Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel apprehensive about moving into DP’s family home?

40 replies

Monkeytrousers04 · 23/08/2024 20:07

DP has recently inherited his mum’s house. It is a beautiful house, the DCs love it and whilst it’s 30 mins away from where we live now, with a bit more planning/ organisation it shouldn’t impact too much on our daily routines of driving the DCs to/ from school and us getting to work. I WFH 95% of the time and DP will be going back to work more of a hybrid model when he eventually returns.

Our house is too small for our needs now and at various points over the years, we’ve thought about moving and did have the house on the market for a while, but DP’s mum’s diagnosis (and Liz Truss’s mini-budget) put a stop to those plans pretty sharpish.

The house is the only family home he has ever known. He’s had every Xmas there since the age of two and it will be a huge wrench to sell it and move on. That said, he has often talked about selling it and our house and buying an amazing house for us all so he’s not 100% against the idea.

We’ve been spending quite a bit of time there since his mum died and despite my thinking the opposite, the DCs have loved it and never want to leave when we are there. They talk about how living there would mean they could have their own rooms (younger two currently share) and it’s safe enough for us to let our cats out and we could get a dog and generally I think enjoy a better quality of life.

We wouldn’t want to change schools so until the youngest leaves primary in 6 years time it will be a bit of a bind getting to/ from school each day. Where we are now we manage without child care as I finish work at 3pm but I wouldn’t make it in time for pick up if we moved 30 mins away. We would have to use a childminder for school pick up each day. DC1 starts secondary school next week and there is a train she can get, so once they are all there it will be fine.

So overall it feels like a good plan but the house needs a lot of work, definitely a new kitchen (DP agrees on this) and the bathrooms need sorting out (I think he agrees on this too). IMO all the bedrooms need new carpets, and given that all the downstairs carpets are cream I’d be inclined to change them too. BUT anytime I start a conversation along these lines DP gets defensive and thinks I want to change everything, which I don’t. I don’t think it’s because it’s too soon either, as we’ve talked about it in the past and it always end up with us agreeing to disagree, and the conversation never concludes. His parents had lovely taste in furniture overall. The only thing I’d like to change are the sofas as they are very traditional (and also cream). Our sofas at home are knackered so it would involve buying new ones which DP says is a waste of money. I’d also like to keep my dining table, I bought it for myself for my 40th birthday. Had it made especially to fit my kitchen with reclaimed oak and a matching bench and I saved up for months to get it. If we designed the kitchen right it would look amazing but again, DP wants to keep both the dining tables and chairs (there is one in the dining room and one in the kitchen currently). I agree that the dining room one is lovely but the kitchen one, whilst a quality piece of furniture is not really to my taste…

I suppose I’m asking how do I navigate all this? I’ve longed for a nice big family home for so long (DP has had to be dragged along to house viewings and has always said he’s happy where we are). I want to host Christmases with my family, I want the kids to be able to have friends over and sleep overs, and host their birthday parties at home, etc. etc. and also do some entertaining of our own - we always go to our friends houses and never invite them to ours as it’s so small and cluttered.

I’m also nervous about having no real stake in the house either? If we sell ours and pay off the mortgage then any left over will just go into the family pot so essentially I’ll have no assets to call my own, etc. what if our relationship ends - he could just kick me out?!

I do at least 90% of the household chores too so part of me is worried that unless I can find a way to be able to talk to DP about making some small changes/ improvements to his DP’s house, I’d essentially be living in his house, decorated to his (ie his DM’s) liking, doing all the housework with nothing to show for it at the end. We’re not married so unless he specifies in his will, it’d all pass to DC1 on his death as well.

Does anyone have and advice on this? Has anyone else been in a similar position?

OP posts:
pinkfleece · 23/08/2024 20:12

Hmm. Sounds like it's going to be a shrine. Be careful.

itsgettingweird · 23/08/2024 20:13

Can you rent your other house out?

Tell him you don't want to sell a joint asset as you aren't married.

With regards the rest I think you need to slow down on some of the changes.

What matters to you most? I'm guessing the dining table. Make that the thing you focus on and so he doesn't focus on everything changing.

SilverBranchGoldenPears · 23/08/2024 20:14

I‘m watching with interest as I’m going to find myself shortly in the same position. I have serious qualms. No advice but ready to hear some!

ShortColdandGrey · 23/08/2024 20:15

You need to tell him that if you are moving in you need to be able to make it feel like your family home, and not a shrine to his parents. You can keep some pieces of their furniture but you need to make it your own home. If he can't do that then I would not be moving in.

Straightouttachelmsford · 23/08/2024 20:15

If you're not married, then yes, he can make you homeless with no notice & no compensation.

Your share of the current house should remain separate.

Butterflyfern · 23/08/2024 20:18

I wouldn't move unless you are added to the deeds and the home becomes jointly owned (or tenants I'm common). And don't move in until the legalities are signed. I assume you have no plans to marry?

I also would be very wary of moving into a home where he has such strong emotional attachment. He has to understand that this is to become your joint family home. It's not a museum to his parents and childhood. I'd probably want some of the changes made before you actually move in, so he can't back down once you're stuck there. (Ie old sofas sold, kitchen table sold, new carpets and the kids rooms redecorated would be my minimum I think. With the understanding that I would also be redecorating elsewhere as required)

SprigatitoYouAndIKnow · 23/08/2024 20:27

If you sell both, could you get a nice and big enough house in your current area? Kids might prefer this option as 6 yearsbof long commute to a primary school is quite a slog.

Selling and having no stake in his inhereted house isn't great, as it leaves you asset poor. But equally, having to force a sell if you separate would be an extra kick in the teeth. would you ever marry? Can you wait 6-12 months before any decisions are made? Then emotions are less raw.

