. There’s no min legal age to leave a child.
I know of a dad who went to court to try and stop ex permitting child to go on a trip as a tween with a well known youth group. He was basically laughed out of court by the judge.

Cakeandusername · 02/12/2025 15:02

The girl in my story is 18 now and no surprise in zero contact with dad and changed her surname.

Pessismistic · 02/12/2025 19:57

How on earth can her dad judge you for this when he barely sees her. omg some men are unbelievable tell him to fuck off unless he’s going step up and be a proper dad. He’s a joke to say he will report you.

Andromed1 · 02/12/2025 20:53

The man is mad. You're doing nothing wrong.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page