Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Horrible heirlooms

51 replies

Justadropofmilk · 23/12/2023 15:09

My DH is from a poor farming family and about 20 years ago his older brother inherited the family farm and everything in it when their DF died. He gave DH the chance to choose a couple of items from the house as mementos. DH chose photos, a couple of chairs and a clock his grandparents had owned.

The clock is hideous. Even my DH admits this. It has a flimsy wooden frame that at some point someone has cut down with a saw, probably in order to fit into a smaller space. They've just sawn the frame raggedly at a slight angle. It's also been kept somewhere very damp, which has meant the wood is discoloured, the mechanism has rusted and the face is covered in mildew spots. When DH came home with it I took it to a clock restorer to ask if it could be fixed. The restorer told me he wouldn't take it on — that it was a cheap, mass-produced clock which was worth almost nothing even in good condition. He said there were loads of them to be found in antique shops and his best recommendation was to go and buy a replacement but not pay more that £30. I have never told DH that: I know that the clock has sentimental value for him.

For years it's lived on a shelf in a dresser in the dining room, which we rarely use. Much of the time it's almost completely hidden by plants or other items. Now we've decided to remodel the house and the dining room wall will be knocked through and the dresser will have to go. The builder is due in the third week of January and we will be clearing the dining room once Christmas is over and clearing out and disposing of quite a lot of clutter and furniture.

For the last 20 years DH has never given the clock a thought. I'm the one who dusts it down every so often. As far as I'm aware he hasn't paid it the slightest attention since bringing it home. Earlier today we were talking about what we'd have to dispose of and agreed that the dresser and our old dining table and chairs, which we bought many years ago to fill in until we decided what we'd prefer, were going. I looked at the clock and said 'We'll need to work out what to do with the clock'. I didn't suggest disposing of it: I was quietly thinking it could go in the loft. But DH went into meltdown. He's said that he knows I hate the clock, even though I've never said anything about it in all these years. He grabbed it and hugged it to him and said it was his grandmother's and he'd part with it over his dead body... I kind of backed away quietly and said nothing. It's absolutely out of character for him. I know he has a very different attitude to things than I do but I've never see him react like that. I have very little sentimental attachment to stuff, even stuff from my late family. I keep one or two discreet small items but it wouldn't break my heart to lose them.

So obviously the clock is here to stay. Now, though, it's likely to be in a position where I'll have to see it every day. Has anyone else here inherited horrible heirlooms? How did you fit them into your home?

OP posts:
junebirthdaygirl · 24/12/2023 02:59

Could you leave the clock in a different place to be repaired and forget to collect it? Sounds like dh never would get around to it!

Stichintime · 24/12/2023 03:08

If its cheep and mass produced I would bin the mouldy clock and buy a replica. I would gradually move the replica back from display until it was mostly hidden, then one day remove it altogether and see if it's missed.

Otherwise place a a house plant near by and train it to almost cover the clock.

LuckyPeonies · 24/12/2023 03:55

Perhaps you could bribe one of the builders to accidentally knock the clock over and shatter it, or drop something heavy on it? 😁

daisychain01 · 24/12/2023 04:18

I've always lived by the maxim about surrounding yourself with things that you know to be useful or believe to be beautiful and the poor old clock is neither.

Thanks goodness William Morris existed, right? Grin

My DH has hoarding tendencies but he did agree to donating all the *family silver" when we moved in together, for which I was eternally grateful, as I can't stand being surrounded by clutter. We do have a few legacy items tat but luckily they are small enough to fit into a drawer and get forgotten. I am ruthlessly unsentimental like you, so can empathise with the frustration.

cant get over the unfairness of your BIL inheriting a whole farm, and your DH nothing, but "allowed" to pick a couple of items. Having said that, farmers are notoriously asset rich, cash poor, so owning a farm is actually quite a burden and responsibility, so your DH may have got off lightly!

dottypencilcase · 24/12/2023 04:51

tokesqueen · 23/12/2023 19:14

PIL house is full of 'heirlooms' they keep saying will be ours which include hideous old grandfather clocks. He and SIL have agreed a large skip will likely be the order of the day for most of it.

Please let me have one of the grandfather clocks- I've always wanted but can't afford one!!!

MeMySonAnd1 · 24/12/2023 07:01

DP also got a clock from his dad, the only thing aside of rubbish his brother allowed him to have. It us a grandfather’s clock, not very good quality and the face looks inexpensive. I didn’t see the point if it or where on Earth to put it when DP took it home.

It languished, in pieces, in the hallway for weeks until I got fed up and insisted in putting it up in a bedroom before someone broke it (didn’t fit anywhere else really)

The bedroom is painted in FB Down Pipe… and the clock looks AMAZING against it!

