Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think with min wage going up 6.7% that

173 replies

Frugalcheesecake · 17/11/2024 18:58

Minimum wage is going up 6.7% next year. My pay has gone up by tiny amounts in comparison to this and is stagnating some years compared to inflation. I only earn a bit above min wage and I find my job very stressful.

Yes I know some minimum wage jobs are stressful but Ive done some that are easy too. AIBU to think that if min wage gets close to your wage a lot of people will quit just to get an easier min wage job if they can find one that is less stress

OP posts:
OtterlyMad · 17/11/2024 19:39

buffyspikefaithangel · 17/11/2024 19:33

People on minimum wage can have student loans too you know? I'm still paying mine back. And yes I have a degree
No I don't stack shelves or clean toilets

Of course I know that, it’s a travesty.

woolflower · 17/11/2024 19:40

TortieRage · 17/11/2024 19:28

If you're on min wage you woukdnt be earning enough to be paying back student lone. Stop being so hyperbolic.

With the increase, if you’re on minimum wage working a 40 hour week it’s possible to be paying student loan back.

Pre-2012 and post-2023 loans pay back on anything about £24/£25k.

Riapia · 17/11/2024 19:42

There is no difference in the price of a loaf of bread no matter what the buyer earns.

BrendaSmall · 17/11/2024 19:43

The more people earn the more tax/insurance they have to pay, so really won’t be better off in the long run!

roastiepotato · 17/11/2024 19:44

Riapia · 17/11/2024 19:42

There is no difference in the price of a loaf of bread no matter what the buyer earns.

There is a difference between Tesco value and the local artisan bakery sourdough

MereDintofPandiculation · 17/11/2024 19:45

shelf stacker in tesco Does this job actually exist? Most supermarket staff are expected to stack shelves in addition to their main role.

When you add in that they find it difficult to organise a social life because rotas come out a week in advance if you’re lucky (try arranging your mum’s100th birthday celebration if favourite grandson doesn’t know which day he can make it), they are daily facing shoplifters, being threatened with physical violence is not unusual, they are expected to work bank holidays with no extra pay … yes, I imagine people will be flocking to take up supermarket jobs.

user1471543683 · 17/11/2024 19:50

I’ve worked for 32 years annd currently earn £17 per hours as a Nursery nurse in a school. I did two years at college. My son is 21 and earns 12.02 working in Tesco (will be £12.21 cone April) My job is stressful and I feel like I’d be better off just going to a supermarket. Less stress

MereDintofPandiculation · 17/11/2024 19:53

in fact, once my student loan gets deducted from my monthly pay cheque, I’ll be earning even less than them! That’s a mathematical impossibility? Student loan is repayable once you earn a particular sum, say S. You then pay back a proportion of your earnings over S. So instead of getting S+a fair bit, you now get S + a little bit. And since S is itself above full time minimum wage (because you're earning above minimum wage but haven’t yet reached S), then S+ a little bit is certainly above minimum wage.

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 17/11/2024 19:55

Teaching assistants with twenty years experience are now on two pound more than sixteen year old supermarket shelf stackers. True story.

Mumof2girls2121 · 17/11/2024 19:59

The government can raise minimum wage and expect employers to find the cash but won’t give that sort of rise to public sector nurses, council officers, TAs

OtterlyMad · 17/11/2024 20:10

MereDintofPandiculation · 17/11/2024 19:53

in fact, once my student loan gets deducted from my monthly pay cheque, I’ll be earning even less than them! That’s a mathematical impossibility? Student loan is repayable once you earn a particular sum, say S. You then pay back a proportion of your earnings over S. So instead of getting S+a fair bit, you now get S + a little bit. And since S is itself above full time minimum wage (because you're earning above minimum wage but haven’t yet reached S), then S+ a little bit is certainly above minimum wage.

That’s true. Making it obvious my degree wasn’t in maths!

Chan9eusername · 17/11/2024 20:17

Yes some people will choose lower stress jobs, and this will tend to push the pay up in higher stress ones. Sort of the point really.

Dymaxion · 17/11/2024 20:57

Yes some people will choose lower stress jobs, and this will tend to push the pay up in higher stress ones. Sort of the point really.

Not sure about this, I deal with life and death situations almost on a daily basis, usually completely on my own, which is quite stressful as you can imagine, make the wrong decision and somebody might die or suffer life changing consequences, the pay for this is the princely sum of £34,000 gross ! That's with 20 years of experience doing the job as well !
I do think jobs where the answer to the question ' could somebody die in the next few hours, if I get this wrong' is yes, should probably be paid more than someone who never has to face that level of stress.

