Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please share the baking recipes people BEG you to make

68 replies

Koili · 11/11/2025 10:56

I’m trying my hand at baking for the first time. Have made a few amazing things but quite a lot of meh.

Please can I ask you to share any recipes you know work and are crowd favourites. I would love to be able to take something to a friend’s house which is actually good.

Thanks in advance.

I made the bbc good food’s banana bread quite successfully for anyone who is looking for a good banana bread recipe. It was a little greasy so maybe slightly reduce the butter (I later saw a few people made that suggestion in the comments)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
kersh33 · 12/11/2025 06:13

Nigella’s Easter Egg cake! I now make it for birthdays or any other big occasion as it’s such a big hit. It’s kind of like a chocolate truffle cake topped with chocolate mousse. Delicious and pretty foolproof to make. https://www.nigella.com/recipes/easter-egg-nest-cake

Easter Egg Nest Cake

This has been my Easter stalwart for years and years and I don't see that changing — ever. Make this just once, and you will be similarly convinced. Even if I wanted to stop making this, I wouldn't be allowed to.

https://www.nigella.com/recipes/easter-egg-nest-cake

MinnieMountain · 12/11/2025 06:15

I think we need a separate brownie comparison thread. The Mary Berry recipe I use is the only thing DS asks for.

Radyward · 12/11/2025 06:53

Wow cant wait to start on these

DappledThings · 12/11/2025 06:57

Always sells out at school bake sales.

Please share the baking recipes people BEG you to make
Jellycatspyjamas · 12/11/2025 09:29

FatherDickByrneV · 12/11/2025 02:22

Three ingredient peanut butter cookies. The cheaper the peanut butter the better these turn out. It makes 24 small cookies but you can adapt the size to suit yourself just adjust the baking time accordingly.
250g of peanut butter
250g of whatever sugar you have
1 large egg.

Mix together until just combined. Roll into balls. Place on lined baking tray. Press with a fork or your thumb. Bake for 10-12 minutes at 190°.

I sometimes add a sprinkle of sugar or salt before baking. I sometimes use my thumb to create indents that I add a half teaspoon of jam to. I sometimes add a chocolate button to the indent and drizzle white chocolate when cooled. These are quick, easy, customisable and absolutely delicious. The only time they turned out rubbish was when I used Pip and Nut peanut butter which has only salt as an added ingredient. I've used bog standard own brand PB ever since and they've been amazing

I make these all the time, quick and easy and gluten free. I echo your thoughts - it’s a recipe for big standard peanut butter, not the purist crushed peanuts and nothing else stuff.

MyCatPrefersPeaches · 12/11/2025 09:35

Nigella’s brownies
Nigella’s lemon syrup loaf cake
Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall’s cocoa powder brownies - he published this in a Guardian column around 2011 and it’s a great option for a last minute bake if you haven’t got actual chocolate in the house.
Smitten Kitchen’s big apple crumb cake.

Nigella is usually very reliable for baking and uses sensible proportions of things. Mary Berry is similar, though I’ve had mixed results with some of her recipes.

Smitten Kitchen is an excellent website and she’s all about streamlining recipes - and unusually for an American, is keen on weight rather than volume (cups) when baking.

gannett · 12/11/2025 09:57

Ruby Tandoh's peach and pepper tart (DP is the one who gets begged to make it, not me)

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2015/jun/27/fruit-tart-recipes-peach-black-pepper-strawberry-vanilla-custard

Lastfroginthebox · 12/11/2025 10:57

Edwinstarrihavefaithinyou · 11/11/2025 18:07

BBC good food guide.
Rock cakes really simple ,I cut the sugar down to 35G from 75 and they're still sweet enough.

I nearly always cut down sugar in baking recipes, sometimes as much as by half. On a drizzle cake, I drizzle with plain juice rather than a syrup.

GellerYeller · 12/11/2025 20:18

Donna Hay’s brownies with peanut butter (I use at least half the recommended amount of filling).
Lime and coconut cake- there’s a recipe in the Be Ro book but it’s basically a drizzle.
Father in law loves tarte tatin flambéed with Calvados!
Banoffee Pie. Gary Barlow’s recipe. Seriously.
I really want to attempt the Tom Cruise coconut cakes (he has a list of people that get one gifted every Christmas, I think it was on Graham Norton. They sound incredible).

HelloCharming · 14/11/2025 19:09

Home I’ll from work so the bananas I usually eat before the gym went very black. Made 2 Nigel slater banana loaf with choc chip. Chefs kiss, one gone in the freezer.

cleo333 · 14/11/2025 20:48

Love this

maryberryslayers · 14/11/2025 21:31

WishingIWasRich · 11/11/2025 16:34

Avoid Jane’s Patisserie recipes unless your oven is dodgy. The timings and temperatures are always wrong. Mind you, I should know that anyone who thinks chopping up a Mars Bar or opening a bag of mini eggs is “decorating” doesn’t know anything about baking. Her recipes are full of manufactured junk and I think they are written for children. I once questioned the timings and temperatures on her Facebook page and I was blocked! It was a perfectly reasonable question. When people ask questions on her recipes such as “can I freeze this” or “can I use this instead of that” she genuinely hasn’t got a clue. The answers are always vague “I think so” or “probably”.

I only use Mary Berry, Sally McKenney and John Kanell recipes.

I've used her recipe's for years and timings and temperatures are always perfect. Even when I switched to an Aga. She just doesn't over cook things and her brownies/cookies are on the fudgey /softer side. I too am a die hard Mary B fan but the styles are very different and my children love the novelty of the JP bakes.

Starconundrum · 18/11/2025 01:05

Starconundrum · 12/11/2025 01:04

Ok, I'm going to share my secret cookie recipe. It took me ages to perfect this.

It's in Oz. I apologise, but when I devised it 20 years ago that's what my scales said.

3 Oz butter. Creamed.
6oz Demerara sugar. Cream it in.
1 medium egg. Beat in thoroughly.

1 teaspoon vanilla. Proper expensive extract.
1 very large pinch of salt
almost a teaspoon.

Fold in 6oz sr flour. It will be very firm at this point.

Fold in 4oz chocolate chips. Thoughts are divided on this. My mum prefers 2 Oz. Galaxy or Lindt is best. Make your own chips.

Bake at 160-180c for 12-16 minutes. 1 tablespoon blobs spaced out on a greased baking tray. They should look Slightly uncooked in the middle and browning on the edges. You need to watch them like a hawk at this point.

Remove after a few minutes while still warm with a fish slice.

They are both soft and crisp and perfection.

Unless you are my daughter who cannot make them to save her life 🤷
Id say it makes 14-18 cookies. I often make the whole lot with an electric whisk as my arms get tired. It's a bit difficult to get the chocolate chips in without them flying around the room but I usually manage ok.

These went down very well this weekend.

All gone in about 5 minutes apart from the few my mum hid.

I used Lindt this time.

Empress13 · 18/11/2025 01:16

great thread

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread