Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

British kids and eating habits - IABU ?

895 replies

lovemycoffee2 · 23/07/2024 16:17

I have two young kids and we live in the UK but we are not originally from here.

At home we cook everyday from scratch our food and we take that food at a lunch box at our workplace. We have a light dinner again made from scratch.

The issue is our kids which are of course going to school/nursery and they love to copy their friends!

In the UK it's healthy if a kid eats sausages (god knows what the meat has inside), or for example Heinz baked beans which have 10% sugar and 20% salt (leaving 70% being actual beans) or if they eat fish fingers which are pre-fried (even if you bake them they were already fried before got frozen) or chicken nuggets (again pre-fried which god knows what was the oil quality).

It's also acceptable to drink juices which have no sugar but plenty sweeteners.

Also, it's perfectly fine to have a ham sandwich for lunch which has ready made processed bread full of emulsifiers and ham which (like sausage) god knows what ingredients has.

It's ok that primary schools offer desserts, even if they are small portions and low sugar on a daily basis - not on a weekly or as special occasion! I don't have a dessert everyday, why my kid is offered one?

Honestly, are all these things ok? Am I paranoid?

I am very worried that the kids will either end up obsessed. with diabetes or with other health issues given all the processed food and the fact that we are what we eat.

YABU - are you crazy?

YANBU - unfortunately this is a "balanced healthy diet" in the UK!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
AzureAnt · 23/07/2024 17:52

Gofo · 23/07/2024 17:44

To be honest I work with the elderly and it’s pretty grim once you get past 80. I wouldn’t worry too much. I want out by then.

Oh god me too. Nobody seems.to allowed to pass peacefully anymore. When I get to that age, if I have capacity I will have a DNAR and no life lengthening treatments x

DeathpunchDan · 23/07/2024 17:52

Maccy D's may call it a Royale with Cheese in Paris...but it's still a fast food cheeseburger and a goujon is a European cousin of the fish finger.
It's a good job you didn't live here in the 1970s, Toast Toppers and Findus crispy pancakes were often served.

Blushingm · 23/07/2024 17:52

lovemycoffee2 · 23/07/2024 17:07

I got the numbers wrong on baked beans but still... out of 125 ml there are 7 grams sugar, which is about 6%.

And if you read the ingredients one by one you read "sugar". Why would you give beans with sugar to your kids and not just boil some beans? It doesn't take long and is not so artificially sweet too...

We come from South Europe by the way

As you can tell from the label this tin wasn't made for the British market - British Heinz ingredients are different

parkrun500club · 23/07/2024 17:53

I don't like baked beans, they are horrible. But they are not a bad option for a quick meal like beans on toast or a not-quick but simple meal like beans and a jacket potato.

I did grow up with fish fingers and chips but I do like salad and I eat a LOT of it (not your MN version of salad). So kids might have a beige diet but most grow out of it. Even my son will eat salad now.

In Italy it's easier, after all they can live on pasta/pizza and ice cream Grin

AzureAnt · 23/07/2024 17:53

DeathpunchDan · 23/07/2024 17:52

Maccy D's may call it a Royale with Cheese in Paris...but it's still a fast food cheeseburger and a goujon is a European cousin of the fish finger.
It's a good job you didn't live here in the 1970s, Toast Toppers and Findus crispy pancakes were often served.

I loved all these 😁

CatrionaBalfour · 23/07/2024 17:53

Been there, @AtomicBlondeRose . Mine went through a bit of a phase with bad food and I honestly didn't know where we'd gone wrong. A few years later it was all fine. Now they're adults who eat well. It'll be ok!

Safaribar · 23/07/2024 17:53

biscuitandcake · 23/07/2024 17:36

Its true!
I am raising my children on the continent and his first words were "mother, please may I have more foccacia" (but in foreign).
The idea that children naturally have tantrums/are prone to misbehaviour is just something Bri'ish people believe because they are too oafish to know better.

lol

Wheredidileavemycarkeys · 23/07/2024 17:54

lovemycoffee2 · 23/07/2024 17:24

The problem to me is how do I make my kid want to take the lunch box which has no fancy pudding and not to have a drama about it in the morning , while knowing that the X,Y,Z best friend will have school lunch because 1. it's free 2. it's the easiest for the parents of the X,Y,Z kid?

Again, I am talking about 4 year olds!

I mean 4 year olds don’t have much understanding of why things happen the way they do. Surely it’s just a matter if time before they make a fuss about something.

If this is important to you then give them a packed lunch with the foods you approve of. If it isn’t then don’t bother 🤷‍♀️

hastingsmax · 23/07/2024 17:54

@BellesAndGraces no, I'm just not a complete health loon.

