Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a financial contribution?

16 replies

Dishwater · 05/10/2025 13:07

Please do not post this on any social media as it is quite outing.

I have a 19.5 year old son, he has a GF of approx 18 months, He has worked PT since he was 17 and left college, I did ask him to get FT work but he struggled to get anything, he has only been working FT for about a month. I think that’s relevant and I do understand that jobs are trickier to get these days but do believe he was a bit picky about what he would do and I wasn’t impressed that he worked only a few hours a week without going to college for almost a year. I used to give him a lift to work about 25% of the time.

So, son stays with GF parents house quite a lot, they seem happy with this. There isn’t much of a pattern to it but for about a year he came home and stayed between 2-4 nights a week. Then when he passed his driving test (I paid for lessons) and his step Dad gave him a car he then stayed at his GF’s for about 6 weeks with little contact, so was only coming home for his lessons and then staying a couple of days.

Im trying to give as much detail as possible because I know people will feel strongly about this subject, son has been very messy in the past (think attracting bugs in his room) despite me telling him repeatedly to clean up and going in myself eventually and being upset about the state of the room. He also when we went away caused some damage to some of our belongings so it has been a bit of a bumpy road.

So. I would like some advice from anyone in a similar situation with regards to a financial contribution to the running of our home from our son. How do I approach it? He has just said he’s coming for a few days and seems reluctant to say exactly when he will be staying here until. I don’t want to keep asking when he’s going back and make him feel unwanted but also I don’t like the nature of him coming and going as he pleases really. I also don’t know how to approach a financial contribution, how much would you ask for? If you didn’t know how many nights a week it is? Would you just say an amount regardless and then he can choose how many nights he stays? Would you be happy with not knowing when your teenager will be home and how long for?

It’s a really tricky situation to navigate honestly.
I let son eat the food I’ve bought when he’s here but he eats lots of protein so I haven’t factored in enough for him when I’m not expecting him (another reason I don’t like the come and go nature of him), he does occasionally bring some of his own but hasn’t this time. I think I’m set on asking for something but don’t know how to approach. He doesn’t do any chores or help with childcare of younger ones etc.

OP posts:
nomas · 05/10/2025 13:09

YANBU. He needs to get a job.

I paid my mum £250pm when I got my first job.

Is there anywhere else he can stay?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/10/2025 13:16

I think you need to discuss with him whether he lives with you or not! Explain that you need to know which it is, and if he is living there, roughly which days he’ll be there and you need to work out how much he should contribute.

Explain that living there is different to coming from time to time as a guest.

Jellybunny56 · 05/10/2025 14:26

I think you need a proper chat with him really. I don’t think the coming & going is unusual really, it’s very common when girlfriends/boyfriends enter the scene, plus friends, plus work etc, but you get to decide on a line. When it was me & my sister our parents sort of said that they totally understood we were growing up, had our own lives, and they didn’t need our diary but they weren’t prepared to be buying/cooking food that then didn’t get eaten if we weren’t home- totally fair enough and we would never have expected them to so we agreed to let them know if we’d be home for a family dinner night and we also did our own food shopping so they could just buy for themselves.

PIL did similar for my husband, they didn’t mind coming & going because that is part of growing up but they weren’t buying/cooking food to go to waste so from then my husband also did his own food shopping.

How much you ask for in terms of money depends on what it is supposed to “cover” in your mind really.

Wingedharpy · 05/10/2025 14:31

Does he pay GF's parents any money for his upkeep?

ApolloandDaphne · 05/10/2025 14:31

nomas · 05/10/2025 13:09

YANBU. He needs to get a job.

I paid my mum £250pm when I got my first job.

Is there anywhere else he can stay?

Edited

He has got a job! The OP says he has recently gone from part time to full time.

How much is he earning? I would suggest he pays an amount towards household expenses as he is still maintaining a room in your house but I would also suggest that he buys his own food when he is at home and does his own washing.

Spirallingdownwards · 05/10/2025 14:35

I would decide what you want to charge as a monthly "keep". Then have a conversation as to whether he considers himself living there or not. You need to know for the electoral register for one thing .

