Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a childcare and parents one...sort of!

6 replies

FellowshipOfTheBing · 30/06/2024 01:36

My brother is cross with me and feels I'm super out of order about my parents and childcare

I have 2 preschool children, one of which is due to start school in September

When I was on maternity leave I spoke to my parents about childcare (Which nurseries we were looking at etc). They said they would love to have DC for an afternoon to help. Great! When DC2 came along they extended this to them also

Over the last 4 years I've asked them for the odd morning at the weekend if DH and I have something we can't take them to, or an extra half day in week if I have a clash (I work condensed hours so have them Wednesday afternoon).

Over the years sometimes they've said yes, sometimes they've said no. I am absolutely fine with this. I always ask with lots of notice and make it clear that it's no problem at all if not, I'll find an alternative but wanted to check with them first.

Our loose rule is they're always happy for me to ask as long as I'm always happy for them to say no when they need to. Which I am

My eldest starts school in September and I was looking ahead to half term October. I spoke to my DPs and asked if they would have eldest one day in the half term week.

They replied that they didn't want to get tied down to committing to half term childcare and for me to plan something alternative now my eldest is at school. (My brother was with them when my mum rang to tell me this) It was a complete non issue for me and I said of course I understand, no problem, thanks so much for letting me know and I'd book holiday club. We then spoke about a garden centre visit they'd done in the morning

My brother rang me later that day saying he thought was completely out of order for expecting my parents to do holiday childcare for me. I was completely shocked by this and said I absolutely didn't expect it, I had asked and had no issue at all with them saying no.

I then pointed out to my brother that his 3 children had not been to nursery thanks to my generous parents and his in laws taking up the slack and having his kids several times a week. In fact they still have all 3 once a week after school

My brother said this isn't the same as my parents were much younger then. (His children are now junior age) I said, I agree, which is why I didn't put them in the same position by expecting them to pick up the slack for me so I sent mine to nursery.

I've checked with my mum that she wasn't upset at being asked and she has no idea where it's come from and said she would always prefer I ask as they'll always try and help where they can.

Brother is now not talking to me as he thinks I'm taking advantage of my parents good nature.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Ozanj · 30/06/2024 01:38

Your brother is a selfish twat just ignore

NuffSaidSam · 30/06/2024 01:43

Of course YANBU.

If this is in character then your brother is an idiot.

If it's out of character then I'd say he's got something on his mind and this outburst isn't really about you/the childcare at all.

FellowshipOfTheBing · 30/06/2024 01:48

It is totally out of character.

We get on very well and have an ongoing WhatsApp of just pisstake memes about siblings

No idea what has happened to set him off but glad the first two replies don't think I'm out of order

I know MN usually comes down hard on reliance of parents for childcare but as I hope I've explained, I don't rely on it but I do ask!

OP posts:
Kitkatcatflap · 30/06/2024 01:52

All is good between you and your parents, it seems you both are respectful on terms of asking first and being able to refuse without any resentment, sho don't give your brother a thought Seems he creamed off all the childcare he needed when your parents were younger and now now ants to pull the ladder up behind him. Let him stew - soounds like something else is going on

randomusernam · 30/06/2024 02:22

Are you sure your parents haven't been moaning to him about it. I'd ask what has made him feel like this because it's between you and parents.

Ivyrosecrayon · 30/06/2024 02:26

He's massively overreacted. Has he got something stressful going on in his life at the moment? Perhaps he's just taking stress out on you by being aggro about this..
You haven't done anything wrong.. your parents are fine with you. It's fine to ask as long as your fine with being told no, you are absolutely right. It's none of your brothers business really.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page