Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guilt about wanting to move away

15 replies

Sillycabbage · 28/07/2025 10:24

My partner and I ran a restaurant together that we’ve recently closed. It’s been stressful, but it’s done and we’re relieved. We lived at the restaurant with our children, so it’s been our whole lives for the last ten years. It’s about 4 miles from my mum, and sister.

This means my 3 children have grown up close to my sister’s 3 children, and we see my mum and dad a few times a month.

Through therapy, I’ve had some realisations recently that my mum is probably narcissistic, and that I grew up trying to please her and be the mature person in the house. My Dad is quiet and enables Mum’s poor behaviour (violent rages when we were kids). Even now in their 80’s he isn’t allowed an opinion for himself and ‘just does what he’s told’ (as he tells everyone!)

My sister suffered too as a kid, she’s the youngest & they let her down even worse, over a complete failure of support when she was abused by a family friend.

Anyway, back to now, DH & I closed the restaurant and are looking to relocate to the other end of our country. My mum is sad, but I’ve been grey rocking her for years so I can cope with that. But my sister, who I love so much, is devastated.

She says she can’t believe that ‘she’s not enough to make me stay’ here.

I’ve discussed with her that we’re not responsible for our aging parents (I used to think I was, but the therapy helped me see I’m not.) I want her to get therapy too but she won’t.

My best girlfriends who live nearby have been so sweet and encouraging for me wanting a fresh start. I wish my sister could try to be the same. Am I expecting too much to want her to try and be happy for me?

She doesn’t understand why we have to go so far, even though we’ll be able to get a better house and quality of life somewhere else (it’s crazy expensive in the place where we are now). I feel like she’s pressuring me to stay, telling me we’ll regret moving. Maybe we will, but we’re excited to go for it. I feel resentful that she can’t at least try.

OP posts:
Sillycabbage · 28/07/2025 12:18

Bump?

OP posts:
mbosnz · 28/07/2025 12:24

I think that it's okay to have your feelings on something, but it is not okay to try and impose your feelings on someone else, and manipulate them thereby.

Obviously, it's going to affect her, and not for the better. But ultimately, you have to do what is right for you and your family. And it's okay to do so, and to be excited for that.

I think both of you have to accept to a degree that the other one does not and will not, feel the way about your big move the way you would wish them to.

SpryCat · 28/07/2025 12:26

Your sister can’t see it from your perspective and is only seeing it from hers. She feels you are leaving her behind with the parents. Could you encourage her to move once you’ve settled?

SpryCat · 28/07/2025 12:27

Does your sister and DC live with your parents? Has she a partner? Do they own their own home?

KiteFlight · 28/07/2025 12:28

Your sister is the problem here.
My sister moved to the other side of the country years ago and I was completely devastated , BUT when I was on the phone to her I showed excitement and happiness for her, it was only when I got off the phone I burst into tears. My sadness was kept completely to myself and she was oblivious to it all.

The fact your sister is guilt tripping you is a toxic trait. If you think back you might be able to think of other times she’s used similar tactics and maybe she has picked up some of those behaviours from your narcissistic mum.

My mother was/is a narcissist (I’m NC with her), and my sister could be very guilt tripping towards me in return. Whenever she wanted me to do something she would create guilt, and over the years I realised she wasn’t completely different to my mother, she just hid it a bit better.

You have nothing to feel guilty for. You have one life and you need to do what will make you and your family unit happy.

MatildaTheCat · 28/07/2025 12:32

Very difficult. You will benefit and undoubtedly your sister will have to shoulder the burden of your parents as they age and need more help.

Although you say they are not your responsibility are you really saying that you will do nothing if they need help? If you are willing to offer some support perhaps you could offer (to her) to deal with things that can be done remotely? And make a plan of how best you can see one another regularly?

The move sounds good for you, are your DC all on board with it? If you are going somewhere remote it can limit their opportunities as they grow up.

ThejoyofNC · 28/07/2025 12:32

You seem to view your sister as a victim. If she's aware of that then she probably makes a habit of using it to her advantage without you even realising.

Go and have your fresh start and leave all this toxicity behind you.

Richiewoo · 28/07/2025 12:41

Dont let your sister guilt trip you. Youre not responsible for her or your parents. I understand she's sad. You have to do whats best for your family.

Sillycabbage · 28/07/2025 12:43

SpryCat · 28/07/2025 12:27

Does your sister and DC live with your parents? Has she a partner? Do they own their own home?

She lives 20 mins from our parents.

Yep she has a wonderful DH and they have their own home, albeit a tiny one (this area, where we grew up, is one of the most expensive in the uk now)

OP posts:
Sillycabbage · 28/07/2025 12:53

ThejoyofNC · 28/07/2025 12:32

You seem to view your sister as a victim. If she's aware of that then she probably makes a habit of using it to her advantage without you even realising.

Go and have your fresh start and leave all this toxicity behind you.

That’s interesting; yes i do see her as a victim I guess, and so does she

I feel so frustrated as she won’t do things that might help herself (therapy, or trying for a new career to earn more £); she keeps life small and safe. But to be fair she has made her own lovely family unit, so I don’t have to worry about that.

She leans on me as a big sister emotionally a lot, especially when it comes to family stuff, but recently I’ve realised it’s exhausting me and I don’t want to do it any more.

I’ve realised I actually feel held back by her, like my ambition is a problem to the family dynamic.

Our parents live in a beautiful but entirely unsuitable cottage, it’s too remote for elderly people. I have tried to get them to consider a retirement village (they could afford a nice one) but while dad is keen, mum refuses outright. Her ego won’t let her downsize I don’t think.

Just writing this is making me feel so tired of it all!

OP posts:
Honon · 28/07/2025 12:55

Actually to disagree somewhat with the above answers I think you could be a bit more understanding towards your sister. It sounds like you're her support network outside of DH and given how difficult your parents sound, and her history, she must be devastated and feeling that now all the care will fall to her - which in all honesty is likely to be the case. The other end of the country is a long way away, you'll presumably go from seeing her at least weekly to what, once or twice a year? She'd have to be a good liar to pretend to be thrilled for you.

Having said that she's unreasonable to be manipulative about it and in an ideal world she'd be putting on a braver face - but I think expecting her to be genuinely happy for you is maybe asking a bit much here, I'd be looking to other people for that response.

ThejoyofNC · 28/07/2025 13:28

Sillycabbage · 28/07/2025 12:53

That’s interesting; yes i do see her as a victim I guess, and so does she

I feel so frustrated as she won’t do things that might help herself (therapy, or trying for a new career to earn more £); she keeps life small and safe. But to be fair she has made her own lovely family unit, so I don’t have to worry about that.

She leans on me as a big sister emotionally a lot, especially when it comes to family stuff, but recently I’ve realised it’s exhausting me and I don’t want to do it any more.

I’ve realised I actually feel held back by her, like my ambition is a problem to the family dynamic.

Our parents live in a beautiful but entirely unsuitable cottage, it’s too remote for elderly people. I have tried to get them to consider a retirement village (they could afford a nice one) but while dad is keen, mum refuses outright. Her ego won’t let her downsize I don’t think.

Just writing this is making me feel so tired of it all!

I had a feeling this was the case.

She's fine putting her wants and feelings first, but she's angry at you for trying to do the same. You can't be responsible for counseling her all the time, that's probably why she refuses therapy because she sees you as filling that role already.

Sillycabbage · 28/07/2025 13:38

ThejoyofNC · 28/07/2025 13:28

I had a feeling this was the case.

She's fine putting her wants and feelings first, but she's angry at you for trying to do the same. You can't be responsible for counseling her all the time, that's probably why she refuses therapy because she sees you as filling that role already.

Oh my god you’re right

Yes I absolutely fulfil a therapist role for her.

thank you that helps a lot; it makes more sense why it’s so tiring

OP posts:
pushthebuttonnn · 28/07/2025 13:54

It's time to put yourself and your needs first now. Maybe you could soften it to your sister, tell her it's still the same country and she can come and visit anytime. It's not like you're moving to Australia 🙈 She has her own dh, it's not like she has nobody. It's not good that she relies on you so much to prop her up. Don't feel guilty. Allow yourself to be excited. I think it's quite selfish of her not to be happy for you.

InterIgnis · 28/07/2025 14:01

You’re not your sister’s therapist, nor her keeper. You’re as entitled to make your own choices, for your own life, as she is, and her choosing to support your parents does not oblige you to do the same.

Go, and do not punish yourself with guilt. You’re doing nothing wrong.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page