Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I just being overly sensitive or am I dealing with an overbearing SIL?

29 replies

Yunni13 · 31/03/2025 18:07

My husband (31M) and I (29F) are due our first baby any day now and throughout my pregnancy, my sister-in-law (35F) has been seriously crossing my boundaries. For reference, my husband and his family are Chinese but him and SIL were both born in UK. Since we’ve been married, his parents have said things like “Does she know she needs to put our family first before anything?” and have made comments about my own family and upbringing. My SIL has also said things like “You are part of OUR family now”. I’ve not had much of an issue with comments like these as I just chalked it up to strict Asian culture, but since being pregnant - it’s been really bugging me.

Since we announced our pregnancy, his mum and sister have both been on my case about what I can/can’t eat, what I can/can’t do, how to sit, how to dress, the list goes on. As if I haven’t researched and read up everything myself. They both also said “Don’t buy her clothes and tell your mum and sisters not to because we’ll buy all her clothes.” when it is the first grandchild on my side of the family too! And would I not like to dress my own child?! They’ve nagged at me several times to just formula feed so they can help feed her too, when I’ve expressed that it’s important for me to breastfeed my baby. SIL even bought and gifted a bottle set to push it on me even after I’ve said no to formula.

Every time his sister has asked to hear what names we have in mind, she’s been highly opinionated “Ew! You can’t name her that!” “No that name is disgusting!” “You should name her ” and so on. Oh, she also said “What are we naming OUR baby?”. So I genuinely think she thinks it’s her baby. For reference, she’s never been in a relationship before and still lives with her parents, she and their parents believe she will never get married and have her own family so I can sympathise with her feeling like she’s living through us with this baby. She’s a primary school teaching assistant and has made comments like “Don’t make her princessy, make her more tomboy.” “She better be born before the Easter holidays so I can come over and spend time with her.” “I can’t wait until summer holidays now so I can come over everyday to spend time with my baby niece.” and has a lot of opinions on how we should raise our child because of her job. The other day at dinner, she was placing her hands all over my stomach whilst I was eating. I told her she’s not moving and I’m eating and she didn’t stop. I felt so uncomfortable and my husband laughed it off.

To top it off, she very recently put down a deposit for a flat round the corner from our house and my husband said to her she cannot come over unannounced to which she replied “I absolutely can and will.” I lost it and said to my husband I am not happy with the things she’s been saying and how she plans to come over “everyday” and he said just to ignore her and he will tell her when and if she comes over. I don’t have hope of this as his family has came over several times without a call or text and many times I’ve been in the house alone or sleeping and been woken up to them at the door. I understand he probably can’t see what the problem is as he is used to how overbearing his family is, but it is seriously making me upset and stressed out. I’m scared for when my baby is born as I feel like his family think they own her like they own me. I’m at my wits end and I don’t want to cause family drama, especially during such a special time of our baby arriving but I’m about to lose it! How do I deal with this best? Am I just being overly sensitive?

OP posts:
OutandAboutMum1821 · 31/03/2025 19:27

Fancycheese · 31/03/2025 18:25

Jesus Christ OP! I’d be having a breakdown if I was having to deal with even half of this while pregnant.

Agree that you have a huge DH problem. You need to sit down and tell him, in no uncertain terms, that this is wildly unacceptable. And do this before the baby gets here. This is insanity. I’m sorry you’re going through this.

100% this. Really feel for you OP 🥲

Mummypie21 · 01/04/2025 10:28

I sympathise with you. I'm also British born Chinese and my PIL (from Hong Kong) were extremely overbearing after we had our first child. They practically moved into our place and then demanded that I move in with them for the first month (so they could help out). I hardly saw my own mum as they were there everyday and felt they were the priority grandparents because our ds had their surname. I didn't have a SIL to deal with though. You need to nip this in the bud at the start.

My PIL are a lot better now and wasn't overbearing when I had my second. However, it took us a few years to get there.

Saltedcarameltiramisucheesecake · 01/04/2025 10:37

Here's something I wish I'd known at your age.
Whatever crazy, stupid shit people (including family) say or suggest to you, if you don't like it, just say no thanks. If they pout, moan or throw a strop that is THEIR problem. This is your baby, so you get to make all the choices.

slumdogminulet · 01/04/2025 11:56

I am White British with a HK Chinese husband and we have been together 30 years and have four children. You have my every sympathy.

There is an expectation that you become part of the husband's family because that's how it works in Chinese culture. My advice would be to push back when the cultural assumptions do not align with your own. I state to my husband that it's not my culture and so it's not how I will be doing things. We are a cross-cultural family, living in the UK, and so there's no reason why we have to do things the way they were done in 1960s HK just to keep his family happy. I have never been rude in what I say but refuse to go along with stuff like you're describing just because it's cultural - they need to respect my culture too!

As individuals all my husband's family are perfectly nice. En masse I am less keen so tend to avoid large family events. My husband is incapable of ever pushing back so I leave him to get on with many family things - like the apparently compulsory weddings etc of a third cousin's stepdaughter that we've never met etc. My advice is to be firm but polite in what you will put up with and keep asserting your need to do what you decide for your own daughter. They might not like it but will learn that it just the way you do things. You don't have to conform to their expectations just because you've married their son. I recommend politeness while being firm.

Good luck! I hope all goes well with your baby.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page