Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about this London birthday gig present situation?

94 replies

warmmincepies · 13/12/2023 20:42

Compared to other threads, this is all very first-world problems but I feel like I've lost all perspective on this so please let me know if IABU.

I found out a few days ago that my favourite band is playing a one-off gig in London this month - the day after my birthday. They were on hiatus for many years, but they played a small comeback gig in Scotland (where I live) earlier this year, and which my DP and I attended and loved. For info, I've been to almost every gig they've ever played in my city, always with DP, and I've loved them for decades.

So when I learned they were playing the day after my birthday, I thought it was a total no-brainer as a birthday present. Nothing else would have lived up to it. Especially as we actually travelled several years ago to Ireland for my birthday, where and when the band played a gig. I thought we could make a mini-break out of it in London, like we'd done in Ireland. Easy.

But my DP is Not Keen at all. He says there's no point, that we've already seen the band this year. They're releasing a new album soon, so in all likelihood will be touring next year with a good chance of being in our city again. He says there'll be too much rushing around for trains, that the venue is in an awkward place to get out of time-wise, if the gig ends at 11pm and our train is at 11.45pm. It'll be expensive if we also stay overnight, there'll be too much walking around in the cold to kill time, and taking time off work might be an issue. Frankly, he's been a workaholic all year - not really his fault, he's been placed on a big project at work - but we haven't been on holiday, and did nothing for a milestone anniversary.

I thought this plan could rectify all of these things by giving us a mini-holiday. I've never seen London at Christmas. So I said, well, if we're staying overnight, we'll do something special the next day that you want to do. Every time we've gone down to London before, because it's such a trek, we usually see two shows/attractions, one for each of us. So he took a look online but said nothing appeals. I just don't think he enjoys London. He says he only went to the Ireland gig because he'd never been to Ireland before. He said he'd have been more likely to go to this gig if the band had announced a one-off gig in Berlin or somewhere we've never been.

By now, I'm very exasperated. This is my favourite band, this is my ideal present, nothing else would compare frankly. So I say fine, I'll go down by myself. This alarms DP. He says that if I went down on my own for my birthday, then he would feel incredibly guilty and he should be there with me to celebrate. I shrug and tell him that sounds more like his problem. He's now very sad and having a bit of an existential crisis over it, says it's all he's been thinking about. I don't think he'd forgive himself if I went down alone, but also... I just want to see the band?? And if we both went down, I have a feeling he'd be so stressed about travel that he wouldn't make it the most enjoyable experience.

So now we're at a sort of stalemate. DP and I very rarely disagree on things and usually manage to hash something out. I don't know if I'm doing the equivalent of screaming I WANT A PONY and should get over myself, especially as DP only had a modest cinema/restaurant birthday this year, or if I should just LTB, etc.

Maybe the tickets will sell out first and we won't have to make a decision??

OP posts:
thelonemommabear · 14/12/2023 08:18

I think you are being very manipulative to be honest - basically demanding it as your bday gift and then threatening to go alone if he doesn't book it and come with you.

EvilElsa · 14/12/2023 08:20

He needs to get a grip. It's a bloody gig, no need for such a dramatic reaction. The moping would annoy me far more than his refusal to go to London.
Just go on your own. You don't want someone whining and looking miserable at something you've been looking forward to. Book a hotel and have a great time.

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 14/12/2023 08:22

By chance I got tickets to my fav rock star.. Got tickets with mate's adult ds!! At the last minute dh said he would come. The one and only concert goer who stood still th entire time with a face like a smacked arse.. Wish to hell had left him at home. By lucky chance I've tickets for next year and a new fab dh to go with. Go alone or take a friend..

Spencer0220 · 14/12/2023 08:22

What sprung to mind for me is that he's desperately trying to put you off the idea, unconvincingly.

Are you sure he's not planned something already? Maybe not with this band though

BoomBhuna · 14/12/2023 08:23

Can any of us Londoners help you with logistics to make it easier? Would help to know the location of the gig?

I think you should go. Alone or with a friend. He is really overthinking this.

If it’s the James Taylor quartet this weekend, you could hang out with my friends who are going maybe ;-)

MetalFences · 14/12/2023 08:25

thelonemommabear · 14/12/2023 08:18

I think you are being very manipulative to be honest - basically demanding it as your bday gift and then threatening to go alone if he doesn't book it and come with you.

Yes, you should never do what you want in life. Only what your boyfriend wants.

And doing something you want to do without your boyfriend is a threat.

Asking for something for your own birthday is a disgrace. You should just wait quietly in the corner. Not manipulate the situation to get what you want for your birthday, or indeed in life.

Just be carried along by the wants and needs of others instead of having your own likes and opinions. He matters more than you. Especially on your birthday.

easylikeasundaymorn · 14/12/2023 13:03

Off topic but why do so many people care about what band it is?

It doesn't affect the situation in any way.

Plus unlike the ubiquitous dh's unnamed hobby if a small band it could actually be quite outing for op to post, e.g. any friend she's mentioned this too or her dh will immediately know who she is!

KingsleyBorder · 14/12/2023 13:04

thelonemommabear · 14/12/2023 08:18

I think you are being very manipulative to be honest - basically demanding it as your bday gift and then threatening to go alone if he doesn't book it and come with you.

Why is going alone a threat? Is she not allowed to go anywhere by herself?

Brefugee · 14/12/2023 13:07

Off topic but why do so many people care about what band it is?

so we can mock OPs bad taste in music? or bond over good taste? or say "oh I'm going to that, i could meet you if you don't want to go alone"

because we're REALLY nosey?

HotGirlInHell · 14/12/2023 13:36

easylikeasundaymorn · 14/12/2023 13:03

Off topic but why do so many people care about what band it is?

It doesn't affect the situation in any way.

Plus unlike the ubiquitous dh's unnamed hobby if a small band it could actually be quite outing for op to post, e.g. any friend she's mentioned this too or her dh will immediately know who she is!

Because it's interesting!

Toddlerteaplease · 14/12/2023 13:39

Go on your own? I would!

Hitshow · 14/12/2023 13:40

Is he always such a drama llama?

This would very much be a case of go on my own and do some shopping whilst there.

WilloTheWispy · 15/12/2023 20:00

Brefugee · 14/12/2023 13:07

Off topic but why do so many people care about what band it is?

so we can mock OPs bad taste in music? or bond over good taste? or say "oh I'm going to that, i could meet you if you don't want to go alone"

because we're REALLY nosey?

Because - as @Brefugee says (in my case at least) - I’m a nosey bastard!

Divebar2021 · 17/12/2023 09:24

I’m not that interested in the band but kind of interested in the venue in case I can offer some personal experience. ( and to show that no you will not need to be walking the streets in the cold beforehand)

warmmincepies · 29/12/2023 21:39

Hi all, I wanted to give an update (because every thread should come with an update!) -

Discussed it with DP and told him that stopping me from going down was unfair. Although he still felt bad about not being there with me, he totally understood... and I enjoyed a festive break in London - by myself! - courtesy of DP.

The first day, I was actually sympathetic to DP's viewpoint - it is a LOT of hassle and expense, and I'd forgotten how insanely busy London can be. But the concert was fabulous, I'm so privileged I got to be there, and the next day I explored places I hadn't been before and even splashed out on tix to a West End show. It was such an amazing birthday!

When I posted, I'd half-heartedly resigned myself to not going down. So this was a fab adventure for me. The trip was very liberating, and I hope more travel adventures - solo or otherwise! - lie in store in 2024.

Thanks, all!

OP posts:
TheSquareMile · 29/12/2023 21:41

Which concert did you go to, OP?

FrancisSeaton · 29/12/2023 21:46

Why is the OP so reluctant to tell who the band is?
It's like all these stupid 'can't say what hobby my husband does it's outing' when it's just bloody cycling or golf

toomanypillows · 29/12/2023 21:54

Was it The Almighty?

Papillon23 · 29/12/2023 21:58

Glad you had a fantastic time OP! I went on holiday on my own last year and I should definitely go again - I had a great time and only pleasing yourself is very freeing.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread