Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think rescue centres don't actually want you to adopt their pets?

325 replies

lurchersforever · 20/09/2025 11:29

One of my cats had to be out to sleep suddenly in the summer and I would now like to adopt a young cat to keep us all company - me, ds and our remaining cat. I've only ever had rescue pets so looking at local centres. All have banners like please adopt/1000s of unwanted pets etc, but it is impossible to go and see any.

I have no issues with vetting and saying only certain types of households are suitable, but my issue is none of the centres are actually open. I've looked at about 6 near me and they are a mixture of not open to the public, don't answer the phone, say they're shut while Google says they're open, want you to fill in an application form and drop it off in person but you won't be able to even see a pet until your application has been assessed, don't reply to emails... The most success I've had is a centre that 'might' be able to arrange a video appointment to 'meet the cat' at some point and then I might be able to adopt 'when they open,' - no idea when that might be. This is for a specific cat they currently have - no sense of urgency to get her in a home. What on earth is the point of a video appointment with a cat?! What will it reveal that a picture doesn't? Just more time wasting.

I appreciate they are run by volunteers but this is ridiculous. Last time I adopted (10 years ago) you could go into local centres without an appointment and make the arrangements there and then. Obviously they weren't just handing them out to anyone but you could get the process moving.

At this rate I'll be on Gumtree, which I really don't want to be. What's going on?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
FlyMeSomewhere · 21/09/2025 22:52

Onegingerhead · 21/09/2025 13:13

When my husband and I got married and bought a house, we decided to get a dog. It’s a large breed — won’t say which one, don’t want to out myself 😂.

So, picture this: two professional adults, both working full time, 3-bed house with a garden and a decent fence. The answer from rescues? No, no, no. Apparently working full time makes you unfit for dog ownership. The fact that it actually allows us to pay for the dog’s needs… clearly irrelevant.

Fine. We went and bought a puppy — because, thankfully, we could afford a well-bred one. Then we had DC. Still not a problem. The dog had a great life. Sadly, it passed away recently at 10.

Remembering the pre-child adoption experience, we didn’t even bother trying rescues this time. Straight to the breeder, bought another puppy.

Full-time working people with children can give a dog a really good life, full of joy. And, crucially, they can actually pay the bills

The reason working full time can be a problem when it comes to trying adopt a dog os that it's not that pleasant for the dog! They aren't independent minded like cats who do they want all happily and go in and out of a cat flap. A lot of dogs in rescues have mental scarring and that often means separation anxiety! That's a dog that's distressed all day whilst your out, messing all over your flooring, whining and barking all doing your neighbours heads in and then the dog ends up being dumped back at the rescue because of it and tie psychological treadmill carries on for that poor dog.

FlyMeSomewhere · 21/09/2025 22:56

Baital · 20/09/2025 14:22

We did this when I was 10 (back in the 1990s). An abandoned dog. We took to him because he was so obviously friendly through the netting of his kennel. He had been found 6 days before, by a main road. We went back the next day because the RSPCA needed to wait 7 days in case he was claimed.

He was the best ever best friend throughout my teens. I cried when he died, he was such a big part of my life. I have a lovely portrait of him my mother commissioned as a birthday present.

A couple of years ago I approached several well established dog rescue charities as I was in a position to have a dog.

None replied.

In the end I went with a private rescue and got a lovely and affectionate young dog from overseas, and am so happy with her. She is very tuned into human approval, and has been perfect for us, although started as an overseas street dog.

I think very few dogs are given up in the UK unless they have significant medical or behavioural issues, because neutering is routine (which is good!).

In other countries neutering isn't the norm, so there are more strays that would make good family pets

The vets are asking people to stop adopting dogs from overseas because the people bringing them in are not having them screened for diseases and it's impacting the dogs already in the UK in a bad way.

Neodymium · 21/09/2025 22:56

I had the same issue with wanting to adopt a puppy (as a farm dog for our property). There is a rescue near me that is constantly posting on their Facebook about how many puppies they have. At one stage they had 2 big litters of puppies they were posting about needing help with. Like 15 puppies. When I contacted them they said none of the puppies would be able to be adopted until they were desexed at 6 months. We wanted a puppy to raise ourselves with our older dog. Happy to sign a contract to desex. In the end we bought a puppy off gumtree from another farm that bred them as working dogs. I didn’t want to do that but it’s a specific working breed we wanted and that was the only rescue so no other way to get a puppy.

Hakunamatata91 · 21/09/2025 22:59

OP try Next Steps Cat Rescue (based in Telford). I've adopted three from there, they are an amazing charity and responsive. I drove from Scotland to adopt from them as wasn't having any luck getting hold of a more local rescue, zero regrets! Did the same again when adopting another as my experience with them was so good.

FlyMeSomewhere · 21/09/2025 23:13

lurchersforever · 21/09/2025 22:44

the rescue will have struggled to buy that a couple of 23 and 24 don't want to have a life and just want to sit at home like a semi-retired older couple with an elderly dog.

What a narrow-minded outlook. Shortly after adopting our lurcher ex and I did exactly what this couple wanted to and adopted an old setter/retriever cross who had been mistreated. We were in our late 20s and ex worked mainly from home. We were his last hope and I actually recall that the rescue place (RSPCA) did seem grateful for once that we were taking him. We didn't 'sit at home' like it was us who were old. We took the dogs out and lived our lives. They were with us still when we started our family and the only time I ever saw ex cry was when the older dog had to pts after around 5 years with us. I understand the need to make checks and so on, but second-guessing everything and trying to foresee the future is just keeping pets in kennels and maybe even causing some to be pts before their time.

It's not narrow minded! It's not often that such a young couple don't want to work fuli time and have a good income, not have nights out? not have holidays? I've never known people that age want to sit at home most of the time with a low income. I'm not being narrow minded! I'm telling you how the rescue sees it!! At that age they are highly likely going to make changes to their lives! They are going to want to do things because people do when they are young adults! The vast majority of people that age will not just shelve the rest of their lives to potter with an elderly dog and the rescue knows that. Like I also said if their income is low the rescue will also see that as an issue. Why do you think the rescue didn't let them have a dog if I'm just being narrow minded? Tell me how I can be wrong when the rescue had concerns and didn't let them home a dog?

Milkbottlewaffle · 21/09/2025 23:13

Try Ashbourne AnimalWelfare -https://ashbourneanimalwelfare.org/cats-for-rehoming/

Also Pets at Home Chesterfield have a space for RSPCA and usually have a couple of cats looking for new homes.

carchi · 21/09/2025 23:17

We adopted a few years ago from Battersea in London. We did have to fill in an application form and then have a telephone interview/vetting process. But the thing that I found really strange was that the animals were actually not housed on the premises but living with foster carers and brought in by appointment when you wanted to see them before adoption.

WildSassenach · 21/09/2025 23:24

YANBU. A very strange system indeed.

bluegreygreen · 21/09/2025 23:30

FlyMeSomewhere · 21/09/2025 23:13

It's not narrow minded! It's not often that such a young couple don't want to work fuli time and have a good income, not have nights out? not have holidays? I've never known people that age want to sit at home most of the time with a low income. I'm not being narrow minded! I'm telling you how the rescue sees it!! At that age they are highly likely going to make changes to their lives! They are going to want to do things because people do when they are young adults! The vast majority of people that age will not just shelve the rest of their lives to potter with an elderly dog and the rescue knows that. Like I also said if their income is low the rescue will also see that as an issue. Why do you think the rescue didn't let them have a dog if I'm just being narrow minded? Tell me how I can be wrong when the rescue had concerns and didn't let them home a dog?

The couple are described as owning their own home, so presumably have a good income.
They live across from a beach and walk for miles, so are not likely to want simply to sit at home - but are likely to have a lifestyle compatible with having a dog.
They are not likely to 'shelve the rest of their lives' to potter with an elderly dog as the dog will not survive that long - but that doesn't mean that they can't be very good caring owners while the dog is alive.

Your comment did sound amazingly judgemental.

ClareBlue · 21/09/2025 23:51

Most of the rescue premises and life styles don't come anywhere near to meeting the criteria they impose for rehoming yet they keep the animals in these circumstances looking for a utopia for rehoming. They need to give people a chance for the actual good of the animals. Not all are going to work, but it's better then denying so many animals a chance of a good home based on a ridged technical assessment. There needs to be some accountability with theses charaties always asking for funding.

MidnightMeltdown · 22/09/2025 00:00

YANBU. I ended up buying 2 kittens because it was so difficult to get them from a rescue. They either ignore you, or say they will get back to you and then don’t. I was looking during COVID so thought they didn’t have any, but maybe they are just generally flakey.

ThingsThatMakeYouGoHmmmmmmmmm · 22/09/2025 00:25

It's absolute insanity. And in many case, as previous posters have suggested, merely an excuse for ' mad cat ladies ' to indulge their obsession, with a regular dose of appeals for food,blankets etc on their local Facebook groups. All too often these ' sanctuaries ' are busted , with lurid media stories of overcrowding and mistreatment. I think the whole concept of animal charities needs as much investigation as the owners trying to adopt. They are genuinely riddled with some very,very odd people.

Baital · 22/09/2025 02:56

FlyMeSomewhere · 21/09/2025 22:56

The vets are asking people to stop adopting dogs from overseas because the people bringing them in are not having them screened for diseases and it's impacting the dogs already in the UK in a bad way.

'The vets'?

Some vets may be, ours aren't.

DDog had a health check, was neutered and had all vaccinations before she travelled. She continues to be in excellent health.

Baital · 22/09/2025 02:57

FlyMeSomewhere · 21/09/2025 22:56

The vets are asking people to stop adopting dogs from overseas because the people bringing them in are not having them screened for diseases and it's impacting the dogs already in the UK in a bad way.

'The vets'?

Some vets may be, ours aren't.

DDog had a health check, was neutered and had all vaccinations before she travelled. She continues to be in excellent health.

TeamBuffalo · 22/09/2025 03:03

Tell me how I can be wrong when the rescue had concerns and didn't let them home a dog?

Because, as has been established earlier in this thread, some (not all) of these organisations are being run by well-intentioned clueless idiots.

daleylama · 22/09/2025 03:52

ClareBlue · 21/09/2025 23:51

Most of the rescue premises and life styles don't come anywhere near to meeting the criteria they impose for rehoming yet they keep the animals in these circumstances looking for a utopia for rehoming. They need to give people a chance for the actual good of the animals. Not all are going to work, but it's better then denying so many animals a chance of a good home based on a ridged technical assessment. There needs to be some accountability with theses charaties always asking for funding.

Quite. I'm astonished by stories in this thread. Might have to check out the charities that I donate to

lurchersforever · 22/09/2025 06:02

@FlyMeSomewhere I didn't necessarily mean just you - I was including the rescue centre in that as, as you say, the couple were denied a dog so perhaps they thought as you did. I just don't think second guessing what 'typical' people f certain ages would do is very helpful. Why not do some checks but then take the couple at their word? Not everyone is the same - what if a middle-aged couple get divorced/slightly older person dies suddenly? Anything can happen to anyone. A couple in their 20s wanting an older dog makes sense to me - they're not ready for children yet and don't want a young dog to grow with their family. And I don't agree at all that having an older dog means you have to live like an elderly person yourself. All the dogs I've had and known who lived full life-spans lived active lives until perhaps the last year or so and then were happy to be left for the evening while people went, for example, for a meal/drinks. They are perhaps offering just the kind of quiet home that an older dog appreciates.

OP posts:
EmpressaurusKitty · 22/09/2025 06:41

carchi · 21/09/2025 23:17

We adopted a few years ago from Battersea in London. We did have to fill in an application form and then have a telephone interview/vetting process. But the thing that I found really strange was that the animals were actually not housed on the premises but living with foster carers and brought in by appointment when you wanted to see them before adoption.

It’s far nicer for the cats to be fostered in homes than to live in pens. I just looked at the Battersea site & it says the fostering is just for certain cats who benefit from it most.

Amberlynnswashcloth · 22/09/2025 06:59

I found a trip to a cat rescue centre to be quite hostile. They chose the cat for you, not the other way around. We filled out a form and were pressured to agree to potentially take on a cat with known health issues which I felt was unreasonable due to the huge additional costs involved long term. We never went back.

I know a loving household who were deemed unsuitable because they lived in a flat (with a cat flap and access to a leafy mature garden). Cats are better off in the cage at the rescue centre apparently.

BountifulPantry · 22/09/2025 07:00

FlyMeSomewhere · 21/09/2025 22:15

The vets are getting very concerned about rescue dogs from overseas because a lot of the people are not screening them for diseases that are now impacting the dogs already in the UK.

Ours is fine. Healthy and a real joy.

mamagogo1 · 22/09/2025 07:07

Everyone I know gets cats from Woodside Animal Rescue, they seem to be open and friendly, no ban on dc etc

DangerousAlchemy · 22/09/2025 07:09

carchi · 21/09/2025 23:17

We adopted a few years ago from Battersea in London. We did have to fill in an application form and then have a telephone interview/vetting process. But the thing that I found really strange was that the animals were actually not housed on the premises but living with foster carers and brought in by appointment when you wanted to see them before adoption.

why is that strange? Cats much prefer being in a foster home than in a rescue centre facility.

DangerousAlchemy · 22/09/2025 07:13

daleylama · 22/09/2025 03:52

Quite. I'm astonished by stories in this thread. Might have to check out the charities that I donate to

Definitely look into it. Aren't the RSPCA one of the richest charities in the Uk? Many branches do not have a good reputation anymore sadly. Try supporting a small local independent rescue charity instead. They will receive no government funding at all.

Peteryourhorseisheree · 22/09/2025 07:30

Same experience.

So many of our neighbours too. Yes, we live on a 30mph road into town, but the back gardens are long and it’s all quiet roads behind and woodland. Had cats for years and none ventured out the front. So many cats here, you only ever see them out the back and in the woods! They aren’t stupid.

But no, no one can adopt.

OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 22/09/2025 07:48

I have found that they only want you to adopt if you can prove you live alone in a completely sealed house with no doors or windows through which the cat might escape. You must of course never go out or have other people around. You must be young but not too young and provide a guarantee that you will not die within the natural lifespan of the animal. You must also not work so that you can provide entertainment for your animal that is not permitted to seek natural entertainment outdoors.

And some of the small places are the worst. Some are lovely of course but some are just terrible and so unprofessional on social media, posting huge unhinged rants. I saw a local one recently saying something along the lines of "all the people who tell me to remember to take time for myself. I can't because [insert several paragraphs about buying stuff and trips to the vet] If I didn't do all this stuff then these kittens would be DEAD! Accompanied by a picture of kittens of course. So apparently you can't even tell them they are doing great and and to remember to take care of themselves too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread