Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd(9) and former bully

9 replies

nobodysaiditwashard · 04/07/2025 21:09

Dd was best friends with A through the first few years of primary. A was very possessive of dd and there were several incidences where she would pull her to the ground by her hair or grab her arm digging her nails if dd tried to leave or didn’t do what A told her to which left dd anxious and upset.

In year 3 Dd was then buddied up with a new girl, I think strategically by the teacher to give her a break from A who seemed to then go off with another group who have a bit of reputation of being mean girls. A completely dropped dd now she had her new group, blanked her or laughed if dd spoke to her so we encouraged her that A wasn’t a good friend and she should just ignore her also.

Anyway 2 years on now dd has her own group
and is much happier and more confident. The two groups don’t really interact or share party invites though there has been some nastiness.

A’s group have for recently for whatever reason kicked her out. Either true or just a made up rumour but they told the whole class that A wet the bed on a sleepover.

Dd has engaged with gossiping and laughing along at A’s expense. She also told a Y6 friend who then spread the rumour round their year and I think have been in bigger trouble for taking it too far. I have spoken to her about being kind and not getting involved and the whole class have been told the same at school.

A’s mother has reached out to me to try to arrange plans and A has been paired with dd for a project and moved onto her table at school so it seems the expectation is that dd and her group will accept A rather than her own group.

AIBU to think it’s not fair on dd to have to be friends with A now she doesn’t have any better options? Obviously dd needs to be kind and not laugh along which I know is hard when everyone else is but I think that should be where her responsibility stops.

OP posts:
Fourteenandahalf · 04/07/2025 21:21

She can be friends with whoever she likes, but I think by the time they are in year 5 it's a bit much to refer to a child as a bully who must have been year 1/ 2 at the time.
Spreading rumours about her wetting herself around the school wasn't a shining moment.

If they're on the same table I think they can be friendly and nice at school.

jesihar · 04/07/2025 21:24

Fourteenandahalf · 04/07/2025 21:21

She can be friends with whoever she likes, but I think by the time they are in year 5 it's a bit much to refer to a child as a bully who must have been year 1/ 2 at the time.
Spreading rumours about her wetting herself around the school wasn't a shining moment.

If they're on the same table I think they can be friendly and nice at school.

abs this. Far too long to hold such a position. At this moment in time, your DD is the one bullying. Regardless of what happened two years ago.

nobodysaiditwashard · 04/07/2025 21:34

I can see what you mean, I don’t know if it can be intentional bullying when they’re that small but dd definitely felt bullied, she was controlled and regularly physically hurt by her ‘best friend’ for her first 3 years of school and as a result was really anxious and unhappy.

She was then suddenly dropped and the the only interaction she has had from her since is either being completely ignored or laughed at.

OP posts:
nobodysaiditwashard · 05/07/2025 12:06

Quick bump before I reply to her mum

OP posts:
MuchTerraine · 05/07/2025 12:28

YANBU OP I think this is sending the message to your DD that she should just roll over and be a doormat when everyone else wants !!!!

Bitzee · 05/07/2025 12:38

It’s up to your DD. Does she want to be friends with A and make plans with her or not? If she does then I would accept that’s her decision and don’t hold a grudge about bad behaviour from a very young child. If she doesn’t then that’s also completely fine, A friendship issues aren’t her problem, but she still has to show her basic respect and work together on the project and not spread nasty rumours.

Barrenfieldoffucks · 05/07/2025 13:20

Well, at this stage your daughter's behaviour sounds just as bad, if not more pervasive than the very young version of the girl she's currently faced with. I'd be coming down hard on it, regardless of how the other girl behaved.

I wouldn't be making plans for them or whatever, but I would be telling my daughter that she is to 'go high' and behave appropriately in the classroom setting, group work etc, be cool, polite and friendly etc. Not take any crap and be sure to report any issues that arise, but to get on with it.

nobodysaiditwashard · 05/07/2025 20:25

Dd isn’t thrilled at the idea of being paired back up with A suddenly but she’s pretty easy going and will just accept whats thrown at her (why the teacher has chosen her) If I made plans she would go without a fuss but I’ve made excuses for now

OP posts:
RandomMess · 05/07/2025 20:58

I think I would respond that you’ll let her know of DD wants to meet up with A outside of school.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page