Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to send my step-mother a Mother's Day card

31 replies

vonsudenfed · 15/05/2008 11:39

I will try and keep this short and succinct, so here goes.

I lived with my father and step-mother from the age of 8 when my parents divorced. It wasn't the happiest time - to some degree I was the family scapegoat, carrying all of the upset and unhappiness.

But the worst thing, for me, was that my father has always wanted me to treat my SM as my mother, even though my real mother is still alive. Ironically, I have always felt that my relationship with my SM would have been better without this insistence, and the resentment it causes, standing between us ( to give you one example, my father will almost never speak to me on my own on the phone, my SM is always on the line too. If I complain about this, he refuses to listen, as he sees no reason why I should mind this, or why I would want a different relationship with him than her.)

Generally, now, I am OK about the situation; have had several years of therapy, and am content in my life. I now have a dd, and am very happy for my SM to be involved with her, as she adores dd. Generally, I think our relationship is better than it ever has been.

And so, the other day, my father corners me. Why don't I send SM a mother's day card? It upsets her, he says, she has after all acted as my mother for the last 20 odd years. When I try to explain that she is not my mother, he shuts down completely and refuses to listen to my point of view.

So, do I send the card for the sake of family harmony, even though I would rather eat my own arm than acknowledge this woman as my mother? Or do I not?

I don't want to, not for her sake, but because I don't want him to win. He broke my mother's will, so that she gave us up, he's not going to break mine.

Or is there such a thing as grandparents' day? I'd happily send her a card for that.

I am now almost in tears thinking about it. I thought we were on an even keel, and I just don't know why he wants to stir all this crap up again.

OP posts:
sheila62hipp · 19/05/2018 13:13

I have read many of your posts, including the original poster. I am a Step-Mother myself. What it sounds like to me, is to think of the individual person. Was she a positive influence in your life? Did she do the best she could? Of course she is not your mother and never will be. But if she treats you with kindness and respect, then, I believe a card or even something you made, would make her happy. Not sending her a card out of spite for your dad, is not only hurtful to her, it really isn't going to make a difference in this life. It just hurts someone that has tried to be by your side in my casecase we became a blended family when my son's were 4 and 9. and my step-children 9 girl and 12 boy. And I love them all with all my heart. I just lost my son two years ago and couldn't imagine losing another child of mine. Just think about why you would or wouldn't send a card. A simple Happy Mothers Day works out nicely. it will actually make you both feel good. if the situation warrants it. Don't try so hard. And always put yourself in the other persons shoes.It should make it easier to put things in perspective. Happy Day, to all!

Mulberry72 · 19/05/2018 13:20

And 10 years later..........

MrsCrabbyTree · 19/05/2018 13:46

For my step mum I always searched for a card that said something along the lines of 'Thinking of you on Mother's Day' and minus flowery soppy sentiment.

MrsCrabbyTree · 19/05/2018 13:49

Ooops should have read your post properly Mulberry Blush then I wouldn't have replied to an old thread.

frieda909 · 19/05/2018 13:49

shiela you’re about ten years late with that advice!

Lizzie48 · 19/05/2018 15:12

My DSis is a stepmum, her DH had a 9 year old DS when they met. She also has 3 DC of her own. She loves her DS as much as her own DC and was his primary carer for some years. (He'll be 21 this year, married and in the army, and with a baby.) He's never called her mum, as he has his own mum, and she was always careful not to overstep the mark in her relationship with him. But they do have a good relationship with each other, after the years she looked after him. (I don't know whether he gives her a card on Mother's Day, I've never asked, but

It's up to you whether you send your stepmum a card, but if you do it should be because you want to, not because your dad is pressurising you.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread