Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to let me DH have a go at my sister for being socially inept?

31 replies

bergentulip · 26/03/2008 17:11

My sister is a lovely person, has a very generous heart, but is very good at not doing things she does not want to do.
She has just maintained the role of being baby of the family.

She will do things if asked directly, ie 'hold DS2 while I just try and get DS1's lunch ready' 'can you take DS1 out for a walk to the swings for me? while I go to X appointment for DS2'... that sort of thing.
and has in the past been very generous and helpful in other ways- selling my car amongst other things.

However, whilst my Dad and I have been quite happy to deal with her in our own way, as my DH has come into the picture, and stepmother, it's clear her behaviour within the family is becoming a problem. It drives DH up the wall.

And it all came to a head when my sis came to stay very soon after DS2 was born. Whereas everyone else chipped in when they came over, she sat back and watched, occassionally playing with DS1. DH was livid on the morning she was going to leave, when he had to go to work, and all he could think about all day was that I had been left with a house in a tip (which he would gladly have sorted out if he was at home I hasten to add!), a 2week old and a toddler-- and was not coping very well with the whole BFing thing as well.

He wrote this very pointed letter to her, basically telling her she needed to grow up a bit, and not expect the world to do everything for her. I stepped in and begged him not to send it, and to let me deal with her, it would just start a big rift between them I don't want. She takes very badly to criticism, and I just think it could be done in a more subtle way.

It's a looooong standing problem with her really. She just makes no exceptions for her behaviour, or how she views the world, for anyone, and I think as she gets older, it is just starting to cause problems. Our family have discussed a few times since, my stepmother also seeming to be quite vocal on the subject, so she perhaps does need to be made aware that sometimes she has to do things she does not want to.
My Dad and I have just let her get away with not doing anything when we are all living together, for years, possibly being too indulgent after my mother died about 10yrs ago- she is now 24, me 27.

Is it really my DHs place to say anything though? We are all family, of course, but are some things just no-go between in-laws? Was I wrong to veto his letter?

OP posts:
bergentulip · 27/03/2008 10:03

Fair point Upwind!

OP posts:
OrmIrian · 27/03/2008 10:06

Sorry but what has it got to do with DH. Of course he shouldn't send a letter. Does anyone's partner ever get on 100% with their 'in-laws'?

If you and your parents decide your sister needs tackling it should be your decision and not his. I don't think she sounds that terrible for someone so young (24 seems very young to me).

TheHedgeWitch · 27/03/2008 10:14

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

mamababa · 27/03/2008 10:21

A letter seems very extreme, but I think DH has a point. I expect people to muck in if they come to stay at my house and my in-laws do sweet fa when they come even tho' my DS is only 11 weeks old. You would even think the kettle was the world;s most complicated gadget. Everyone thinks 24 is dead young, I don't, she's a grown adult. She doesnt have to look after the kids, but she I'm sure she's capable of operating a hoover or an iron? Maybe you should have the conversation with her about some ground rules if she stays again, but then again you sound very laid back. I'm with your DH, it would drive me up the wall so maybe he could have a word and say that it would be nice for you if she helped out a bit?

bergentulip · 27/03/2008 10:39

I think you talk a lot of sense mamababa.

Ground rules- yup. Ask her to help out a bit.

I think 24 is also perfectly old enough myself.

OP posts:
PotPourri · 27/03/2008 10:46

OH, don't let him send the letter. However, your sister does sound (sorry to say it) a right sap. I personally think that she does need to grow up, and you should either set some ground rules when she is in your home (as it is DPs home too). If you don't feel able to do that, I don't think it is unreasonable for DH to expect not to have to sit and watch her doing her thing....

Don't beat yourself up about it, you sound like you are taking alot of blame, and you have obviously gone through the pain of losing your mum etc. But seriously, what sort of life is she going to have if she never grows up. She sounds really overly sensitive, and yes, socially inept - to use your words. Maybe you should talk to DH about how you can help her with those issues in a more appropriate way.

I think DH is within his rights to be p-ed off though with someone who is taking you for a ride if you are not willing to tackle it to stop it happening again and again- but not to send a letter. It's not the way to deal with it.

You sound like a lovely, caring sister BTW. But I am sure you can channel that caring into helping your sister grow up a bit. The world is a scary place, and protecting her forever will do her no favours inthe long run.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page