Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be unsure about continuing this relationship?

17 replies

Alasia24 · 18/03/2024 08:03

I've been in a relationship officially for 4 months with a man who is separated. We'd been friends for a long time but lost touch when he met his STBX wife and I met my previous partner - neither of our partners were very happy with us being in touch with each other as they felt threatened by how close we were, so we sort of came to a mutual decision to ease off on the friendship and just message a few times a year to check up...eventually that just fizzled out.

I split with my last partner early last year and not long afterwards, he separated from his wife. We happened to bump into each other in town one day last summer, ended up going for a coffee and chatted away like we hadn't ever lost touch.

I learnt that he'd initiated a divorce a couple of months prior and that his relationship hadn't been the most successful; after they had got married a few years ago the relationship declined with COVID, being together 24/7, health issues etc just bringing them down and towards the end the affection and communication had died. This is exactly what happened with me and my partner, although mine wasnt due to COVID; my ex partner stopped speaking to me civilly a long time before that :(

We started dating. I was wary due to my past relationship and he understood, was sensitive and didn't push me, etc. I have a child and have kept it relatively separate from them so far; they are a teenager so know I'm dating but haven't met him yet apart from seeing him outside in the car picking me up a couple of times.
Although he was understanding at first, it was hard seeing him more than once a week due to our jobs, my home life, and also I have poor mental health so I tended to swing from wanting to see him one week, to not wanting to see him the next. I'd always be honest about how I was feeling and he seemed to understand, but his ex wife also played a factor in my hesitance...

He told me before we started dating that since they split, his STBXW has been messaging him pretty much daily, long messages that stress him out.
He's shown me some of them and sometimes she's asking for another chance, then she has a go at him saying things like he was controlling, caused her 'severe mental health condition that almost killed me' (he used to go over to the property to carry out jobs in preparation for selling it and one night while he was there, she told him that she'd taken an overdose and he spent the evening sorting her out, getting her to hospital and contacting her family).
She's contacted me sporadically (how she found my number I don't know) slating me as apparently she's convinced herself I was seeing him before they split - we weren't - she's even contacted my ex partner accusing us of cheating which obviously then landed me in trouble with my ex.

I've suggested over and over that he stops replying to her messages unless they're about the divorce, stop going round to the house and get people in to mow the lawn or the other jobs he's been doing, as when he's there she either begs him to try again or has a go at him the entire time about what a shit person he is.
He then ends up stressed and upset but maintains he wants to stay amicable to avoid dragging the divorce through court (all been done privately/through mediators so far, although I think a solicitor has recently been brought in).

The last time his STBXW contacted me was around a month ago and she sounded so distressed that I phoned her to explain my side of things.
She ended up telling me that my boyfriend is controlling, her friends weren't happy about how he was treating her, that he's been leading her to believe that he wanted to try again the whole time we've been together, that he told her we haven't slept together or even kissed (I do know he'd been keeping that from her up until recently). I was so upset that I decided to end things with him.

Yesterday, I found out that after that phonecall, he told her we had split and it's all her fault. She was delighted and told him I'm toxic and he should stay clear, she'd be "disappointed" if he got back with me.
I also found out that last week, he'd gone in her car to their mediation meeting (despite the fact he'd told me he was going to distance himself from her) and on the way home, she'd laid into him with the emotional stuff again, bringing up the phonecall from last month and saying how upset he was. He says he tried to ignore her but she kept asking how often he'd seen me and he admitted he hadn't seen me for a week by that point, and that I see my ex on a regular basis. Apparently he told her that my ex comes round almost daily (which is true, as I don't drive so he helps me out with shopping etc a few times a week, we've also been for coffee a few times but I always tell my boyfriend about this) and she responded that it's toxic and he should end things with me.

That evening, he had sent me a message saying that although he believes me and my ex aren't having a sexual relationship, it's "clearly still a relationship" and he needs to move on to avoid getting hurt.

I immediately spoke to my ex and told him that our contact is causing issues in my new relationship so we need to ease back on the contact out of respect for my boyfriend. My ex agreed and we haven't spoken since.

So when I found out about what he'd said to his ex, I was hurt. I feel really betrayed and we got into a long conversation about it all, he sent me screenshots of some of the conversations with his ex and in my opinion he replies to her crazy messages far too often, much to politely and it almost looks like he's encouraging her contact.

Anyway last night, I ended things with him. His response was to send her a long message explaining that I'm his number one priority and he'll be blocking her from now on, yada yada. He sent me the screenshot and also one of her being blocked.

He wants another chance with me and I'm really not sure. It's all such a drama for a 4 month long relationship and he's lied to me about the level of contact he had with his ex, whereas although I've been in touch with mine and we're still friends, I've always told my boyfriend about it and been totally honest.

However - he's blocked her now.
So do give him another chance now he's realised his mistake and acted on it?

Sorry this ended up so long, I did try to edit it down a bit!

OP posts:
ALittleBitAhAh · 18/03/2024 08:10

This sound far too much work for what should be the lovely initial stages of a relationship. Bin him off imo!

Alasia24 · 18/03/2024 08:23

ALittleBitAhAh · 18/03/2024 08:10

This sound far too much work for what should be the lovely initial stages of a relationship. Bin him off imo!

It is a bit!

I just wondered whether we could almost start from scratch now that he's finally blocked her and I'm no longer in touch with my ex.

It does feel like it's just toooo much drama though

OP posts:
Hannahoo · 18/03/2024 08:27

I think this is an absolute no. You are both still too involved with exes, it's not normal to have your ex help you with shopping and go for coffees either. I think you both need a clean cut from exes, and then a start again in time but not with one another.

OhTheSilence · 18/03/2024 08:32

Way too much drama and instability. Speaking from experience, it won't improve all of a sudden just because he's blocked her. Both of you hadn't moved on fully from your past relationships before getting involved. Better to take some time on your own.

Alasia24 · 18/03/2024 08:33

OhTheSilence · 18/03/2024 08:32

Way too much drama and instability. Speaking from experience, it won't improve all of a sudden just because he's blocked her. Both of you hadn't moved on fully from your past relationships before getting involved. Better to take some time on your own.

:( that's a shame but I think it confirms what I was feeling, too.

OP posts:
cerisepanther73 · 18/03/2024 08:55

Oh my word where do i start, about this dilemma,
and this is a 4 month only relantship???

the amount of drama's etc,

Is bonkers,🤪

My advice is to hot foot out of this relationship as soon as possible,

this is suposed to be a honeymoon period of the relantship,
Not all this crap 💩💩💩

this is as good as it gets with this kind of relantship and its woes,
Could even potentially get worse,

you could do so much better than this,

Both your exs are too much emotionally involved in your lives and relantship in different ways,
one in particular ex has too much say influence sway, due to issues of jealously neediness and insecurities proberly,

this will not change thats for sure, cause he is hasn't got the back bone to make that kind of difference that a relantship needs to happen for it work,

You have relied on your ex way bit too much in the past, you realised that, so toke steps to address that,
turned into co dependency type of platonic friendship,

you really need to explore look into emotionall support elsewhere and address the reasons behind such poor mental health,

such as turning to charitable organisations that support mental health issues and having effective therapies etc,

Otherwise you will allways no matter who you start a new relationship with,
run into issues of them not wanting you to have an ex too much involved in your life like that,

Obviously it's not healthy to be in any co dependency arrangement or heavily enmeshed situation with anyone allways that for whatever reason,

cerisepanther73 · 18/03/2024 08:58

@Alasia24

I agree totally with @OhTheSilence insighful post summed it perfectly in a nutshell..👌

Move on

Alasia24 · 18/03/2024 09:01

@cerisecerisepanther73 thanks, I get where you're coming from and you're right

OP posts:
Testina · 18/03/2024 09:08

“he told her that my ex comes round almost daily (which is true, as I don't drive so he helps me out with shopping etc a few times a week, we've also been for coffee a few times”

The man that couldn’t speak to you in a civil manner?
You both kept one foot in each other’s camps in your previous relationships, and both are doing the same thing now to your exes. You two are the problem here, and I think your similar tendencies multiplied = a shitshow.

Alasia24 · 18/03/2024 09:12

@testina

That's true. Which is why I wondered whether now he's blocked his and I've contact has stopped with mine, we could start again from the beginning, without the distractions of exes.

OP posts:
Alasia24 · 18/03/2024 09:13

Alasia24 · 18/03/2024 09:12

@testina

That's true. Which is why I wondered whether now he's blocked his and I've contact has stopped with mine, we could start again from the beginning, without the distractions of exes.

He's been nicer to me since he moved out. It's like he resented me while we were together but now he's happier, the arguments we had and resentments aren't there anymore

I didn't see the issue with being in touch as I was always upfront with my boyfriend about it, my ex knows about my new relationship etc.

OP posts:
OhTheSilence · 18/03/2024 10:07

Alasia24 · 18/03/2024 09:12

@testina

That's true. Which is why I wondered whether now he's blocked his and I've contact has stopped with mine, we could start again from the beginning, without the distractions of exes.

You may have each blocked contact but your exes still take up too much headspace for you to move forward in a healthy relationship. I see some co-dependency traits in both of you that if not healed, would still sabotage your relationships going forward. I know it's difficult, but set some boundaries and stick to them.

KreedKafer · 18/03/2024 10:10

All this drama in FOUR MONTHS? I was exhausted just reading that. This is not the relationship for you.

Alasia24 · 18/03/2024 10:15

@ohthesilence

Thanks, I've heard about codependency but not entirely sure what it is so will do a bit of research (just for myself and the future, nothing to do with this relationship).

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 18/03/2024 10:19

Life is too short for this bullshit and he's shady AF. Run for your life.

WallaceinAnderland · 18/03/2024 10:24

It's toxic. You really don't need that in your life. Cut contact completely and you will find happiness elsewhere. This one's not for you.

Aubree17 · 18/03/2024 18:57

If you want any relationship to work your going to have to cut ties with your ex.
No one wants to be second place.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page