To ask which Greek island?

[Whichisland]

I am being unreasonable to post on here but I know it gets a lot of traffic so I do apologise!

Looking to go to Greece next May with our 2 year old. Which island would you recommend? Would ideally like something that has a Greek feel rather than purely karaoke bars etc but don’t mind a bit of a mixture! So many places to choose from it’s hard to pick.

Thank you!

Fiskardo is absolutely stunning but we stayed in Scala which was lovely too. Lovely, sandy beach, good restaurants, great for a families, boat trips etc.