KendraTheVampyrSlayer · 17/11/2024 21:12

The problem is people being paid poorly in the first place. I earn just above MW (literally 31p above) in a pretty stressful job I hate. Looking at other jobs out there, I found one that required a degree (which I don't have even though I could do the job) for £15ph. How the hell can they justify paying someone with a degree less than £4 more per hour above MW?

StevieNic · 17/11/2024 21:26

They are giving lower grades a 4.5% pay rise at my organisation and only 2.5 to those on my grade and up. So things are harder and harder every year for me even though I’ve got degrees out of my ears and a difficult job with responsibility. Wage increases should be the same % across the board!

Walkden · 18/11/2024 04:03

"I do think jobs where the answer to the question ' could somebody die in the next few hours, if I get this wrong' is yes, should probably be paid more than someone who never has to face that level of stress."

Well not sure this is going to happen until doctors and nurses and the like make profits !

Most high pay professions generate revenue at least 3 times their salary. NHS work is very stressful but there is a fixed amount of cash available for salaries....

bluebalou · 18/11/2024 05:09

Littlebitpsycho · 17/11/2024 19:04

Yep, I always say this. The answer isn't to keep raising the minimum wage (although I don't know what the actual answer is either)

The fact that some highly skilled jobs that take years to train for will be paid close to a shelf stacker in tesco is ridiculous.

It's taking away any incentive to work hard and get qualifications. I wouldn't bother if I knew I could get similar money and less stress working on checkouts 🤷‍♀️

This is so true the pay gap is getting smaller to the point where you have to think if you're stressful and what was classed as a decent wage is worth it..

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 18/11/2024 05:11

I'm in local government, and we have all got a flat £1290 pay rise. I've calculated that to be 6.2% of my full time wage. Seems reasonable.

Sugarflub · 18/11/2024 05:13

LittleRedRidingHoody · 17/11/2024 19:07

I think the idea is other salaries will continue to inflate also. So retail supervisors who are about £1 over NMW will then also rise to continue being that, and it will trickle upwards. Not everyone will raise salaries obviously, but enough will that if you're stagnant, there are options to move.

But NMW is the only one the govt controls, so it makes sense to start there.

But NMW is the only one the govt controls, so it makes sense to start there.

They also control public sector pay, but the difference between the lower grades is ridiculously small now in a lot of departments; they don't care.

Sugarflub · 18/11/2024 05:15

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 18/11/2024 05:11

I'm in local government, and we have all got a flat £1290 pay rise. I've calculated that to be 6.2% of my full time wage. Seems reasonable.

Look forward to pur council tax going up record amounts as green lighted by labour to cover it.

autienotnoughty · 18/11/2024 05:18

It's great that minimum wage is going up but it doesn't address the issues of how do employers afford it. I'm a couple bands above nmw and my wage has gone up 5k in past 3 years to allow for a difference (albeit a smaller one) my manager (who has significantly more responsibility than me) has seen her wage increase by 3k. So now she earns less that 2k more than me. It's not really worth the extra grief

tedx · 18/11/2024 05:36

In 2020, I was working as an executive administrator for a college so organising board meetings and the associated tasks around that etc . I also organised and took minutes at several types of management meetings..I had a lot of deadlines, some legal too.

I earned 12p more than the cleaner.

Oblomov24 · 18/11/2024 06:35

I don't think the 'lower grades a 4.5% pay rise and only 2.5 % to higher grades' is a good idea either.

Agix · 18/11/2024 06:36

If people feel their job is too stressful and doesn't pay enough to warrant it, and they feel they want to move to working in a supermarket because it pays about the same and is much less stress, then they should just... you know, do that?

Don't see the issue. Start applying for Tesco. Apparently much less stress and you won't even take a paycut. Your life has now improved!

NQOCDarling · 18/11/2024 06:40

Littlebitpsycho · 17/11/2024 19:04

Yep, I always say this. The answer isn't to keep raising the minimum wage (although I don't know what the actual answer is either)

The fact that some highly skilled jobs that take years to train for will be paid close to a shelf stacker in tesco is ridiculous.

It's taking away any incentive to work hard and get qualifications. I wouldn't bother if I knew I could get similar money and less stress working on checkouts 🤷‍♀️

Why does one need an incentive?
Surely if you have a brain, training for a job, keeping yourself apprised of new research, etc in your job, and contributing, is satisfying?