Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move DS to a new school…

16 replies

DrivingMyselfUpTheWall123 · 26/01/2025 02:26

Apologies, this may be a long one, I’m having serious anxiety over whether I’m doing the right thing… perhaps this is more of a “get it off my chest” but we’ll see…

DS is in Primary Year 5. We moved 18 months ago just as DD was moving into year 6 therefore kids stayed at their current school as felt it was best for her to do her SATs first. DD is now in Secondary school and she started not knowing a single person. She’s made friends quickly and settled in well but is a sociable child so it didn’t come as a surprise.

DS stayed at original primary school - we battle traffic for 40 minutes each morning to get in to school (walking or cycling would make us late for work so we need to drive unfortunately), and there has been a couple of issues that I don’t think the school has dealt with correctly over the years however, both my children have loved it and have wonderful friends. DS has struggled to really concentrate in previous years, but he’s hit the ground running this year and has made an amazing start to the year!

On Friday DS and I went to visit a primary school within a 5 minute walk of both home and work. It’s a nice school, some of his teammates go there (although, they don’t really speak much), he could meet some new friends who would move into the secondary school he will likely be going to and who live in the area, and next year he would be able to independently take himself to and from school - something he has been itching to do this year but the distance would mean it would never be feasible for him. This also means I could increase my hours at work so I can upgrade the car which is on its last legs and afford a family holiday maybe. His best friends are in his football team so he’d still see them weekly. It all sounds great…

… but. I cannot get over this overwhelming anxiety I feel. I have visions of him walking a playground by himself, eating lunch alone, being picked on or whispered about! Or that he’s going to fall way behind and struggle to catch up, making his mental health dive bomb. He’s a shy boy until he feels comfortable and would watch from the side for fear of rejection if he asked to play. It’s 2am and I’ve been unable to sleep for fear that I’m taking him away from something so stable and a place he loves with people he trusts and plonking him somewhere with strangers. It is taking over every thought I have and I cannot switch off from it.

The new school have given me some reassurance that they will buddy him up and ensure he’s involved but nothing has settled this anxiety. They’ve even offered some day/afternoon/morning sessions before we officially accept an offer of a place to see how he gets on.

Im having such a head vs heart debate and all I want to do is the best for my son. In the long run, if this new school works out, it’ll 100% be the best decision. But what if it doesn’t…

YABU - Get a grip. Listen to your head, it makes sense and will be fine.
YANBU - Maybe moving him now isn’t the best idea?

OP posts:
Mumdiva99 · 26/01/2025 02:29

Of course move him. It's a no brained. He will adapt. Kids move schools a the time. Independence is important.

TappyGilmore · 26/01/2025 02:59

You should definitely move him. It’s a shame you didn’t move him at the start of the school year but whatever, you can’t turn the clock back.

To be honest I don’t really understand your doubts about this, he will need to start secondary school not knowing anyone so why not just move him to a new school now? It will be easier at primary where it will be a smaller school and they will look after him better, and it will be nice for him to go to secondary knowing some people.

I started a new school myself at the beginning of year 5. It was fine. The worst thing for me was that I then went onto a secondary where I knew no-one. I’d have much preferred being able to go onto a secondary with the kids I already knew from year 5 and 6.

JMSA · 26/01/2025 03:02

The new school has offered you trial sessions. There is literally nothing to lose.

TheSandgroper · 26/01/2025 03:04

God, just make the move now.

DO NOT make your anxiety his problem.

christmascanfuckoff · 26/01/2025 05:13

Moved my son in year four from a huge school to small primary. Was hard at first and some tears but within three months he was fully settled
Now in year 8 and he has nothing but affection for second school and tells me he wishes he went from the beginning.

He will be fine might be hard at first

Bournetilly · 26/01/2025 05:20

Take them up on the offer of trial sessions and see how he gets on.

xRobin · 26/01/2025 05:24

Move him!
I moved my daughter, albeit into Year 3 (September just gone) and I was super anxious whether I was making the right decision too.
She’s quite shy too.
The school was much closer (still unable to walk or ride, have to drive) but it means she’ll end up going to high school with those new children too.
She absolutely loves it. The teachers have been so good to her and have said how she made friends instantly.
If it means he’ll have the freedom he wants in Y6, he’ll have a whole year of getting to know these new kids before heading off to high school, it’ll be great for him.
Good luck x

Tohaveandtohold · 26/01/2025 05:34

Move him. I wish I’d moved DD1 in those circumstances too. I worried too much about how she’d cope and did 2 primary school run for a year and it was manic (because DD2 started at the brilliant pry school close to home when DD1 was in year 6 at the previous pry school). She is shy and we worried she would miss her friends, etc. she started at the secondary school closer to us now without knowing anyone and we were so worried but she made new friends from her transition day. We were pleasantly surprised. She does not even talk much to her pry school friends anymore because she has a new solid group of friends who are all lovely. We wished we didn’t worry

pincklop · 26/01/2025 05:37

Does he want to move? It's definitely the best idea. Change is always scary but he will adapt quickly and make new friends. Friends he can then walk to the park with Or see after school. You know it's right but it's so scary to commit thinking it might be the wrong plan it's easier to do nothing. You have to go for it x

Silvertulips · 26/01/2025 05:43

I worked in a school and to be fair Al the kids are amazing at welcoming new children.

They show them round the school, play at play time, if he’s a footballer he’ll definitely make friends.

There are usually clubs to join.

I moved DD in year 5 and had 3 drop offs at different schools for a year but it worked.

DrivingMyselfUpTheWall123 · 26/01/2025 10:02

Thanks so much all - really appreciate hearing others experiences!

His application is in and he’s on board - he certainly wasn’t and burst into tears the first time it was discussed but he was happier after the tour. The decisive factors for him was that project based homework (which he cannot stand!) was optional haha!

My anxieties are what they are but as someone correctly mentioned above, my anxieties shouldn’t get in my son’s way or impact what’s best for him. I definitely need to just get a grip :)

OP posts:
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 26/01/2025 12:26

Let him visit and see what he thinks. Do NOT let on that you're anxious or he'll smell it.

Reassure him that you'll continue to facilitate play dates with his old pals and do that - if it's only 40 mins away I'm sure he'll still get party invites etc. I remember way back to when I was in primary school quite a few children moved in year 5/6 (I guess to get closer to preferred secondaries) and we still invited them to sleepovers and kept in touch with the ones we like, they even came to our leavers disco.

Mumdiva99 · 26/01/2025 14:22

Good luck . I moved my daughter in year 5 similar circumstances. (We moved as eldest was in y6 so didn't move him when he left tried to get younger 2 into local school. I was nervous but I think the best thing for my daughter. She went to secondary knowing way more people. She did more transition activities. She settled as well as she could considering we went into lockdown soon after the move.

TeddyBeans · 26/01/2025 14:29

If it helps OP, I work in a mixed 5/6 class and we had a new year 6 pupil join after Christmas. They're very shy and quiet but have been included in playtimes and lunchtimes from the get go. I'm sure your son will be absolutely fine and it sounds like you'd make home life much more enjoyable as well. Go for it!

Mischance · 26/01/2025 14:32

My GS moved schools for Year 6 for several reasons - all went fine. A nearby school with a cohort likely to go to the same secondary sounds good.

Snorlaxo · 26/01/2025 14:33

I would move him.

My son started year 6 in a new school and he was not the only new starter. When he started secondary, it meant that he knew others starting and that he could spend school holidays with friends too. No regrets here

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread