Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do any of arch-lockdowners regret it?

1000 replies

Refractory · 04/07/2024 01:12

Just that really.

I haven’t really been on MN since 2020 because I found the near complete support for lockdown far too upsetting.

the lockdowners in my life seem to not think about it much. For them, it’s just over.

with hindsight do you wish you’d been more sceptical?

would love a civil conversation about this.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Shortfatsuit · 04/07/2024 09:58

I think it was the right thing to do at the time, I followed the rules and have no regrets.

I rarely think about it these days, life has moved on and it's no longer relevant to me.

I'm sorry if it was difficult for you, OP. If you're still struggling to come to terms with what happened, would it help to get some counselling so that you can start to move forward with life again?

Kinshipug · 04/07/2024 09:59

CharlotteBog · 04/07/2024 09:56

Hindsight gives you this insight.

I disagree. I think it was quite clear within 6 months. The duration of restriction was absurd and we should have been able to trust the authorities to make these judgments sensibly.

LostRider · 04/07/2024 09:59

Jumpingthruhoops · 04/07/2024 09:57

This! The fact some people know most of the measures were utterly ridiculous and would do it all again is frankly mind-blowing. It's not 'caring', as some are claiming, just bloody virtue signalling.

People revealed some very nasty true colours in lockdown. They might be able to 'forget' it... but I sure as hell won't.

I relate to this! but I've always had an intolerance for ILLOGICAL rules.. rules for the sake of rules. And some people just love to be correct and enforce ... while shouting at you wearing a facemask that stopped working half a day ago

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/07/2024 09:59

I really struggled with lockdown - as a single mum in a job that couldn’t be furloughed (public sector) but wasn’t considered “key”, and two then primary aged children it was intolerable.

We stuck to the rules, but tbh there wasn’t much option not to!

bananaphon · 04/07/2024 10:01

OneLoyalGreyFish · 04/07/2024 03:01

My elder daughter’s second child was due in April 2020, booked in for a c-section. Obviously my son-in-law wanted to be there for the birth so after discussions with the consultant and midwife it was agreed that myself and my husband would isolate as soon as possible - we actually did this before Boris the clown told us to, so that I could go look after their 18 month old daughter. We also decided that I would stay with them from the night before she had to go in, until 2 weeks after my daughter and grandson came home. This was in case they brought Covid from the maternity hospital.
My younger daughter had 2 young children also, she was furloughed but my son-in-law was an essential worker so he was the ‘errand boy’ for all 3 households, fetching anything we needed. He came in no contact with the public through his job, worked alone, had full PPE from the start and stripped and showered before seeing his family.
My 2 daughters are also best friends and found it so hard to be apart from each other and each other’s children.
i was heartbroken when I left my eldest daughter, we all cried not knowing when I’d hold that days old baby again, read stories etc to my granddaughter, help my daughter after her c-section - I’ve been involved in all my grandchildren’s lives (I now have 5) and looked after them when my daughters went back to their jobs after maternity leave.

i started to think - surely as none of us are going anywhere, seeing anyone, going to the shops etc then how on earth can we catch Covid, and more importantly how could we give Covid to each other, where would we ‘catch it’ from?! We were led to believe that there was this invisible monster just waiting to get us at anytime and anywhere - it was on surfaces, it was on your delivered groceries, it was on your post, it was on your door handles (whether anyone had touched them or not!) - we were advised to wipe everything with antibacterial wipes, leave the post unopened for 2 days. It was complete madness! I said very early on, if it’s so contagious and lurking on everything then why haven’t supermarket staff been dropping like flies?! It must be airborne just like colds and flu, and if you touch your nose/sneeze then touch something which in turn is touched (very quickly afterwards) then you will get the virus, whether it’s Covid, flu, the common cold. I was right, I figured it out way before it was admitted that that’s how it was spread.

From that moment on I did everything to keep MY family safe - we didn’t eat out to help out in the August, no we kept to ourselves but were scared to break the rules, scared if we did that a neighbour would report us. Ridiculous really as we couldn’t be expected to make the right decision for our family but people were expected to go to work and miraculously Covid wouldn’t get them!

My now 4 year old grandson has had problems socialising, he wasn’t taken to the shops, a cafe, soft play, get together with children the same age - it’s had a profound effect on him. By December 2020 my daughters were allowed to form a support bubble, for families with babies under 1 - so for 8 months my daughter just had to get on with it, bringing up a baby with no extended family support.

I was my younger daughter’s childcare ‘bubble’ - how I was supposed to change my then 2 year old grandson’s nappy at a distance I don’t know. I changed him, cuddled him, comforted him, all close to me.

Then of course we found out about Boris and his cronies having parties etc, basically putting two fingers up at us, the great unwashed. I am so angry that they have got away with this.

Would I follow rules like this again? NO WAY!!!! I would do what I thought best and what my family thought best (we’ve talked about this many times over the last 4 years), we’d keep ourselves safe thereby not being a danger to others and spend time together as a family.

(Some of my family caught Covid, some didn’t (within the same family group - figure that one out) but not during any of the lockdowns)

I had my son in May 2020 and had a long hospital stay due to preeclampsia. I was crying everyday as no one could visit me in that hellish post natal ward. I wouldn't wish that time on anyone again, especially as the hypocrites in charge wouldn't even stick to the rules. There needed to be a balance.

Dontcallmescarface · 04/07/2024 10:02

seethingmess · 04/07/2024 09:51

I find only lucky people who didn't lose fanily members to Covid can look back and think some of the precautions were unnecessary.

I lost my mum in the 1st week of the 1st lockdown and not only were some of the precautions unnecessary, but downright cruel. The one that stated my (then), 83 year old frail dad should be left home alone after burying his wife of almost 60 years was one of them. That one got ignored by me and my sibling (the only other people to attend mum's funeral). The words "our thoughts are with those who have lost loved ones" said by Johnson, Hancock and many on here were laughable. When it came down to it, nobody cared about us, we even had rules on how to fucking grieve as in no hugging, no meeting up, etc. Nope it was a "you've lost someone, suck it up and don't be selfish, my family's needs are greater than yours" mentality.

Sweden99 · 04/07/2024 10:04

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/07/2024 09:59

I really struggled with lockdown - as a single mum in a job that couldn’t be furloughed (public sector) but wasn’t considered “key”, and two then primary aged children it was intolerable.

We stuck to the rules, but tbh there wasn’t much option not to!

Admirable.
The OP gave a nonsense post.
I am not sure there is any campaign for us to have lockdowns for the sake of it now we are out of Covid-19, so there are not really arch Shutdowners, despite the bad faith arguments on this thread.

MaMarysBigBowl · 04/07/2024 10:04

I wasn't an arch-lockdowner but I do look back now and think what on earth were we thinking for parts of it - how could we think sitting with one empty seat in between us on the Tube would make a difference, or standing 6ft apart in supermarkets?! Or that walking outside with someone was a huge risk?

I remember at the time being really uneasy with people's policing of others though. I reminded my mum several times over that she had no idea of others' reasons for not wearing a mask when she complained, and my auntie even mentioned how everyone on their street had noticed a neighbour's car missing for a few days so they must have gone down to their seaside home, as if it was a huge scandal. I never got into all that.

GingerPirate · 04/07/2024 10:05

Arch lockdowner here, mostly because of my Asperger's, I think.
I actually had the best time of my life,
with no other people demanding my time, energy and biting chunks of me they seem so entitled to.
Married, no kids.

Oldcroneandthreewitches · 04/07/2024 10:06

I broke the rules plenty. Some of my family were washing fucking cans from the shop.

My brother basically barricaded himself and my nana in the house and she hasn’t been the same since. The muscles in her legs went and is now in a wheel chair. Up until that point she was getting the bus every other day to go in to town, playing darts in the pub team. He LOVED it as he’s an anti social bastard who had a good excuse for no visitors.

I was very very lucky that I live semi rurally and life here for me and my neighbours didn’t really change. We had BBQs and lots of boozy summer days together. I also bought a paddle board and spent most of the summer on the lake near me with my kids.

I drove in to town one day and seen a little child up on a balcony in flats and they were on a little plastic bike going from one end of the tiny balcony to the other. I actually cried when I seen that. The whole area was deserted

I came off MN because of the crazy threads about people buying wine in Tescos. It’s really shocking how easy to manipulate an entire country is. The videos I seen of police bashing doors in because neighbours had grassed people up or pulling people for walking with a fucking coffee.

I’ll never view society the same again.

It might have been the ‘ law’ but if the law was that you had to sacrifice your eldest child would you? Where would be the line for you?

Being allowed to leave the fucking house for 60 mins a day? And people were actually timing themselves. Easy to see how Hitler managed to do what he did so easy

LetsTalkTwaddle · 04/07/2024 10:08

Not an arch-lockdowner, though when on Good Friday 2020 holidaymakers turned up at the holiday rental property next door (after lockdown had been declared and people had been told not to travel) and proceeded to carry on as if on holiday — sending unmasked children to the shop several times a day for ice creams and provisions, spending the whole day on the beach while other people stuck to their single hour's exercise, going surfing and sea kayaking, and then having another family show up to join them (breaking travel and visiting rules) I did phone 101 to let them know what was going on. I have no idea whether the police visited or not. The people (six adults, three children in a 2 bedrooms plus a bunk room cottage) stayed for more than a month. The owner expected them to leave once their week's booking was up but they argued that because of lockdown it wasn't safe for them to go home and stayed on — and they didn't pay the house owner for the extra weeks.

In January 2021, when we were locked down again, I went to help a friend look after her dying mother. The mother had cancer with secondaries in her spine and brain. It was a nightmare. Very restricted help from the District Nurse, a GP who came once in a month and a lack of effective pain relief. MacMillan, Marie Curie and hospice at home support vanished. The mother needed a lot of help (doubly incontinent, could barely walk/ move for the pain) and my friend and I were on care duty 24/7. I don't think I got more than three hours sleep at a time.

After a month of deterioration the GP decided the mother had to go into hospital. Apart from FaceTime calls a few times over the first couple of weeks, my friend didn't see her mum again. Her mother became comatose and died after five weeks in hospital. When my friend saw her body, it was covered in bedsores: it was clear she hadn't been cared for properly. Perhaps OP you can imagine how bad you'd feel if you knew you'd allowed your much-loved mum to be admitted to hospital where she was neglected in her last weeks.

Compash · 04/07/2024 10:08

Nah, I just had a big karaoke party where people got pissed and puked up the walls and... oh no, hang on, that was the Tories...

godmum56 · 04/07/2024 10:10

GreenTeaLikesMe · 04/07/2024 02:28

Look, with respect, that's always going to be a question of balance, not absolutes.

Flu kills huge numbers of people annually. We could greatly reduce flu deaths by forcing kids to stay at home all day under lockdown conditions during flu season (so, a couple of months each year). Should we do that? Is it worth the cost in terms of physical and mental health? Of course not.

There is a flu vaccine and now children can also get a nasal vaccine. Both reduce the risk of flu considerably and better uptake would reduce it still further. At the time of lockdown there was no virus and no effective treatment so not comparable. If doing what we were asked to do makes me an arch lockdowner then that's a badge i will wear with pride. Sometimes there are no good decisions only least bad ones. Given the same circs, i would do the same again. I did not and would not police others unless i felt they were putting people at serious risk.

Arraminta · 04/07/2024 10:14

We did follow the rules, begrudgingly. It shocked me how fanatical and deranged people behaved though. You assume most people are fairly normal and sensible but then you scratch their surface and underneath madness lies. Easy now to understand how the atrocities of WWII happened due to the twisted compliance of 'average' people.

COVID was only dangerous to a tiny fraction of people. Tiny. Hundreds of millions suffered in order to protect this tiny fraction and that was crazy. The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

Kinshipug · 04/07/2024 10:14

If we experience a similar pandemic again, I will support nothing more than properly funded sick leave.

WittyFatball · 04/07/2024 10:15

The lockdowns seem to have worked so not sure what there is to regret?

Maybe they should have been stricter/earlier and definitely the government should have adhered to their own rules!

BeaRF75 · 04/07/2024 10:16

It was obvious at the time that lockdown was too severe and lasted too long. (This is not a political comment, as both Conservative and Labour parties broadly supported lockdown).
And yet, in spite of all the evidence we have of how disastrous lockdown was, there are still members of the public who think it was a good idea! It's absolutely baffling..... I just don't understand them.

PregnantWithHorrors · 04/07/2024 10:18

Kinshipug · 04/07/2024 10:14

If we experience a similar pandemic again, I will support nothing more than properly funded sick leave.

Which of course we never got with covid. All the money in the world for dodgy deals and tracing services that didn't work anyway, but heaven forbid we pay ill people to stay at home and rest.

Spacecowboys · 04/07/2024 10:20

Jifmicroliquid · 04/07/2024 09:46

I do feel we have a problem with todays youngsters if having to have a couple of terms of home schooling has deeply affected the rest of their childhood and early adulthood.

I was unfortunate enough to be extremely unwell as a child and miss year 7 and 8 of school. I’m talking hospital stays, no contact with other children, no weekends/days out.
This was obviously pre mobile phones, Netflix, computer consoles, internet. Once a week a school friend would ring my landline and we would have a ten minute chat.
So I have very little time for the swarms of children who seemed to have a meltdown because they had to do online learning for a few months (obviously those in homes of DV is a different thing entirely)

I really do feel something has gone wrong with todays young people.

Hardly as simple as that. Some children had no access to the internet at home. Even if they did, the cobbled together online learning was in no way a replacement for the support and guidance provided by teachers when in school. The impact of social isolation shouldn’t really be underestimated either. Some children were scared, unsurprising given the hysteria displayed by some adults and it will have taken some time to work through these emotions. Yes, some children were unscathed by lockdown. But some weren’t and to dismiss their struggles is ridiculous. They are some of the most vulnerable people in society.

BeaRF75 · 04/07/2024 10:21

I have many friends and family who were/are NHS workers and they all thought lockdown was ridiculous and pointless.
And as for the f*ing clapping, they absolutely hated it!

Apollo365 · 04/07/2024 10:21

I know people who lost their life - horribly alone in hospital - during the first wave of covid (the nasty one).
If lockdown even prevented one needless death it was the right decision.

bananaphon · 04/07/2024 10:22

BeaRF75 · 04/07/2024 10:21

I have many friends and family who were/are NHS workers and they all thought lockdown was ridiculous and pointless.
And as for the f*ing clapping, they absolutely hated it!

The clapping was pathetic.

Apollo365 · 04/07/2024 10:23

We didn’t clap but it was nice to see the neighbours were all alive 🤦🏻‍♀️

LostRider · 04/07/2024 10:23

Spacecowboys · 04/07/2024 10:20

Hardly as simple as that. Some children had no access to the internet at home. Even if they did, the cobbled together online learning was in no way a replacement for the support and guidance provided by teachers when in school. The impact of social isolation shouldn’t really be underestimated either. Some children were scared, unsurprising given the hysteria displayed by some adults and it will have taken some time to work through these emotions. Yes, some children were unscathed by lockdown. But some weren’t and to dismiss their struggles is ridiculous. They are some of the most vulnerable people in society.

I have multiple friends who are primary teachers and they say they might as well have spent a year playing at home, they are so far behind. So many being diagnosed with ADHD etc not sure if related but the amount of parent at my work who are happy to diagnose and drug up so they sit quietly in class is astonishing

fliptopbin · 04/07/2024 10:23

I don't know what OP means by "arch lockdowners", but I think it is unfair to blame people for following the rules. With the benefit of hindsight it is easy to say that some of the anti covid measures were wrong (and they were), but nobody knew much about Covid at the beginning as it was a novel virus.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.