Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Merton Council is deliberately breaking the law, leaving disabled tenants in horrific conditions

44 replies

HardyBiscuit · 13/03/2025 00:39

I would like urgent advice and insight from anyone who has dealt with council housing failures for private tenants, legal battles, or forced homelessness due to totally inhumane and uninhabitable living conditions caused mostly by local authority neglect. My property is privately rented. I live with housing Category 1 hazards, and I am asking for advice because this situation is ongoing.
What is a Category 1 Hazard?
A Category 1 hazard is the most serious level of housing danger under the Housing Health and Safety Rating System (HHSRS). It means the conditions pose an immediate and severe risk to health or life. Councils are legally required under the Housing Act 2004 to take action when a property has a Category 1 hazard.
My property currently has three Category 1 hazards. These have been getting worse, and for four years, I have reported and requested help from Merton Council non-stop for most of this time.
Merton Council has been fully aware of my case for years. Yet, despite their own Environmental Health reports, legal obligations, and repeated complaints, they have refused to act.
My Reality: Living in a Dangerous Home
For four years, I've been trapped in an uninhabitable, rat-infested, water-contaminated flat, with no heating. This is not an exaggeration—this is my daily life:

  1. Rat Infestation – Worse Than You Can Imagine
Hundreds, possibly thousands, of rats—some massive—live inside the walls, beneath the floorboards, inside the plumbing, and throughout the entire building and garden of 6 self-contained flats. They infest the sewage system, confirmed by three pest control specialists, all of whom stated it's among the worst infestations they’ve ever witnessed. Rats have damaged plumbing systems and constantly cause internal structural harm. At all times of day and night, I hear them scratching, banging, clawing, and running along metal pipes, inside walls, and beneath floorboards. The sound isn’t just noise—it’s a constant horror, a reminder that I'm surrounded by vermin. I suffer from severe sleep deprivation. Tonight, like most nights, I will remain awake past 5:50am due to the constant loud noises they make around my living space (for instance, beneath my bed or within walls inches from where I sleep). Even during the day, when my severe fibromyalgia is at its worst, I get no rest—the rats never stop. Neighbours have also complained, but Merton Council still refuses to act.
  1. Contaminated Water – Merton Council is Fully Aware
The water stinks strongly of sewage and frequently stains everything it touches. After washing, it leaves brown residue on surfaces and even my skin. It's impossible to use for cooking, cleaning, or washing dishes—even mopping floors attracts more rats because of the smell. Thames Water tests confirmed dangerously high levels of lead, fluctuating just below and sometimes likely above the legal threshold, given my reported symptoms. Thames Water and the Drinking Water Inspectorate both advised me in writing to ask Merton Council to urgently investigate the internal plumbing. I provided these letters to Ross Garrod and all council departments, but they've all ignored them.
  1. No Heating – No Safe Living Conditions
There's no proper heating, legally making the property unfit for human habitation. I can’t even safely use the minimal heating available because it attracts rats beneath the floors. (As I write this, there's a rat rustling beneath the floorboards by the heater, forcing me to switch off the only heat source available.) I am constantly, forced out of my home because of the unbearable combination of rats, contaminated water, and freezing conditions. Ross Garrod – Leader of Merton Council Ross Garrod is my local councillor here in Mitcham; he is also the Leader of Merton Council. He oversees Housing, Environmental Health, and Adult Social Care. His name carries authority in Merton. I personally invited Ross Garrod multiple times to visit my property, which is literally one minute away from his surgery location in the local library. Yet, he has taken no action at all to help me or even talk about my category 1 hazardous flat. Systemic Neglect – How Merton Council Broke and are Still Breaking the Law This is not incompetence—it's systemic neglect. Each relevant council department has broken clear legal obligations: Environmental Health: Legally obligated under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 and Public Health laws to take enforcement action against severe infestations and water contamination—but they refused to act despite confirming these hazards. Housing Department: Legally required by the Housing Act 2004 to address Category 1 hazards immediately, (I have 3 Cat 1 hazards). Instead, they repeatedly denied my requests for safe alternative housing. Social Services & Adult Care: Required under the Care Act 2014 and Equality Act 2010 to support disabled residents facing severe housing dangers. They refused to intervene even after they themselves found the property inaccessible due to the severity of the rat infestation. This isn't incompetence—it's systemic, deliberate neglect across multiple council departments, each illegally refusing responsibility and passing the problem on to someone else. What I've Done to Challenge This ✅ Submitted multiple formal complaints – All ignored or dismissed.✅ Escalated concerns to my MP & councillors – No removal of the 3 cat 1 hazards.✅ Requested emergency housing – Repeatedly denied, despite overwhelming medical evidence.✅ Involved pest control & Thames Water – Their official reports clearly prove dangers, yet Merton Council continues to ignore these findings. Seeking Advice & Guidance Have you experienced anything similar with your council, especially as a disabled or vulnerable person? Have journalists or housing campaigners successfully intervened to force council action? Are there legal strategies or actions I might not yet have tried to compel quicker council response? How can I effectively hold Environmental Health and Housing accountable for their legal violations? I have video evidence of the rat infestation, photos of water contamination, and over 200 pages of legal evidence, including court filings, Environmental Health reports, and medical documentation. My experience isn't unique—this is evidence of widespread, deliberate neglect by Merton Council, which must be affecting other tenants, both disabled and non-disabled. Thank you for any advice or shared experiences.
OP posts:
Slimbear · 13/03/2025 04:54

Have you no family who can help you out?

Nat6999 · 13/03/2025 05:05

Councils should have a private renting standards department by law, contact them. I would also apply to go on the housing list & send photographic & video evidence in to prove your unsafe living conditions to hopefully get you priority for a move. It may mean temporary living in somewhere like a Premier Inn or emergency council accommodation. If you can't get any action from the council, then go to the Housing Ombudsman.

Changeissmall · 13/03/2025 05:07

Good grief. Did your MP do nothing when you contacted them?

Changeissmall · 13/03/2025 05:09

Do you have the support of the other tenants? Have they taken any action or leaving it all to you? Do they have exactly the same issues?

HomeTheatreSystem · 13/03/2025 05:27

I am so sorry you are living in these beyond putrid and poisonous conditions but no real idea how to resolve. Shame them on social media? Find a pro bono lawyer who specialises in this stuff? Talk to your MP (take an outline of all the issues with detailed and clearly documented evidence and timelines)? You'd be safer living in a fucking tent by the sound of it.

Autumn1990 · 13/03/2025 05:32

That sounds horrific.
You may have tried these things contact shelter, CAB, a housing specialist solicitor, the local paper, the daily mail or guardian.

JustMyView13 · 13/03/2025 05:47

I would speak to citizens advice but this sounds awful. I can’t believe they’d ignore one of those things, let alone all of them.
What’s crazy is they are bringing in stricter rules for private landlord (rightly so), but it’s all self certification and tick boxes so won’t improve things for tenants because bad landlords will always find the loophole. It’s basically just a tax.

Mumof2girls2121 · 13/03/2025 05:54

Have you called a pest control service?

PenguinLover24 · 13/03/2025 06:18

Publicly shame them. Send this to every newspaper, tag them on twitter even call this morning, this is an absolute disgrace.

Mingenious · 13/03/2025 06:27

I think you should speak to either the ombudsman/ a solicitor/ the media. Possibly all 3.

it just isn’t good enough, is it.

Accidentaladult · 13/03/2025 06:41

It would be a complaint to the Local Government Ombudsman (not Housing as that's for social housing tenants only). You could also make a disrepair claim, but this may mean the Ombudsman might not be able to investigate.

Who is the freeholder of the building, do you know?

Soontobe60 · 13/03/2025 06:58

Have you not considered moving?

MitchamMum · 13/03/2025 07:02

I have no legal advice for you, OP, but just to say that we live in Merton as well and they are completely useless to anyone who isn't it in the posh bit of Wimbledon. It's awful and the whole Borough looks so shabby these days. I'm sorry that you are having these dreadful living conditions forced on you. I hope there are some knowledgeable posters who can offer some practical advice.

Ace56 · 13/03/2025 07:03

Yes, sorry to be stupid, but if you’re privately renting then why can’t you move? Or are you renting a council property/are the council helping you out with rent?

ThreeFeetTall · 13/03/2025 07:06

Sorry if I missed this but what action have you taken against the landlord of your property?

MitchamMum · 13/03/2025 07:06

Sometimes BBC London covers the failure of councils to ensure adequate housing - maybe you could ask them to get involved? [email protected]

BodyKeepingScore · 13/03/2025 07:11

Is there a reason that moving isn't an option for you?

NowYouSee · 13/03/2025 07:15

Surely the primary obligation here is on your landlord? What you are talking about here largely sounds like a failure to use legal powers against private landlords.

What did the council say in response to the councillors and MP as to why they won’t act?

User5274959 · 13/03/2025 07:16

Agree with post above - you've not said why you can't move? Do you have particular housing needs or adaptations which mean you can't move? Surely that's what most people would do

Wimbledonmum1985 · 13/03/2025 07:16

Awful. Merton Council are an utter joke.

London22 · 13/03/2025 07:17

This sounds horrific. I've heard about Merton council's neglectful and shoddy council run homes, including temporary accommodation.

However if Ross Garrod refuses to intervene, which sounds unusual, as that's exactly what their job is to do. Then you go above his head to his manager and cc in the CEO details of Merton council which is Hannah Shoddy.

Let her know all you're dealing with and see what actions can be taken from there.

OP when you're leaving your home to live elsewhere at times when it's unbearable, is there a reason why you can't stay there long term. Then go back to the council and cite you're being forced to become homeless, due to your current unsuitable living conditions.

Londonrach1 · 13/03/2025 07:18

Are you renting via the council or privately?

CactusForever · 13/03/2025 07:19

Sorry that I can't access Twitter at the moment to provide the handles, but look up Harry Scoffin and Kwajo Leon Tweneboa who are both social housing journalists and campaigners.

soupyspoon · 13/03/2025 07:25

OP is renting privately, it says so in the OP

You need to move OP, simple as that.