I think the person you spoke to was very rude and unkind in their advice for the clock. Sure, you can get old mantel piece clocks for pennies these days BUT it is about the sentimental value. The clock is so ugly it is quirky, it just needs a better place less prominent place to keep the peace with your OH , because believe me, the mantra “keep in your home just things that are useful or you believe to be beautiful” also applies to other people in the household.

MintJulia · 24/12/2023 08:46

An ex had a stuffed owl that belonged to his gran. It was a horrible, evil looking thing complete with impaled mouse, in a glass case. 🙁

He kept going on about how the taxidermist said it was a fine example of a Victorian blah blah blah. But it was just horrible.

And going off at a tangent, who, in God's name chooses to be a taxidermist?

Justadropofmilk · 24/12/2023 10:14

@Procrastination4 that looks lovely! Yes, those legs are currently a bit too baroque for current tastes but the white marble top calms it down. It's a practical piece and looks great in your more modern setting. Very classy. I'm envious!

OP posts:
Justadropofmilk · 24/12/2023 10:38

cant get over the unfairness of your BIL inheriting a whole farm, and your DH nothing, but "allowed" to pick a couple of items. Having said that, farmers are notoriously asset rich, cash poor, so owning a farm is actually quite a burden and responsibility, so your DH may have got off lightly!

Yes, this is something that still rankles — mainly me but also him. DH was the younger son and he and his sister grew up knowing that their big brother would inherit. It's what happens: it avoids farms being split up or sold (which is what the deceased parents want to avoid, having sacrificed their whole lives to keep the place going). His brother didn't just inherit 250 acres of now very valuable farmland and a five-bedroom farmhouse filled with cheap tat. He already owned a large, swanky house built on the farm's land at his parents' cost in 1999, so that he could give up his work as a fairly high-ranking manager at British Telecom and come back and help supervise the farm when they retired. So when DH's dad died DH's big brother (who is nearly 15 years older than DH) got the land (which had gone from being worth very little to being worth a fortune in value over the years), two big houses, his redundancy settlement from BT and a humungous BT pension which he's been drawing since he's 55. As soon as their dad died Big Brother sold off several acres for a housing estate and made the best part of another million on top of what he already had. DH got the clock, two (admittedly rather nice) chairs and photo albums.

I have to try very hard not to think bad thoughts about DH's parents. He was the youngest, the accidental one, and they absolutely adored him. He grew up poor but hugely loved and he was devastated when they died. Money isn't everything.

OP posts:
StarlightLime · 24/12/2023 14:29

Procrastination4 · 24/12/2023 01:59

We inherited a hall table that I really wanted to get rid of as I thought it was too big and awkward in our hall, but over the years I’ve got used to it, and now enjoy using it for Halloween and Christmas displays. For the rest of the time it’s quite useful for dumping the post on!😉

I love your polar bear!

Procrastination4 · 24/12/2023 15:16

@Justadropofmilk Thanks! The table has been in my husband’s family for years and at first I was planning ways that I could get rid of it! However, over the years I’ve grown used to it, and it’s grown on me. Our hall is quite big anyway, and, after moving an internal door a few feet when we were doing a major job on our kitchen a couple of years ago, the table suddenly had a nook all of its own so it weirdly looks fine now.

@StarlightLime The polar bear probably looks a bit incongruous under the crib scene, but my other half is a big kid at heart and loves Christmas and really wanted that bear but we had no place for him (our house is seriously OTT decorations-wise at Christmas) until I suggested that he could maybe go under the hall table…it’s a perfect bear cave!🤣

Noseyoldcow · 24/12/2023 15:41

I have all sorts of stuff I don't want in my home courtesy of my husband, who is a bit of a collector/ hoarder. But since I love him, I can just about put up with his junk.

Noseyoldcow · 24/12/2023 15:50

Posted without reading the thread, sorry. Just read OPs thread saying that eldest sold off land for housing, but didn't share the proceeds. What a cunt. Ok, he inherited the farm to keep it going. But surely his parents would want the actual assets split? Reminds me of my old Dad . Who inherited some money - not much- split 5 ways amongst all the kids from his Dad. My Dad said he was well enough off thanks, and gave his share to the youngest, who was not. Sadly, it turned out that she had a coercive git of a husband, though no one knew that at the time. Still, she might have got some benefit which was all my Dad wanted, and my Grandad would have too.

Janieforever · 24/12/2023 15:53

Why don’t you source a replacement, he said they were widely available and cheap and tell him you had it repaired as a gift for him?

wafflingworrier · 24/12/2023 15:56

Noseyoldcow · 24/12/2023 15:50

Posted without reading the thread, sorry. Just read OPs thread saying that eldest sold off land for housing, but didn't share the proceeds. What a cunt. Ok, he inherited the farm to keep it going. But surely his parents would want the actual assets split? Reminds me of my old Dad . Who inherited some money - not much- split 5 ways amongst all the kids from his Dad. My Dad said he was well enough off thanks, and gave his share to the youngest, who was not. Sadly, it turned out that she had a coercive git of a husband, though no one knew that at the time. Still, she might have got some benefit which was all my Dad wanted, and my Grandad would have too.

Your dad sounds so kind, that is lovely to read. I hope the family member has left the coercive person 💐

I would keep the clock, it clearly means a lot to your husband and you love him. It would be pretty brutal to break it on purpose!
Maybe you could find a vintage style corner shelf or a set of 3 plain ones then decorate, so that it is a feature that makes you both smile e.g. put it at the back of shelf with photo frames in front of family members.

I think houses that look too styled are boring and a bit "new money" if I'm honest though, so have a house dull of sentimental tat.

Noseyoldcow · 24/12/2023 16:04

Also reminded of my mums mum. A bit outing, but she separated from my grandad due to his infidelity, way back in the war years. I grew up thinking that his housekeeper M was actually his housekeeper. During the separation - she wasn't at fault legally and never granted him a divorce - she expressed a wish to leave her house (which my grandad bought but agreed was hers) to my parents as her other daughters had emigrated from the Uk. My parents ( who could have jolly well done with the inheritance!) said no and that any inheritance should be split between all her offspring. End result? She died, and with the laws of intestacy, her legal husband- my grandad, inherited. He married M within a week of my grandmothers death. And shortly after he died intestate. So M inherited the lot. And my Mum and her siblings nothing but keepsakes. I'm hoping what of those I've inherited from my mum might be with a few bob, but I doubt it. And I'd never sell anyway.

Noseyoldcow · 24/12/2023 16:21

Yes, waffingworrier, she did leave him. But not until, sadly, his ways, had damaged their daughter, and she was now an adult. He was so controlling, and my aunt so trusting and compliant and frankly simple, that he got away with denying them any heating/tv until he was in the house. Imagine growing up with that? Home from school and sitting in a freezing cold flat in your coat until he got home and deemed you could turn stuff on? Even more sadly, his daughter blames her mum, and her wider family (who knew nothing about it) for her awful childhood. Of course, if anyone had known, someone in our family would have stepped in. But my aunt (now sadly recently deceased also) never let anyone know. And that of course is the nature of coercion. Until she confided in her sister that she hated him and wanted to stab him, and then it all came tumbling out. Awful. And of course now we all blame ourselves for not seeing it. But if she wasn't saying, how could we? Sorry to derail the thread. But just shows how family can miss stuff. If any of us had had any inkling of any of it, Mr Coercive would have been knocked seven bells into next week, maybe physically too but definitely legally.

Justadropofmilk · 24/12/2023 16:38

Janieforever · 24/12/2023 15:53

Why don’t you source a replacement, he said they were widely available and cheap and tell him you had it repaired as a gift for him?

Because it wouldn't be his grandparents' clock. It's about it being their clock, knocked about as it is.

OP posts:
ErrolTheRednosedDragon · 24/12/2023 16:55

DH inherited a few things I don't like - some of them like an oddly ugly Wedgwood urn he's put into my china cabinet which is my main heirloom, but I can't complain as he had the latter renovated.

He's also got a particularly hideous teapot, which lives on the bookcase on the landing. Apparently his grandmother was very proud of it, that's sort of why he keeps it - to remind us we're lucky to have nice things that we can take for granted.

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 24/12/2023 18:53

You need a pet cat. Tell the cat the clock is very special and not to be knocked over.

Then wait. The cat will know what to do.

ANightmareBeforeChristmas · 24/12/2023 18:56

As long as he is not hoarding loads of junk, I would let this go. The clock is obviously important to him - it's not like a huge piece of furniture - let him put it where he likes.

willsandnoodle · 24/12/2023 19:05

Can you buy a replacement that's in good condition, and tell the dh you took the heirloom to be restored?

willsandnoodle · 24/12/2023 19:05

Ignore me, just red alone else suggested the same

MouseMinge · 24/12/2023 19:35

I have a dog "Teddy" from the 1960s and he is in a dreadful state but he's been with me my whole life and I would never get rid of him. He's my Captain Rover. I've been thinking of contacting The Repair Shop, maybe you could do that too @Justadropofmilk ? They won't care that it's ugly and not worth anything, it's all about sentimental meaning and it means a lot to your husband. If you got it repaired it would look so much better and you'd hate it a lot less.

RedVanYellowVan · 24/12/2023 20:12

I once jokingly told some removal men I would not report them if they "accidentally" dropped an item. They said I wouldn't believe how often they were asked to lose or damage things.