Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Worried my lazy CF mat leave cover will make me redundant?

10 replies

Bilbymum · 19/12/2023 17:11

Sorry this is super long but don’t want to drip feed.

I've been fortunate enough to have a 3 month handover period with my maternity leave cover before I go on leave in March. To set the scene, I work in the UK, but remotely in a global role in marketing - my colleagues are all over the world. I am subject to UK employment laws.

My concern is that a lazy/underperforming mat leave cover may look really bad for my role while I'm away, and given it is a known thing that restructuring is happening, I'm worried about my position. If the cover doesn't perform/makes my position look bad/redundant (i.e. not producing anything of value) I worry my role will be made redundant. A lot of my job is self directed but what I produce adds value.

My cover is someone from an agency our company uses (rather than a maternity contract position). I had no say in my cover, my manager went for this option as it was cheaper than hiring a contractor.

She lives in another part of the world. When I come online at 9, it's the last two hours of her day (3-5pm). I asked her at the start of Nov whether she was 100% allocated to this role, and she said yes. I've been handing over and training up the cover for almost one month. This involves a 2 hour meeting where I go through work that I do and she shadows/I talk her through it, or direct training with training decks and documentation, and sometimes joining meetings I attend. That would lead me to expect that she has another 6 hours to fill in the day - 4-5hrs if I'm being generous with multiple breaks in the day. At first I was a bit daunted as I didn't know how I was going to fill her other 6 hours. But now I'm very much feeling on the other end of the spectrum...

I share a list of bite size tasks, exercises, training videos, documentation for her to do that is the outcome of our daily meetings, with the expectation that she can EASILY complete these in the 9am-3pm window she has the next day before our meeting. I am not exaggerating when I say most of these activities should not take more than 30 minutes each (a VERY generous estimate - some are 5 minute jobbies), maybe in total over the month there have been 2-3 activities which could take roughly an hour (as in, watch a training video or a recorded meeting). I would ask the next day how she went with X,Y,Z activities, did she have any questions, and most of the time, nothing has been done for a few days. This pattern of behaviour consistently for a month! At any given point, there would not have been more than 3 activities to do. We end up doing some of the activities together in our meeting, because I'm actually stuck and can't move forward with a piece of work until it's been done, and I want to harness the teaching opportunity/get her to get get hands on, rather than do it myself which might take me <5 minutes (think editing a Facebook post from "2023" to "2024" or something small to this effect).

It's not even that she attempts to do it and is stuck - that is not a problem, I genuinely love teaching and helping my colleagues. I want to see her succeed. I am despairing because NOTHING has been done because she has been busy 'running errands', or going to 'appointments' (6 hours worth of appointments in one day??) , or sick kids. I get it with the sick kids and had empathy for this (have my own), and in my head I've written them off as a Carer's Leave days, but why are you running errands or decorating your house for Christmas (yes she told me this!?) on company time? I'm in an awkward position because I'm not her manager - I'm just the person who is handing over to her. I am not here to performance manage.

I am 100% sure that this attitude will continue over into the year I'm taking out for maternity leave, and not even the bare minimum will get done without lots of reminders and prompting from others.

My manager is super hands off, trusts me to get on with my responsibilities, and doesn't really like to get involved in performance/conflict/confrontation etc. He will probably ask me when we catch up how the handover is going, and I plan to tell him that it's slow going because of the various disruptions, and that I'm struggling to understand why she is unable to complete (VERY generously estimating) 1-2 hours worth of tasks, when she has 6 hours to spare in the day. I want to say that I'm concerned about how this will reflect on my role when I'm away. I don’t think he will do any performance management whilst I’m away, it is just not his style.

I would be grateful to MN to give any advice on

  • Whether there is any law in the UK that would protect my role from being made redundant whilst I am on maternity leave, especially if it is related to the performance of my cover?
  • Any thoughts on how to approach (and continue to communicate) this issue with my manager?
  • Any ideas on how to protect myself/role (e.g. I've just started to try and keep a log of the 'busy running errands' and 'decorating' comments - which feels really petty from me but not sure what else to do)
  • Anything else would be really helpful.

I really like my job, and really worried it's all going to turn to sh*t when I'm away and my cover makes my role look useless. The main thing is, I don't want to role to be made redundant because it looks like it isn't contributing anything of value for a year. Thanks in advance!

OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 19/12/2023 17:13

I imagine they will welcome you back with open arms.

Thinkero · 19/12/2023 17:14

You’re protected OP.

You are allowed by law to return to the same job on the same conditions and pay if you have only taken 26 weeks mat leave (ordinary maternity leave)

If you take the full year, which it sounds as if you want to, they have to have a very very good reason to not allow it - such as, the role no longer exists. If the role does exist but they want your cover to keep on doing it then that’s not allowed and you’d have a case for maternity discrimination.

DeedlessIndeed · 19/12/2023 17:20

(OP correct me if I'm wrong) I think that actually OP is saying that she is concerned that the role will no longer exist.

She's not saying she thinks the company would prefer the cover, but instead they'll look at the cover's output during the restructure and determine that the role is no longer required.

My understanding is that you can be impacted by redundancy whilst on mat leave but hopefully another poster has more experience.

mrboombasticwhy · 19/12/2023 17:21

Hmm

jay55 · 19/12/2023 17:24

If they are from an agency can you not speak up now and say they're not up to standard, can they allocate someone else?

WillowCraft · 19/12/2023 17:26

Thinkero · 19/12/2023 17:14

You’re protected OP.

You are allowed by law to return to the same job on the same conditions and pay if you have only taken 26 weeks mat leave (ordinary maternity leave)

If you take the full year, which it sounds as if you want to, they have to have a very very good reason to not allow it - such as, the role no longer exists. If the role does exist but they want your cover to keep on doing it then that’s not allowed and you’d have a case for maternity discrimination.

I don't think you read the OP.

It's perfectly possible to be made redundant while on maternity just as at any other time, as long as it's genuine.

Surely her manager will have to step in if she's not doing anything? Unless the role genuinely is pointless?

WillowCraft · 19/12/2023 17:27

jay55 · 19/12/2023 17:24

If they are from an agency can you not speak up now and say they're not up to standard, can they allocate someone else?

Yes...if there's still time, try and get someone else instead?

WashItTomorrow · 19/12/2023 17:27

It is very possible to be made redundant while on maternity leave.

Bilbymum · 19/12/2023 17:30

edit - this is in response to suggestions about getting someone else from agency - forgot to quote

I think this is worth suggesting.
Not that my post isn’t outing enough 😅 but the cover has ties to my company before they starting working for this agency which is why my manager thought she was a shoo in.
But not a bad suggestion, thank you. Other people from the agency have a better work ethic, if not as familiar with the systems and company. But that is her edge and why she got the role.

OP posts:
TigerJoy · 22/12/2023 21:35

You need to speak to your manager ASAP, do not wait for your next scheduled meeting. Tell them this person is just not going any work - you have well documented examples here (you set clear tasks, they were not done), including the frankly unprofessional things this person is saying as to why (decorating their house, running errands).

This is not going to work out in your absence. There is plenty of time to find a reasonable replacement.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page