If he says yes then that is the rate. If he says part time then say its 2/3 rate however many nights he is there but if more than 20/30 its full rate.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/10/2025 14:35

I’d just have a fixed amount per week/month because if he was living in a shared flat his bills wouldn’t change because he stayed elsewhere a few nights a week. He needs to get used to having fixed costs of living, wherever he chooses to sleep.

I’d also expect him to let me know if he was planning to eat/stay over each night - it’s common courtesy to let folk you live with know you’ll be out overnight.

Bambamhoohoo · 05/10/2025 14:38

If you tell him he has to pay you for staying with you (for a few days a week it looks like?) then he will just go and live with girlfriends.

without commenting on whether he \should be paying, why would he if at 19 he can live with gf for free?

I’d play the long game here. It will make him feel unwelcome and he has a long adult life, which presumably you want to be part of?

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 05/10/2025 14:39

It’s tricky if he’s not actually living with you??

Id talk to him and lay out the expectations, if he wants to stay at your house more than 3 or 4 nights a week you will expect a contribution towards housekeeping and food.

How much you charge him is up to you based on how much you need the money. My dd is the same age, working FT and only pays me £100 a month however she does also buy food when asked and is saving hard for uni.

FuzzyWolf · 05/10/2025 14:39

Ask him if he is living with you or not because you’ll rent out the room to a lodger if not. If he is then he needs to pay £XX regardless of the amount of time he is here.

Dishwater · 05/10/2025 17:58

FuzzyWolf · 05/10/2025 14:39

Ask him if he is living with you or not because you’ll rent out the room to a lodger if not. If he is then he needs to pay £XX regardless of the amount of time he is here.

To be honest we could use the room ourselves but I know it’s not his fault I had a multiple pregnancy. It’s so hard though because after 6 weeks of not being here I thought it wasn’t fair that I have 2 kids sharing when there’s an empty room but when I posted people thought I was being mean and that 6 weeks isn’t a long time. I did approach him about it when I saw him and I think that prompted him to come back for a few days (albeit a week later).

OP posts:
Dishwater · 05/10/2025 18:00

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 05/10/2025 14:39

It’s tricky if he’s not actually living with you??

Id talk to him and lay out the expectations, if he wants to stay at your house more than 3 or 4 nights a week you will expect a contribution towards housekeeping and food.

How much you charge him is up to you based on how much you need the money. My dd is the same age, working FT and only pays me £100 a month however she does also buy food when asked and is saving hard for uni.

Thanks. Well really he has spent more time there than he has here in the last 12 months but he’s still a teenager so it’s difficult to say ‘you don’t live here anymore.’ What if they break up etc? I hate it all, I’m not happy with how it is but feel like there’s not much I can do.

OP posts:
Dishwater · 05/10/2025 18:02

Bambamhoohoo · 05/10/2025 14:38

If you tell him he has to pay you for staying with you (for a few days a week it looks like?) then he will just go and live with girlfriends.

without commenting on whether he \should be paying, why would he if at 19 he can live with gf for free?

I’d play the long game here. It will make him feel unwelcome and he has a long adult life, which presumably you want to be part of?

Yes of course but weeks on end without him here has really got me thinking that the coming and going so sporadically isn’t working for us.

OP posts:
Dishwater · 05/10/2025 18:04

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/10/2025 14:35

I’d just have a fixed amount per week/month because if he was living in a shared flat his bills wouldn’t change because he stayed elsewhere a few nights a week. He needs to get used to having fixed costs of living, wherever he chooses to sleep.

I’d also expect him to let me know if he was planning to eat/stay over each night - it’s common courtesy to let folk you live with know you’ll be out overnight.

I know what you mean.

OP posts:
Dishwater · 05/10/2025 18:05

Spirallingdownwards · 05/10/2025 14:35

I would decide what you want to charge as a monthly "keep". Then have a conversation as to whether he considers himself living there or not. You need to know for the electoral register for one thing .

If he says yes then that is the rate. If he says part time then say its 2/3 rate however many nights he is there but if more than 20/30 its full rate.

Edited

Yeah that’s another issue isn’t it? I have kept him on it but technically he’s spent more time there than here. Thanks.

OP posts:
Dishwater · 05/10/2025 18:08

Wingedharpy · 05/10/2025 14:31

Does he pay GF's parents any money for his upkeep?

No but he buys food. They’re very different people to us.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page