Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private school payments

8 replies

Tinkerbellsmum84 · 13/01/2025 20:42

Bear with me this might be a long one…

A short history first…I have a 10 year old daughter to my ex, i left him on the day I left hospital after having her 10 years ago due to domestic abuse. Mostly emotional but physical on the night I left. Fast forward 10 years, 7 of which we spent back & forwards to family court, and communication between us is still fraught with difficulties due to his need to control things. Needless to say, I have set boundaries which I am strict on after years of therapy and CBT for what I have been told is PTSD from the relationship. Anyway, my little girl has always seen her dad and on a 2 week basis she sees him 6nights out of 14.
He lives almost 30 miles from where I moved to with our newborn, but has property all over the region and has the option to live around 7 miles from where we are but doesn’t (i believe its a status thing, he describes my local area like its some kind of slum).

My 10 year old has come to me panicking about going to high school and which one she will go to in year 7 (she has just started year 5 so we have another year to think about it). I just assumed she would want to go to the local school with all of her friends so said thats where she would go. She’s really upset that, quote: “thats not fair mum because for the last 10 years dad has had to do all of the driving to take me to school when i stay there and you really need to step up and do done of the driving now so i want to go to school [in the local area where dad lives] for 2 years and then go to the school where all of my friends will go after that”

I’ve explained that when she is in high school she’ll be making her own way there from our house, i work 4 days a week, her older step sisters have always got the schollars bus to school and she has a younger brother who will start school next year who i will have to drop off, so driving her to school where her dad lives isn’t an option for me.

she has also suggested that her dad would send her to private school…now this doesn’t surprise me as he has always tried for that but it was court ordered that she would go to a local school when she turned 4.
Logistically, the private schools are all in the city centre where we live and its about half way between our houses. It would make sense for her to go to school in the city centre. My issue is that there is no way on gods green earth I could afford to contribute to private education. He’s not directly said it to me yet but I know its coming!

Her dad has never financially contributed to her, even when he saw her less. My solicitor when she was born helped me apply to the CSA and according to them he earns less then £7 a week, claims no benefits so is eligible to pay £0.00.
He owns a business and a property portfolio. Any time i have ever asked him for help in the past he has been non committal and nothing has materialised.

So…would it be unreasonable when he asks to agree but on the understanding that I couldn’t contribute to the annual fee’s and expect him to be able to prove that he could pay for it??

I think he will say absolutely not, but with 4 children, a mortgage and bills to pay, there is no way I could afford to contribute but from what my poor daughter has said it sounds like he won’t be agreeing to her going to her local school because he might have to drive her there 🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
MyrtleLion · 14/01/2025 00:54

If he can afford the fees for private school, he can afford to pay maintenance. I'd go along with it for now until you have a letter or email from him saying he'll pay the fees, preferably a chain that includes the school name and the fee amount.

Then take that to your lawyer and claim via the CSA. As you've already claimed from them, you might even get it backdated.

In case you weren't aware the words your daughter spoke about it being unfair that he's driven for 10 years and it's your "turn", he's primed her to say that.

This is financial abuse.

Tinkerbellsmum84 · 14/01/2025 12:10

thank you for your reply, I have evidence of abuse continuing to this day but unfortunately no one is interested, as long as my daughter gets to see her dad. I’ve come to accept that unfortunately!

I have no faith in anyone taking his behaviour into account when a decision comes to be made :(

OP posts:
MyrtleLion · 14/01/2025 12:14

I'm so sorry he's doing this to you. 😢

Letlooseonthedanse · 14/01/2025 12:48

Send her to the state school. She’ll be better off there.
Plus you won’t have the stress of him holding the fees over you for years as something to control you/ her with.

Letlooseonthedanse · 14/01/2025 12:49

And obvs - if he can afford fees then he can afford money towards his child too. Tell him he’ll need a full assessment done, that should slow him down.

Sparkleandglitter · 14/01/2025 12:55

Even if he agrees to pay the full amount I’d take it to court if necessary to ensure she goes to the school of your/her choice.
Once she’s at private school and settled it’ll be very distressing and disruptive for her to move (she’ll make friends there and will start exams etc, it’ll be much harder to just move in secondary than it was in primary school).
If he’s abusive then he’ll use that to control her and you. Every time she does something he doesn’t like he’ll threaten to stop paying, e.g. ‘dump that boyfriend or I won’t pay your fees’ or ‘I’m paying for the school so you’ll take French rather than music for GCSE’.
If you can’t afford to take over paying then it’s a recipe for disaster and her being stuck in a very difficult situation.

No court is going to allow him to force you to send her to private school on the basis of him paying the fees when he claims not to have any money.

Friendships move on quickly in the early teen years. It’ll be a total pain to move her in 2 years. I’d try to persuade her of the benefits of just going where her friends are going (as long as it’s a school you’re happy with).

Tinkerbellsmum84 · 14/01/2025 16:17

I really appreciate everyones replies.

its not until I’ve written it down and read your opinions that I realise he’s now trying to control things through our Daughter. She’s so taken in by him, but then you are when you’re 10!!

The feeder school her friends will go to is a good school with a great reputation.
I’m seriously considering getting the ball rolling again with court again. I had a great solicitor when we did it last time so hopefully she will remember us and give some helpful advice.

Such a big stress which anyone could do without!!

OP posts:
MyrtleLion · 14/01/2025 17:09

Tinkerbellsmum84 · 14/01/2025 16:17

I really appreciate everyones replies.

its not until I’ve written it down and read your opinions that I realise he’s now trying to control things through our Daughter. She’s so taken in by him, but then you are when you’re 10!!

The feeder school her friends will go to is a good school with a great reputation.
I’m seriously considering getting the ball rolling again with court again. I had a great solicitor when we did it last time so hopefully she will remember us and give some helpful advice.

Such a big stress which anyone could do without!!

I think you should go to court. He obviously has money and he should be paying - it's his responsibility to support her welfare. You can get them to check his income tax records for his declared income. If he doesn't have any declared income via HMRC then you might want to let them know he's offered to pay school fees....

New posts on this thread. Refresh page