Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AITA for moving 3 hours from my parent's house?

10 replies

Cupofherbaltea · 31/01/2024 16:48

I'm 35(F), never married and have no kids. I've always lived close-ish to my parents, max 30 minutes away, apart from when I went to university - around six hours from them - for three years. For context, my much younger brother is married with a kid and lives very close to my mum and dad, his choice.

I am an adventerous traveler by heart but I've always felt very stifled by my mother in particular. She has always drummed into me how important it is to live close to my family and has a big fear of me travelling. At 18, my dream was to do a gap year in America but my mum discouraged me from doing so, highlighting cost as a factor. I later discovered an uncle was prepared to fund my gap year as long as I went to University, but he went through my mum to offer it, and she never relayed this information to me.

I moved back in after uni at 21, got a job, and moved out at 23 to a town 20/30 minutes drive from my mum and dad's house. My mum wasn't very happy as it was "so far away" but I had the absolute best years of my life living with friends and don't regret it for a second.

Over the years, I'd expressed an interest in buying a house but there's no way I could afford to live near my parents and regardless, I don't love the town they live in enough to buy a place there. It has really gone downhill since they first bought their house there over 30 years ago. My friends are scattered around. I once expressed an interest in living somewhere 45mins/1h drive from my mum and dad and my mother shrieked that it was "too far" and "you might have a few friends who live near there now, but I'll be the only one there for you when it really matters." I didn't buy a place in the end, stayed renting, house prices went crazy and I got priced out of the market.

Now at 35, I've moved in with my boyfriend. He already owned a house around 2 hours drive from them. My mum wasn't very happy: in fact, I'd go as far as to say she was very disappointed in me, although she did understand that I couldn't help where he'd chosen to buy his house before we met.

We've now sold that house and plan to move around 3/4 hours away. I've told my mum it's temporary and she keeps saying: "Great, then you can finally move back this part of town!" and when I've told her I don't really like that area, she gets angry, reminding me how important it is to live close to family, etc. Sometimes she uses the guilt thing: "fine, live where you want, you'll see how much you need us and how much you'll regret that when we're dead".

One thing I've not told my parents is that our move is likely to be permanent. If not, the minimum we'll end up living from their house is maybe 90 mins away. My mum doesn't even like that I'm moving temporarily, let alone permanently.

My parents are older and have a few health issues, but whenever they've needed me, i've been there without a fuss and even though the new distance will make it harder for me to go instantly, I will absolutely be there if/when needed.

I am so excited about the move and finally getting to experience a different town in adulthood, but I feel so guilty for purusing my dreams because my mum tells me I should stay living there..

AITA? Should a child live close to their parents purely because their parents live there?

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 31/01/2024 16:51

YANBU at all in terms of the distance. She sounds quite controlling.

You moved in with your boyfriend- will the new house be in both your names? Have you got your investment in it protected? That would be my main concern - not the distance!

Catza · 31/01/2024 17:11

"Living close to family is very important"
What did you get so far from living close to them except missed opportunities, guilt tripping and missing out on owning a property much earlier (at better cost and mortgage rates)?
Arbitrary rules are just that, arbitrary. You can live wherever you want. I moved to a different country in my 20s and never looked back. Yes, I miss my family but not enough to move back or "regret it when they are dead". I visit and have a good time with them, then go back to my life until the next time.
ETA: "I am the only one who is going to be there for you when it matters" is a highly problematic statement. If it came from a man you were dating, I would say it's a red flag for domestic abuse...

GreyhpundGirl · 31/01/2024 17:16

You're an adult, you can make your own choices about your life. I couldn't wait to escape my hometown after university and my brothers and dad (mum died years ago) are scattered over the country but we are very close, just not geographically. It sounds like your mum wants to control you, or live vacariously through you.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 31/01/2024 17:18

You're 35 years old. THIRTY FIVE.

Go and live your life. Take responsibility for yourself, enjoy the privileges. Your mother is totally out of order, and so are you really for entertaining her manipulations.

I have moved 5000 miles and a day's travel away from my family. Nobody once said anything other than "how exciting!". Any disappointments were personal and therefore kept to themselves.

RampantIvy · 31/01/2024 17:21

This is a Reddit post isn't it?
35(F)
AITA

Startingagainandagain · 31/01/2024 17:21

You need to live your own life and build your own family if that's what you want.

Your parents sound controlling.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 31/01/2024 17:22

Also, in my experience, "I'll be the only one there for you when it really matters" tends to be code for "I need you to be here for me"; and "you'll see how much you need us and how much you'll regret that when we're dead" is actually an expression of how much she needs you around for her own needs and a lashing of guilt-tripping on top. How dare anyone, let alone your own mother, treat you like this? Don't you feel manipulated, as though she thinks your life isn't as important as hers?

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 31/01/2024 17:24

Turn it on its head, your parents could
move near to your new place.

Go and live your life where ever you want, be happy, you only get one chance. This is about you, what you want and need and not anyone else right now. If you don’t, when are you? You’ve already missed a great travelling all expenses paid trip due to your parents. What else are you prepared to miss?

cardboardnumerator · 31/01/2024 17:25

We lived a good 3 hours drive from both sets of parents for years. We only moved closer for job opportunities not to be near family. We are now an hour away.

Your Mum sounds stifling, lots of people don't live near family. Realistically how much have you "needed" your Mum over the years? I raised 2 children with Dh and no family help at all due to geography and then when we did move everyone was still working full time.

She sounds like she holds you back. Tell her the move is likely to be permanent then she can get the idea of you living close out of her head. The one thing I will say is get independent financial advice about buying a house whilst unmarried.

@RampantIvy Reddit style posting is being used on here a lot, I don't particularly like it but if this post is already on Reddit then a UK based opinion might be beneficial to the OP.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 31/01/2024 17:26

As for being there when it matters (snorts with laughter) she wasn’t there when you needed someone to help you go out in the world and make something of youth and time to explore who and what you wanted to be was she? No she held you back.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page