Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's better to have an absent dad than an inconsistent one?

5 replies

TheRealLinda · 07/06/2025 09:28

My ex has been extremely inconsistent. For the last 4 years of our DD's life (she's 6), he was largely absent. He only visited around twice a year. He had an affair, moved abroad to be with the other woman, and after their relationship ended, he started another on-off one. That also ended last year, and that’s when he returned to the UK and stayed with his sister for about 5 months.
During that time, he became quite consistent, seeing our daughter almost every weekend. However, he went back abroad in March and since then, he has completely disappeared again. He doesn’t respond to calls, takes days to reply to basic messages, and DD is the one constantly chasing him for any form of contact.
This has really affected her. Recently, she messaged him saying she wasn’t feeling good, and his only reply was, “I hope you feel better.” He didn’t follow up, didn’t call, and hasn’t made any effort to check in on her. Then, 2 weeks later (yesterday), he sent her a 14-second voice note to say “Happy Eid” and promised to call later which he didn’t.
She had a friend over recently and told her, “My dad has forgotten about me.” That was so sad to hear.
We’re coming to the end of the divorce, and despite my repeated requests, he refuses to commit to any kind of consistent contact schedule. I’m now seriously considering withdrawing all contact and letting him take it to court if he wants access, because this emotional rollercoaster is hurting DD far more than no contact at all.

OP posts:
toomuchfaff · 07/06/2025 09:34

Some people will defend him " he's her dad he deserves access" blah blah blah but your daughter being and feeling abandoned over and over again, being placed behind the latest new woman must be devastating to her and to bear for you.

Let him have to fight for her, if he does then he may stick to it, if he doesn't, we'll she can be consoled that she doesn't need his presence to be amazing.

You'll be blamed, prepare for it but own it. "she wont let me see my child, she's denying me access" - just block him on everything, if it doesn't come via a solicitor or court, don't entertain it. Cut out anyone who defends him too, they aren't supporting you.

Fearfulsaints · 07/06/2025 09:35

I believe so and I actually think this is one of the main reasons mums start to be obstructive about contact. (The other being more obvious abuse).

My nieces dad was inconsistent. Would turn up late, the wrong day, not at all for weeks, missed birthdays, didn't visit when she was in hospital on a day he was supposed to visit. Then would appear after bed time and demand she was woken up etc. The poor little girl was really affected by it.

Then suddenly he completely disappeared as cms were chasing for money. We never saw him again and whilst it was very sad it really removed that uncertainty and constant let down and her life improved lots.

MassDebate · 07/06/2025 09:38

I agree; having experienced the hurt of inconsistent contact through my teenage years, I made the choice to go no contact when I was 19. I was definitely emotionally damaged by his inconsistency and when I chose to get in touch again some 20 years later it was totally on my terms.

I’m sorry your DD is going through this.

aCatCalledFawkes · 07/06/2025 09:53

It is yes BUT my ex dropped out of my sons life for quite some years and by the time my son was 12yrs he was desperate to find his Dad and now he sees his Dad who thinks he amazing once a month. He's with him today, he's now 14yrs and will no doubt arrive home in a foul mood.
I never blocked his Dad, or blocked his number. I even went to court to get a "live with order" and his Dad signed all the paperwork but didn't turn up in court.
The thing for me is though I won't be the one who blocks access and I do feel that if my son wants a relationship with him then he has a right to that. And the courts would also go with what he wants.
He's with me 99% of the time and the next 48hrs will be bumpy as my son will come home filled with crap about me (I left his dad for abuse) but it will settle and I'm sure he will understand more as he gets older.

In your shoes I would wait for things to drop off. I wouldn't start throwing court around as this has been known to actually not work and kick off things like 50/50....but I also wouldn't offer or engage with him about contact.

mumofoneAlonebutokay · 07/06/2025 10:29

Yanbu, act to protect your daughter from this bellend xx

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread