Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want a relationship with my only brother.

8 replies

Thunderinsummer · 04/04/2024 19:43

I come from a very small family. My parents moved to the UK and had my sister, my brother and me. My sister died young so it is just the 4 of us here.
I did not particularly get along with my parents well. My dad is a functioning alcoholic and was not very nice to me/uninterested in me growing up and I think my mum resented him. My older brother however got on with them really well and
really was the favourite! He could do no wrong whereas I always felt judged for my choices (eg he got engaged and never started planning a wedding but had a baby, I got engaged 3 years later and booked my wedding venue and date after 3 months- he decided he wanted to get married that month/year too so my parents told me to change the date. I didn’t)

I was despite this quite close to him between the ages of 16-24 and did lots with him, his now wife and my now ex husband. We did days out, nights out, lunches, parties together. But then something changed. His wife kept making comments on how poor our family is (my parents were immigrants we were poor in comparison to many) but how well my brother is doing - little does she know my brother is up to his eyeballs in credit card debt and my dad bails him out now and again and I’m talking thousands! She then stopped speaking to me, started making rude comments to my parents and then my brother stopped speaking to me. I still sent birthday and Christmas cards to them and their children and asked to meet up etc with no response. The final straw was when I reached out to them for some support when my marriage fell apart when I was 8 months pregnant with my second child. I was in pieces and really struggling to function. I heard nothing from him. My parents also not particularly helpful.

Fast forward 8ish years and I am remarried with a new baby and happy. I have also let go of having a relationship with my brother and his family. My dad had cancer and is in remission but is like a new man and has wanted to spend time with me. I have welcomed this and often invite him to family days out theme parks, galas, kids sporting activities so he can spend time with us. However he hides having a relationship with me from my brother because he makes remarks like with her again? She only wants you to babysit. She only does it so you’ll pay. It annoys me because he’s still an alcoholic so I don’t leave my children with him and I wouldn’t dream of asking him to pay for me to do something.

My dad (I think with his renewed faith in life) has asked me to start trying to build bridges with my brother. I honestly couldn’t think of anything worse. I find the thought of him toxic, he puts people down, he’s genuinely disinterested in anyone but himself. We’ve already missed out on having our children have a close relationship (they’re about the same age and we live less than 30 min away). I understand that once my parents die he is all the family I have left but I just don’t like him and I was done many years ago trying to keep a relationship. I know this upsets my dad but I spent a long time wondering what I’d done wrong and now I’m done. I may regret it in the future but I don’t want to bring this negativity back.

I realised by writing this I’ve vented a lot so apologies for the long post!

OP posts:
Groovee · 04/04/2024 19:51

Looking back I have never had a proper relationship with my father's other children. So I walked away. They seem to think it's ok to harass me and slate me on social media. But I have a strong husband and children who have kept me strong in my decision to not bow down to them.

I have some very good friends who have embraced my children and cared for them and do not need the ones who share half a DNA with me in my life.

It's up to you. Do not feel forced to have a relationship to keep a parent happy.

PermanentTemporary · 04/04/2024 19:57

Relations between me and my bil broke down some years ago. FIL would like us to get on, meet up etc. I just state the truth 'I'm not able to do that' and then go on to ask about their time together, general progress of the kids etc (nothing private). Lots of positivity from me about how well they're all doing. Rinse and repeat.

It sounds as if you are still trying to believe that you have the right not to see him. You do.

Thunderinsummer · 04/04/2024 20:02

@PermanentTemporary I think I do feel like I have to justify why I don’t want to start up with them again. It feels like a competition all the time, whose house is nicest, best job, makes money, whose kids are smartest/most athletic. I’m not here for that. If they’re healthy and happy then I’m happy for them (or at least trying my best to be)

OP posts:
justthecat · 04/04/2024 20:10

Just say no, I'm happy where we are and that's it

PermanentTemporary · 04/04/2024 20:19

It's tricky isnt it. I think there probably is a past/future where ì made different decisions, gritted my teeth and rebuilt the relationship between me and my BIL. I certainly regret the bits that are my fault. But the bits that were his were so bad and so longstanding that I just didn't feel I could fight my way to a point I could trust him. I wish him only good things though - which probably includes not having me in his life.

Hatty65 · 04/04/2024 20:23

I would say calmly, 'I do not want contact with him, Dad. He is unpleasant to me and I'm not prepared to tolerate that in my life. It's a pity if you are bothered by that, but it's not a subject that is up for discussion'.

3beesinmybonnet · 04/04/2024 20:29

Is there any chance you would want this person in your life if he wasn't your brother? Perhaps if your father wants you to be close now he should've made more effort to encourage a good relationship between you when you were young.
I dumped my abusive brother 13 years ago and I haven't regretted it for one second. You only get one life OP, don't waste it on toxic individuals, family or otherwise.

Thunderinsummer · 04/04/2024 22:13

@3beesinmybonnet absolutely not. He brings nothing to my life whatsoever. I just worry that when it comes to just the two of us left I will regret it. But I don’t think he will.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread