A few observations:
There is a lot of nastiness and foolishness on this thread
There are the posters who say that I shouldn't be taking my child to these luxury places because other people want to enjoy it in peace.
Then there are those who sneer and say that I'm not actually going to luxurious places.
Re the digs about boasting. No - you are wrong. If you want holiday ideas you need to specify a budget. I realise DD is special only to her family and not to others. She's by no means perfect. She IS however a happy, settled child. She DOES travel well. That's not a boast - just a fact. Lots of children are like that and it's not unusual. People do comment that she does well when travelling. I'm not suggesting people queue up to tell us she's wonderful but other guests and people on flights have commented that she's such a happy little thing.
To be clear:
We don't expect child-free. We used to stay in adults only hotels because we wanted to avoid children.
We're now looking for places that attract a varied demographic. Where we've stayed with DD on the three holidays we've had, we've found maybe a handful of families at mealtimes. That's perfectly fine - ideal actually. Other guests have to live with that when staying in a resort that doesn't exclude children. If they can't they should book adults only hotels to ensure that their hotel meets their needs.
What I don't want is a hotel that's entirely populated by families such that mealtimes are like a softplay cafe. I have no obligation to book those sort of places. I don't want a "children's buffet" as DD doesn't need that. She eats what we eat at home. I don't want a hotel with water slides etc as that will attract predominately families which we wouldn't enjoy.
To those saying we shouldn't book certain places so as not to disturb guests - we book the holiday that suits our family. We don't book our holiday, which my husband and I work hard to pay for, based on what it would suit others for us to do for our holidays. Others need to book the holiday that meets their needs - it's their responsibility do that. It's not my responsibility to ensure that I don't take my child to a hotel that would welcome her just in case another guest is displeased. If they can't possibly cope with a handful of children in the hotel then they should book adults only hotels just as we did in the past. There's nothing selfish about that - just the practical reality.
To those saying we won't enjoy places that aren't family resorts - you're definitely wrong and sound quite sheltered. Children at DD's age don't need anything special to entertain them. A pool and a beach and gardens to run around in is perfect. I bet these are the sort of poster who think children eat chicken nuggets and chips.
We do tend to book the shoulder season and tend to go in early June or mid/late September with the exception of the Maldvies which we visited in March. DD was one of a handful of children there and was welcomed with open arms. It was a honeymoon type resort and didn't have child specific facilities but they provided cribs and high chairs and a steriliser. That's all we needed.
To those suggesting we want to fob DD off to anyone who'll take her - definitely not. DD will be with us at all times on holiday. We don't want babysitters or kids clubs. Days are about her - mealtimes, beach, pool, playing etc. Yes it's hard work but we enjoy it. We chill on our outdoor terrace attached to our room while DD naps inside a few feet a way, with eyes on her at all times. (The poster asking about intruders or fires has clearly never seen this sort of set up and I think had in mind that we were several stories down at the main pool rather than a few feet away watching through a glass door) DD goes to bed at 7pm after bathtime at home. We do the same routine and then put her down to sleep at that time and she adapts really well. We then have dinner and maybe a cocktail. If she wakes, she joins us briefly until we finish dinner and we go back to our room. We then settle her and sit out on our terrace with a drink and get to bed at a decent time ready to be up early with DD. Mostly she sleeps through in her pram with some white noise.