Allie47 · 23/08/2024 20:35

You shouldn't have a family pot if you're not married, you need to split your finances. You get added to the deeds of the new house or you take your half from your house sale and put it into an account in your name.

MostlyHappyMummy · 23/08/2024 20:40

Do you jointly own your current home?

Icanttakethisanymore · 23/08/2024 20:42

This will be difficult. To him it’s not just a house, it’s not just a dining table, nor just a sofa. It’s his family home and it’s the only thing he has left. Yoh shouldnt have to live in a shrine to his mum / family / childhood but equally he’s grieving so obviously you need to be sensitive. Could you agree to park some of your decorating / upgrading plans until next year perhaps? Maybe also have an honest conversation with him about the possibility that a clean break might be better? Could you look at other houses and discuss that?

good luck, I don’t envy you.

Lindjam · 23/08/2024 20:44

As you aren’t married I would not be comfortable with this set up.

Sell both houses and buy something in both your names. The DC will be just as excited about a new house, and the additional commute sounds like a pain.

AShortName · 23/08/2024 20:46

We did this. Just make sure your name is on the deeds as equal owner. Also be clear that you will be updating/ making changes as needed. At least you will know its full history.

AgnesX · 23/08/2024 20:47

I wouldn't. There are two many memories tied up in that house. You need somewhere of your own to start afresh.

Ponoka7 · 23/08/2024 20:48

With great difficulty men get rid of sentimental stuff after 50, so it's now or never on the clearing out. I agree with the shrine comment. It doesn't sound as though he sees it as a joint home. In his head it's his mum's house.

Meadowfinch · 23/08/2024 20:48

If you aren't married, there is no family pot. Don't be fooled.

I moved into my ex' family home and we lasted 12 months because he also refused to change anything, and expected me to fit into the domestic-shaped hole left by his mum.

I'd not be going anywhere without being 50:50 on the deeds, or married.

DillyDilly · 23/08/2024 21:01

I wouldn’t move into the house as things stand, you’ll just feel like a guest.

JanefromLondon1 · 23/08/2024 21:16

I'd say I'm either up for selling both and buying the amazing home you both agree on or you get put on the mortgage/deeds for his parents house but you have to be able to make it your home, unequivocally state that you are not living in a house where you aren't allowed to put your stamp on it.

Those are the choices.

gamerchick · 23/08/2024 21:23

Is his mother's death recent? It's too soon to be talking about moving in and changing things. It's hard to let go and takes time.

I think I'd say there will be no selling of the house you're in for now and see how it goes. But he'll have to be open to changing the house to suit the family needs eventually or it won't work. In that case it'll be back to the original plan of selling both.

Ponderingwindow · 23/08/2024 21:28

i was reading along just assuming you were married and your name was going on the deed.

I would not move in this situation. You should be an equal owner of the family home legally.

if he decides it is worth resolving that,

you should also have equal say in how the family home is set up. That is at least something you can work on. I would start with not moving in until the messier repairs and redecorating are done.

FictionalCharacter · 23/08/2024 21:40

Meadowfinch · 23/08/2024 20:48

If you aren't married, there is no family pot. Don't be fooled.

I moved into my ex' family home and we lasted 12 months because he also refused to change anything, and expected me to fit into the domestic-shaped hole left by his mum.

I'd not be going anywhere without being 50:50 on the deeds, or married.

This. As it stands, it's his house (which he still sees as his mum's) and you're very vulnerable and have no control. Already it isn't looking good, with him getting defensive when you want to change anything. You'll never be an equal partner in this house.

MounjaroUser · 23/08/2024 21:52

You're in an incredibly vulnerable financial position. Can't he see that?

I would say to him that unless you get married, you'll have to see a lawyer about this, but that you'd rather stay put than live in a house that's a shrine to his mum.

Createausername1970 · 23/08/2024 22:06

We did this, but DH was on the same wavelength as me. I didn't want to live in a shrine.

We did have some interior works carried out before we moved in, and changed the layout and moved the bedrooms around. I wasn't, in any circumstances, sleeping in what was their bedroom and thankfully DH felt the same.

We have their nik-naks scattered through the house, but it was redecorated throughout, all carpets and curtains were changed, and the furniture is either our existing furniture or new. It is our home, and feels very much "our" home.

OP - if your partner is unwilling to change even basic decor, I would be very nervous of moving in. Even with your name on the deeds, it's going to be "his" home and not yours.

CitronellaDeVille · 23/08/2024 22:08

If we sell ours and pay off the mortgage then any left over will just go into the family pot so essentially I’ll have no assets to call my own, etc. what if our relationship ends - he could just kick me out?!

This is the most important issue here.

For the rest, can you afford to leave it a little while? It is such a wrench saying goodbye to a much loved family house after the loss of your parents.

If you do decide to live there your DP would need some time to make the transition from it being his parents house to yours. But in time of course it would need to be fitted and furnished for the next generation: you. Including your lovely dining table and bench.

Could you suggest spending a month if school term there, making sure he does his share of the school run? Am I right in thinking the school run would be a round trip of an hour, twice a day? No way would I do that!

Hunglikeapolevaulter · 23/08/2024 22:11

I'd want to be legally married, and I'd want to be able to refresh the house decor. Otherwise no go on moving to that house.

buttonsB4 · 23/08/2024 22:21

Sooo many negatives to this move.

You lose your financial security.

Half an hour drive to school each day (is that on a good day or in school run traffic?)

Having to sort childcare that you currently don't need.

Having to take on more housework (not sure why you're carrying the burden of this currently- misogyny I presume?)

Not having a say in how to decorate

Not being able to keep the furniture you love and worked hard to get.

But mostly, losing your financial security. Never, ever give that up, you and your kids could end up homeless, that would be a terrible mistake.

Swipe left for the next trending thread