Rufus27 · 23/07/2024 17:54

Jazz7 · 23/07/2024 17:17

What nonsense to damn all uk parents like this. Not many eat these things exclusively and provided the home diet is mostly good they do no harm from time to time. You are very judgemental from a position of little knowledge of the mass of the uk population. Most parents do the best they can within their budgets. Your fixation with food is more of a worry in case it causes your children eating problems in the future if you must pontificate at least get your facts right eg Heinz baked beans

This.

ohtowinthelottery · 23/07/2024 17:55

@Safaribar The local Primary school here is 1/2 mile from our estate. The majority of the children are driven to school in spite of there being pavements all the way and no main roads to cross.

I passed the local swing park earlier. There were no children in it. It's a dry, bright, sunny afternoon.

I can only assume they're all sat inside playing on screens.

Zanatdy · 23/07/2024 17:55

lovemycoffee2 · 23/07/2024 17:24

The problem to me is how do I make my kid want to take the lunch box which has no fancy pudding and not to have a drama about it in the morning , while knowing that the X,Y,Z best friend will have school lunch because 1. it's free 2. it's the easiest for the parents of the X,Y,Z kid?

Again, I am talking about 4 year olds!

Well that’s your job as a parent as you’re always going to have people who do different things to what you agree with when parenting. If you feel so strongly the obvious answer is packed lunch and you tell them that they have to eat what you provide. You’re not going to change the British cuisine so that’s your only choice surely, what else can you do?

loropianalover · 23/07/2024 17:55

lovemycoffee2 · 23/07/2024 17:13

Of course not! I just cook with either pure tomatoes or tomato puree and there is no sugar in there and I add no extra sugar too...

Malta is our origin for whoever is so interested 😁

Ok I had to stop reading here 🤣 I am sure other people have already commented on the irony of this.

I lived in Malta, Malta has a lot of unhealthy food habits!! Quite similar to the UK I would expect.

Dolly567 · 23/07/2024 17:55

What does a healthy weekly menu look like to you at home please, i actually need help with this .. kids have just had pizza and now I've seen this post i am consumed with guilt.
Dad works shifts so hard to cook with a toddler and a five year old wanting to just play out.

Blush
parkrun500club · 23/07/2024 17:56

Simonjt · 23/07/2024 17:51

Remember bananas are also pure sugar and will kill you, if you admit to eating one on the low carb thread you’ll be treated like an actual criminal.

I read a book recently about menopause and exercise and it said that you don't need to worry about the sugar in fruit (or sweeter vegetables) because of the fibre.

So I have now decreed that fruit has no calories and no sugar Grin

biscuitandcake · 23/07/2024 17:56

MammaMiaPizzeria · 23/07/2024 17:41

I'm from Sweden and I do agree with you OP. I moved here for uni and it was the first time I ever met adults who wouldn't eat veggies 😬 Like, I understand not liking something specific eg mushrooms or whatever, but I'm talking wouldn't eat any veggies at all unless they were blended into a sauce and therefore not visible to the naked eye. In contrast, we had salad with dinner every single day. We also never ate at restaurants and only had takeaway a few times a year, and it was always pizza which is a very big deal in Sweden. Here, everyone we know have at least one takeaway a week (including us!!). I think a large part of the reason for this is that people in the UK are largely overworked and underpaid, so there's simply not enough time or money to cook from scratch on a daily basis.

Having said that, it still horrifies me that the first time my child ever had something to drink that wasn't milk or water was at nursery - they gave him squash. The whole dessert with every meal thing annoys me too.

In all seriousness I also agree there are issues with the food culture in the UK. A lot of it is due to the issues you outlined and its not evenly spread. There is a theory that the speed of industrialisation in the UK killed of a lot of native food culture and the connection between the land and the food you eat. That combined with the massive push to make mass produced food available in the 50s onwards had a negative effect on people's eating habits. Also, when healthy eating did become a thing, it came from the top down so there was a certain disdain for "traditional" foods like stews, or they just weren't heard of anymore - groats etc are just as healthy as quinoa and traditionally much much cheaper.

Plus small children the world over are conservative in their tastes - they tend to like the same five meals rotated. So parents getting in a flap and thinking "healthy" eating = "sophisticated" and changing up the child's meals dramatically (see comment about disdain for normal foods) can make it worse - adults grow up associating healthy eating with being forced to eat "weird" (to a child) foods.

But the OPs comment on how shocking British nursery food is, is misplaced. It is worse in Malta (I know people with kids there). Possibly if she was still there, she would have had the same shock between her own food and the nursery's. And she is targeting the wrong thing - there is nothing wrong with baked beans as a small part of a balanced diet (see comment about disdain) and the "home cooked" puddings served by the nursery/school are usually deliberately low in sugar.

