Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad how much nicer ILs are compared to my family?

35 replies

ncfrths · 25/12/2023 20:47

My parents are significantly better off than DH's parents. I am "very close" to my mum in the sense that we see a lot of each other, I grew up sharing a lot with her, didn't have too many secrets, she's very open with me too etc but she's also very critical of me. I'm from a different culture and being critical is seen as part of closeness in our culture. For example, I might come to hers and she will just say "oh you're looking bigger and bigger each time I see you! Are you not eating healthily?" or one time in pregnancy I ate some eggs that had gone off the day before (didn't notice) and she exclaimed "how can you be that careless?! How will you ever look after a child?" Or "why are you wearing that old thing? Where's the nice Chanel coat I bought you?". Financially she helps with a lot and if we didn't accept her financial help our lifestyles would be very different for me and DC. With her help we can afford private school, I'm a SAHM which I wouldn't be able to otherwise do, travel 5-6 times per year, have a full time housekeeper etc. My mum always puts herself first so if we travel and get a villa she will choose the room that suits herself best rather than ask us what might be best for our DC.

By contrast, ILs don't have a massive house but offered us the master bedroom (ie their own room) so that it's more comfortable for us when we visited - DH is the only child with his own children so far. ILs spent the whole time we stayed spending time with us and playing with our DC. They'd normally go for Xmas day service but said they wouldn't this year because they don't want to miss out on time with us. Whereas when I visit my mum she will see us at mealtimes but quite often goes about her daily business. She will just sit on the sofa reading magazines and if DC wants to climb on she's happy but no way would she get down on the floor and make animal noises the way ILs do.

A further example is my MIL was due to have a friend visit but the timings weren't working with our DC's nap so she told her friend that she can't visit. My mum will live her life how she wants even when we visit - talk loudly on the phone during a nap, if her friends are meant to come they'll come without asking us.

Sorry for the long post. It just makes me sad seeing how ILs have such a lovely atmosphere and give us everything they can even when they have less to give but my mum seems to care about herself more than anything. Or am I just being an ungrateful brat considering how much she helps financially? It's like she will help with funds but just isn't as considerate of me or DC (or DH!) and will prioritise her own interests over ours always.

OP posts:
Sunshineismyfavourite · 25/12/2023 21:20

Sounds to me like you've got the best of both worlds OP! It's a shame your Mum isn't more hands on with your DC but if she was then she wouldn't be the person she is and possibly wouldn't have the financial success/life she has? Not everyone is so maternally aware like your own Mum. I'd suggest you just accept that we're all different and count yourself very, very lucky.

Ginnnny · 25/12/2023 21:22

Her coldness with the kids shocks you when she’s also critical of you? Maybe she feels she does enough by paying for your lifestyle…

SD1978 · 25/12/2023 21:40

So because she won't give you her own bed, and when paying for holidays give you the best room, on top of the house keeper, private schools and the holidays, and will not cancel plans on your behalf, she's a shit parent? Maybe stop being so happy to take everything from her then. You've said she does play with your kids, just not the way the IL's do. If you're not happy, stop using her for your lifestyle benefits......

SarahAndQuack · 25/12/2023 21:42

It sounds as if you have nice parents and nice in-laws. That's lovely.

AtrociousCircumstance · 25/12/2023 21:44

The money is the key here. It keeps you infantilised. Have you read or watched an adaptation of Pride and Prejudice? Lady Catherine de Burgh is an absolute monster - critical and controlling - but if you want to benefit from her enormous wealth you have to suck it up. Characters fall into the sucking up category or the refusal to do so category.

Your mum doesn’t sound like a monster, but difficult and harsh. Used to her own way. Used to having this immense power and having people
fall into line.

However I have no idea how you or anyone would turn down being handed riches like that - huge riches - on a plate. The first option is to accept her as she is and learn some techniques for refusing her criticism. Therapy will help as a PP says.

Jioyt · 25/12/2023 22:04

OP, you say you come from a culture where people are blunt. Have you ever said something hurtful/blunt back to your mum? How does she take it?

It could be that she is not aware of how insensitive her comments are. The next time she says something, pull her up on it and let her know how it makes you feel.

As for her supporting you, count your blessings and realise you're lucky to be able to live a lifestyle many dream of because of your mum.

It's no different from a sahm/sahd with a successful spouse who brings in the money that enables the family to have a nice lifestyle. Given a choice, I'd rather be dependent on my mum than a guy who may divorce me tomorrow and leave me struggling. At least with your mum, the bond is thicker (my opinion).

ncfrths · 26/12/2023 12:21

@Jioyt
Have you ever said something hurtful/blunt back to your mum? How does she take it?

It depends on the topic of what I criticise her for. If I say something about appearance (eg you've gained weight or that bag doesn't go with your outfit) she'd take it well and respond with something like "yeah I ate croissants every day in Paris, trying to stick to light meals now that I'm back" or "ah you think maybe this bag is better?"
But if it's her decisions or the way she leads her life then she'd get annoyed as she often thinks her views are the only right views. And would likely then make a dig back at me or just act offended and quiet for a while. For example, if I say she drank too much at occasion X and I don't like how she acted (she doesn't drink a lot or often, that's just an example) or if I say I don't like her talking loudly on the phone during a nap if we're doing a pram walk / nap in the pram whilst we walk it'll be "don't go on walks with me then" and acting annoyed that I've given her any criticism.
If I say that I wish she paid more attention and actually made an effort with my child she'd say something like "I'm not here to be a clown, your child so you keep her entertained, I'd rather watch some TV" or if I say that I like how in laws are so hands on and will spend hours playing with a dolls house she'll say something like "well that's nice that it's fun for them, I need more mental stimulation than that"

OP posts:
WhenIsSpringg · 26/12/2023 12:51

This is the definition of biting the hand that feeds you.

If my mum did this for me, I would be thanking her everyday and trying to make her life easier in any way I could.

Perhaps you should stop taking her money if you would like the right to criticise her?

Densol57 · 26/12/2023 13:00

Id be more worried about your own behaviour and what this teaches your own child = ponce off mother, dont work, have a house keeper ( not even capable of running your own house ) but secretly moaning about your lot and mother and wonder why your mother criticises you!

Sorry yes = ungrateful goady brat

OutsideLookingOut · 26/12/2023 13:12

Your poor mum. I don't think everyone needs to be super child focussed. Also some people just have guests and incldue them in their lives not revolve around them. Two different approaches. I can't believe you take so much from her too... financially.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page