Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this an underhand comment

37 replies

thesurreymum · 20/09/2025 18:36

It’s my bday in a couple of days. DM came today to bring me a present. My DH notoriously never makes much effort for my bday and it’s been the source of tension previously. My DM knows this well and often makes comments around my birthday like ‘did x spoil you rotten’ knowing full well that’s not happened. I have two primary aged children and today DM went to them in full ear shot of me ‘have you gone and got mummy loads of presents’ they replied no we’re waiting for daddy. Again she knows that they are too young to get anything on their own and knows that my DH has highly unlikely not sorted anything. It just upsets them as they want to make an effort plus I’m there anyway so it’s like she’s making a point! I know the real problem here is my DH but my DM knows this and it feels like she’s digging the knife in at my expense. If she was that concerned at the lack of effort she could take the kids to get a card.

OP posts:
101WaysToFail · 21/09/2025 09:18

Sorry OP, if you were to be really honest with yourself she’s holding a mirror up to your marriage and you don’t like the reflection.

BitOutOfPractice · 21/09/2025 09:21

Why do you suspect she’s being spiteful op? Has she got form? Because in the face of it, it sounds like she’s trying to remind dh / the kids to make a fuss.

DramaQueenlady · 21/09/2025 09:28

Sounds like your mum is trying to ensure your kids get their dad to step up. I'd take them myself, give them the money to get stuff and just hover, but let them feel they've done it themselves. When it comes to husbands birthday there would be no effort from me at all.

TappyGilmore · 21/09/2025 09:29

Yep, it may not have been intended to upset you, but it would have been upsetting to the children who wanted to get you something.

PinkyFlamingo · 21/09/2025 09:29

If you know tnd problem is your DH why are you putting up with it?

TheSlantedOwl · 21/09/2025 09:30

Your mum loves you and knows you deserve better.

It must be awful seeing your kid with an unkind/lazy/thoughtless partner.

ConstableStable · 21/09/2025 09:56

Been there. In my case, my mum would have said nothing and if anything would have been like "oh men aren't in to that kind of thing, you're being princessy"

But if she had been the one to step in and do it, it would have annoyed my partner (now ex). Since he's a man that's something she would never do have done, Men are VIPs in her book. And honestly it probably would have made me feel even sadder. And my ex would have told me it was pathetic/childish etc.

You know the characters best but mum's position could be tricky here. Is she annoyed on your behalf and trying to fix it?

Every year it made me sad how my partner made no effort, and when other people made a big effort or even a small effort that meant a lot, it also highlighted the contrast - that my nearest and dearest couldn't be bothered. Or because birthdays weren't a big deal for him, he didn't get it despite being repeatedly told. The only world where he might have made a fuss at all would have been if I had no other loved ones at all. But I do so either he thought they had it covered, and he could opt out, or he hated having to compete with them......he was a contrary type.

Posters are suggesting you treat him the same. If i had decided not do anything for his, in retaliation, that would have made me feel sad like a a couple we NEVER marked any occasion or went out, but even worse, it also would not have bothered him in the slightest!

I mean I guess you could organise something fab for just you and the kids but that's not ideal either and they'll get the message that he's selfish/uncaring/miserable. (Which might be true)

thesurreymum · 21/09/2025 11:03

Thank you for the replies! Yes, there's problems in my marriage and my mum is not happy that I put up with a lot. She does regularly make comments though which I do think are just so unhelpful. Not only about this but other things like my weight, she started looking at dresses for me and went this is nice, oh scrap that it's a size 14 you definitely won't fit in that when I was a size 14.

I'm not that fussed about my birthday, I always do something for myself like book a massage or a facial and me and the kids go for cake afterschool etc. I've been with my husband 16 years and he's never made a fuss so I don't see why my mum should continue to make underhand comments. If she was truly concerned she could have a work with my husband or just get a gift/card from the kids herself.

This is not me blaming her over my DH though. I know he is the problem!

OP posts:
DaisyChain505 · 21/09/2025 11:04

It sounds like she sees you’re not being valued and you’re not in a happy marriage and is holding a mirror up to you.

BlueMum16 · 21/09/2025 11:07

She's trying to get your kids to mither your DP into making an effort.

Does your DP get you anything from the children?

Skybluepinky · 21/09/2025 11:10

Some people aren’t bothered by Birthdays it’s just another day if you want a fuss sort it yourself, comments from others won’t change his attitude and if it did they were doing it because they felt they had to rather than wanting to.

EuclidianGeometryFan · 21/09/2025 11:48

thesurreymum · 21/09/2025 11:03

Thank you for the replies! Yes, there's problems in my marriage and my mum is not happy that I put up with a lot. She does regularly make comments though which I do think are just so unhelpful. Not only about this but other things like my weight, she started looking at dresses for me and went this is nice, oh scrap that it's a size 14 you definitely won't fit in that when I was a size 14.

I'm not that fussed about my birthday, I always do something for myself like book a massage or a facial and me and the kids go for cake afterschool etc. I've been with my husband 16 years and he's never made a fuss so I don't see why my mum should continue to make underhand comments. If she was truly concerned she could have a work with my husband or just get a gift/card from the kids herself.

This is not me blaming her over my DH though. I know he is the problem!

my mum is not happy that I put up with a lot. She does regularly make comments though

She makes comments because she is not happy that you are not happy.
I don't think the comments are to make you feel bad (unless you know that she is a spiteful or cruel person). They are to try and make you take action to improve your life. You are her child and she loves you - how frustrated and concerned she must be, to watch you carry on in an unhappy marriage.

So - do you think she is spiteful and cruel? Or do you think she is frustrated about your situation?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page