Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to have just hung up on my sister... (long, sorry)

10 replies

duchesse · 23/05/2008 20:40

Well, it's like this. We all in our family have varying degrees of ishoos and hangups about our slightly weird childhood at the hands of a depressive alcoholic father with grandiose ideas about childrearing mainly inspired by his own neglected wartime childhood, and a passive aggressive mother, more passive than anything when it came to actually defending us against his excesses.

Ok so all five of had a weird childhood, tempered by birth position, level of intelligence, prettiness, etc....

Roll forwards 30 years my father is still a bully, my mother is still passive, and we've all built our lives in spite of them. I cope with my childhood by shelving it and not really ever getting it out of cold storage.

Except that my sister (no 3 of 5) will keep going on and on and on about every single perceived slight from either of them at any time. Usually by phone, usually at around 7-8 pm (just after her children go to bed, just when we're having supper).

And guess who is her sounding board?

She continually rehashes the past, gets brusque and aggressive if interrupted or contradicted or challenged on any of her assertions, and sounds and reacts basically like our father. I don't want to say to her that she is sounding like our father, because that would be deeply unproductive, and if she is, well that's who she is.

I just do not want to spend 20mn on the phone to her during supper 2-3 times a week listening to her tell me how mean our parents are to her, how they appreciate her, how it's everyone's right (HA!) to a perfect childhood with an attentive set of parents, yadda yadda yadda

I know that there's no such thing as perfect parents, and that quite possibly ours pretty much did the best they could (not excusing them, just can't see the point of dwelling), and I really really do not want to listen to her yaddering on time after time about the same things. I just feel that she is an intelligent woman and ought to sort it out in her own mind and how to deal with it so that it doesn't poison her relationships (as I did around the age of 22). I can't see why she thinks it's OK to ring up quite to frequently to try to get approval for her opinions, and will not even talk about it. Frankly I'm not cut out for the sounding board role, particularly on this.

Anyway, this evening, I put the phone down on her pretty much mid-sentence after muttering a feeble excuse through a half chewed boiled potato. I'm feeling ashamed now.

OP posts:
GoodGollyMissMolly · 23/05/2008 20:53

duchesse, no need to fell ashamed at all. I can see that it would be very hard for you to hear all this.

It sounds like you have dealt with your childhood in your own way so I can understand how it would be difficult for you to discuss it with you sister.

Is your sister younger than you?

Maybe this is your sisters way of dealing with her childhood issues. But I do agree with you that it sounds like she just wants to sound off and not actually discuss it and deal with it.

Heated · 23/05/2008 21:04

I have a friend like this who thankfully doesn't phone as often as your sister but does mammoth monologues. All I'm required to do is occasionally say "hmm", "yes" while I check out teletext or do something else. I sound a dreadful friend but she really doesn't want a different opinion or suggestions, just acknowledgement & I'm cheaper than counselling I expect.

Can you say to her that you don't see your parents how she does, but it would be a good idea to speak to someone who will be helpful (implied is that you are not), what about a counsellor? Then next time give her the details of one.

Elasticwoman · 23/05/2008 21:09

Make it a rule never to take phone calls during a meal. You are unavailable. If she knew you were having a meal, she should not have expected you to participate in a long call about things that happened decades ago.

Try communicating with her by email in future. Life's too short to spend it on the phone.

duchesse · 23/05/2008 21:20

I used never to answer the phone during meals at all. Now that the children are the age they are, they always think it might be for them and jump for it even though we theoretically still have that rule.

OP posts:
Elasticwoman · 23/05/2008 21:23

Refuse to take the phone from your child. Train them to say "we are having dinner, please ring back in half an hour". You do not have to take a phone call, or answer the door, if you don't want to.

dittany · 23/05/2008 21:30

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

duchesse · 23/05/2008 21:36

MissMolly- I'm the oldest, unsurprisingly. Because I was "in charge" and "responsible" from the age of 5 or 6, my siblings see me as middle management and seem to want to bounce their aggression off on me instead of our parents. It gets a tad wearing...

Dittany- I agree.

OP posts:
colander · 23/05/2008 22:32

Get caller ID display, and don't answer the phone if it's her.

wobbegong · 24/05/2008 22:05

If it is really bothering her this much, I agree with Dittany.

Triathlete · 24/05/2008 22:21

Get down to Al-Anon. You're not the only person with that background, and it will help.

And drag her along too.

Feel for you, nasty situation.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread