Finally, finally.
Here is my draft letter to MPs. I am happy to have comments and may then set up a seperate AIBU, as in AIBU to ask you to write to your MP.
With these things it really is worth personalising. If a bunch of different letters end of on the desk of whoever is responsible for policy, they will decide there is more strength of feeling than if it is the same letter each time. That said it is often easier to follow an existing draft. My draft is light on stats. Others may want to add more.
I recognise that a couple of posters strongly disagree. I suggest rather than comment on the draft below they work up an alternative that can be used by those who feel that no action is needed.
So here goes:
Dear MP (check the right form of address. H/she might be a Rt Hon). You should give your address and it needs to be in the constituency.
I am hoping that you can offer me help on the issue of unemployment amongst doctors and other health care professionals (HCPs).
I would like you to share my concerns to your colleague The Rt Hon West Streeting, and also to your colleagues responsible for Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland policy as these are areas which have traditionally struggled with Doctor recruitment and retention.
Perhaps a bit of background on your own/DCs circumstances
She now says she will have to look overseas for work, and that all but two of her placement group will do the same. I didn’t really believe her until posters on Mumsnet (we have exchanged notes with since our children were applying for medical school) confirmed that their children had also and reluctantly, accepted that there are no jobs for them, leaving them the choice of: to look for work abroad; to seek short notice shifts via NHS bank; or to leave the profession.
The same is being reported on several Reddit threads. Unfortunately the NHS do not keep data that might that would enable them to gauge the size of the problem, and instead assume young doctors are actively choosing to leave for Australia. So their solution is to hire even more replacements from overseas or to expand medical school places.
The problem seems to be an unintended consequence of the scrapping of the Resident Labour Market Test (RLMT) for various HCPs in 2021.
The impact is costly and damaging. Young doctors cost £250,000 each to train and will have built up debts of close to £100,000. There are also long term planning issues around losing those who should be the next generation of consultants and specialists. Not forgetting the moral questions around recruiting experienced medical staff from countries that cannot afford to let them go, especially if they then find themselves unemployed at the end of their contracts.
After their foundation years (F1 & F2) young doctors would choose. Either a specialist training post, or a year (known informally as an F3) working a short term entry level contract as a locum or a Clinical Teaching Fellow whilst getting the experience for and studying to apply for a training post.
My daughter was aiming for the latter. Her F1 and F2 rotations have been demanding so rather than juggle she is focusing first on gaining good experience and then taking a year to prepare for her training application.
Worldwide recruitment without protection for those already in the UK means that an industry has been created in preparing overseas doctors for UK vacancies. Though the NHS does not collect data on application numbers, anecdote suggests that entry level vacancies are being spammed by hundreds of applications, to the extent that entries are often closed within a few hours. Even if a UK based doctor is able to spot the vacancy whilst it is still open, they won’t have the help in polishing their applications that those going through agencies will have, or as much experience. The point for them is to gain experience. Applications are anonymised so they expect to lose out.It is not surprising they say it is not worth applying.
Throw in budget cuts and the introduction of Physician Associates into jobs previously held by newer doctors and the outlook is bleak. Our young doctors have not only lost a career path, they have lost their chances of employment.
Accessing specialist training posts is even more difficult. The UK has always trained doctors from overseas. A generation ago this was fine. Overseas recruits could be expected to make a lifetime contribution to the NHS or to return home to support their own evolving health services.
Things have changed. Private medical schools in places like Malaysia and India are pumping out large numbers of graduates, far too many to be absorbed into the lower rungs of their own health care systems. British specialist training enjoys a strong international reputation, and once at Consultant level there are a raft of well-paid opportunities either in the private health care system back home or in hubs like Dubai or Singapore. This makes a few years in the UK a good investment.
The numbers are illuminating. In 2023 there were 19,675 doctors (9273 from UK medical schools, 10,402 from medical schools elsewhere) sitting exams and making applications that would qualify them to apply for 12,680 training posts. In 2024 applications had risen to 25,469 (10,628 domestic graduates, 14,868 international) for the same number of places. In 2025 the figures had risen again. 33,108, of which 12,305 graduated from UK medical schools and 20,803 who graduated overseas, without any significant increase in the number of places.
The number of international applicants has doubled within two years.
The proportion of specialist training posts going to UK graduates has fallen from 65% in 2021 to 59% in 2023, and this year is expected to be below 50%. In 2012 only 5% of graduates from British medical schools failed to get into specialist training. By 2022 it was 48% and in 2023 it was 75%. Given the numbers applying continues to explode, in 2025 there will be even more young doctors who can neither get training places nor alternative F3 work. This has huge longer term implications for the NHS. If we are not training the people who can be expected to spend a career in the NHS, where will we find consultants of the future? Especially those willing to work in less popular regions.
This competition has created an arms race. Ever higher exam results are required, ever more academic extras: winning prizes and competitions, having papers published and so on. Already institutions overseas are offering lengthy and expensive courses that provide additional degrees and credentials to enhance an application. Much, much, harder for a busy F2 working in the NHS to do the same.
Every other country seems to protect their own doctors and other health care staff. We don’t. We should.
There is a lot of further information and data that I would be happy to share with you or your staff.