Also - there is a bit of "I am shocked that they can't make healthy food children will eat" combined with "my children won't eat my food, it must be the schools fault."

LadyFeatheringt0n · 23/07/2024 17:56

*Kids menu's on the continent are also significantly better - there are no chicken nuggets and pizza's; kids eat what adults eat, just smaller portions!

We also don't have a problem with children and tantrums. Somehow european kids palates are well developed and they simply don't want unhealthy stuff.*

You do realise lots of us travel regularly to the continent? France is full of boulangeries selling sugar laden cream cakes. Germans eat tons of sausages washed down with beer and plenty of bread, cakes and pastries.Spanish food includes plenty of chorizo and salty serrano, lashings of olive oil, cheeses etc.

Ive seen many a European child throw a tantrum. However I've also seen lots of tantrums avoided by parents in europe tolerating behaviour i wouldnt. Guess what - i don't assume all European parents are the same based on the limited sample I've seen and you shouldn't either.

tribalmango · 23/07/2024 17:56

Schools get a budget of about 1p and are then expected to feed children.
I can't imagine for a minute that the people in school kitchen believe they are serving up a healthy meal.

MyOtherCarisAVauxhallZafira · 23/07/2024 17:56

lovemycoffee2 · 23/07/2024 16:30

Last week's menu was:
Monday - beef with rice and nachos . A reception kid needs to eat nachos?
Tuesday - sausage . Honestly?
Wednesday - BBQ pulled pork in a bun - Sugar & emulsifiers
Thursday - Chicken , noodles - Ok, that's ok
Friday - Fish fingers

Of course they could have the veggie, or pasta or potato. Most veggies are not healthy too like crusts, spring rolls, sausages etc. Not excessively unhealthy but not super healthy and appropriate for a 4 year old.

If it was me lunch boxes should have some lean protein freshly cooked without sugars, bad oils etc. , some carbs on the side like rice/boiled potatoes without saturated fats and some fresh/steamed veggies and then fruit and/or yoghurt.

That's both your school and your child's choices, last week for us also reception was
Mon Squash and lentil lasagne with salad
Tues fish curry with rice green beans and baby corn
Weds ratatouille pasta with or without chicken and with salad
Thurs cous cous with veg chickpeas and salmon
Friday yes fish fingers, oven baked with peas but in the grand scheme of things I don't think terrible.
DS could've chosen other options that are more processed such as sausages but those are the choices he made because they are more similar to food at home.
We also cook from scratch every night and DH and I often take left overs or at the moment salads for work lunches.

RausageSoul · 23/07/2024 17:58

This is peak Mumsnet. Has anyone mentioned giving bullion as a snack yet?

tribalmango · 23/07/2024 17:59

Gofo · 23/07/2024 17:44

To be honest I work with the elderly and it’s pretty grim once you get past 80. I wouldn’t worry too much. I want out by then.

There are swathes of people past 80 who are living happy and healthy lives.
I want to be in their gang!

Sahara123 · 23/07/2024 18:00

NotAlexa · 23/07/2024 16:30

I hear you OP. I'm also from the continent and British kids (as adults too) have atrocious diets. I did not know what chocolate was until 7 years of age, and was only allowed fruit for the sweet tooth. To this day, I do not want chocolate, because I am not addicted to it like to an opioid.

Kids menu's on the continent are also significantly better - there are no chicken nuggets and pizza's; kids eat what adults eat, just smaller portions!

We also don't have a problem with children and tantrums. Somehow european kids palates are well developed and they simply don't want unhealthy stuff.

Also there is something to be said regarding the fact that we introduce babies to solids at 4 months old, in the UK they all look at me like I'm an alien. 😅And we get them potty trained as soon as they can sit!

I would say, for the sake of your kids try to explain to them the back of the ingredients list on packaging and definitely show them pictures of obese people so they know what can be the result of sugar/aspartame overdose and processed food eating. Definitely going to do that to my DD when she is old enough to read.

Have you met my french nieces and nephews ?! So much sugar .. Le snack is always sweet . One of them is a seriously fussy eater . And no tantrums give me a break, they’re just kids, of course they have tantrums !
I don't think you can generalise ..

Ancestrysos · 23/07/2024 18:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sethera · 23/07/2024 18:00

Goady sort of opening post. You could have asked for advice on counteracting the influence of unhealthy school dinners, without assuming all UK parents feed their children a never-ending conveyor belt of chicken nuggets and sweets.

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 23/07/2024 18:00

Of course some people feed their kids less than optimal foods. Most do it sometimes, I suspect even you do sometimes.

I have to point out that you have grossly misunderstood labelling on food - baked beans have 10% of the recommended daily allowance of sugar and 20% of the recommended daily allowance of salt - NOT are 10% sugar and 20% salt.