Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

3 year old tantrums

33 replies

dAnkl · 11/03/2023 21:25

My 3 year old's tantrums are really really really testing my patience.

Almost any time he does not get his own way, a massive tantrum ensues.

I try to stay calm, but after an entire day of it, I'm starting to really struggle to stay calm.

Getting him ready for preschool is difficult. He's not happy to get ready and cries and screams while we are getting ready. He's happy once he's there.

Every day he comes home and he's unhappy and grumpy as soon as we get in. It's always something, for example he gets out of the car and decides he wants to get back in and pretend to drive / or he wants to walk around outside the house of whatever it may be. By the time he's inside, he's always having a tantrum.

He's then ok for a bit and the throws another tantrum if he wants to do something in the kitchen he's not allowed to do. For example he wants to ' help ' while I'm cooking. So I let him have a look and maybe stir a couple of things. I sometimes let him put ingredients in while we cook. But then we just need to leave the food alone to cook and he wants to carry on and has a tantrum about that.

He then often gets upset and has a tantrum about getting ready for bed/ brushing teeth / bath time. He doesn't want to do that.

When we go to the playground and have to leave, more often than not, he goes completely nuts because he wants to keep playing.

It's better some days, but some days it's really relentless.

I think he is tired sometimes. But he does have quite a solid routine. Occasionally he wakes up early or he may wake up in the night and that can result in more tantrums the next day.

He loves to just say no to everything at the moment.

How can I get through to him ? I am so extremely patient. I validate his feelings. ' I know you're sad because you want to keep playing ' etc etc. but when will this get easier ? His language has improved so much and he's able to tell me why he's upset. But he still just finds it so hard when he can't do what he wants.

Can anyone help ?

He has no tantrums at preschool and they have no concerns. He follows instructions / boundaries etc there. But I really struggle with him at home some days.

My husband says I'm not strict enough and need to tell him to stop more. Whenever I do tell him to stop, things just escalate. I usually try to distract him and or label his feelings but sometimes nothing helps at all. It's really sad because I feel like he's sad a lot and I don't know how to help him. It's made me really sad today and I just feel broken and like a really bad mum.

OP posts:
Donotneedit · 12/03/2023 21:12

she is telling him no all the time, so clearly there are boundaries

Aftjbtibg · 12/03/2023 21:18

I’d really recommend the book how to talk so little kids will listen; it really helped me with my first DC. My youngest is now 3 and we are in the same stage - it’s true that prevention is better than cure. One thing that helped in the morning is putting DS clothes out on the floor like a person and then some kind of game to get ready.
Sometimes there is no compromise or warning though and we use the thinking spot where he stays until he calms down; I’ll stay with him or at least keep coming back if I’m in the middle of cooking and we have a cuddle when he’s ready. I find it stressful if I’m trying to cook, listen to my other DC, and manage his tantrums so sometimes I need that space too and I try not to beat myself up about that as I’m only human

3WildOnes · 12/03/2023 21:32

Mariposista · 12/03/2023 15:00

So he won’t tidy up the ball pit when you ask? Dismantle it and put it away, he loses it for a week. Wont leave the park? No park the next day. Hits his brother? Straight to bed, don’t want to see you until morning. Tantrum in the kitchen? Removed and placed in another room away from you. His life will be hell for a couple of weeks haha but he will soon learn.

This is likely to escalate the bad behaviour. Children usually behave worse when they feel a lack of connection or feel bad about themselves which is exactly what those consequences wouod do.

anothermamaa · 12/03/2023 21:50

Ignore everything @Mariposista said. @WellRested has sound advice and this is what works in my house !

00100001 · 13/03/2023 20:38

Mariposista · 12/03/2023 15:00

So he won’t tidy up the ball pit when you ask? Dismantle it and put it away, he loses it for a week. Wont leave the park? No park the next day. Hits his brother? Straight to bed, don’t want to see you until morning. Tantrum in the kitchen? Removed and placed in another room away from you. His life will be hell for a couple of weeks haha but he will soon learn.

I feel sorry for your kid.

Raising them to fear your reactions.
That's how kids learn to hide things and be deceitful. They'll just learn to kick their brother when you're not there...or be confused and angry as to why they are alone in a room.

Imagine if you did something like...

  1. ran a red light and the police, stopped you, said "that's it, what a horrible woman you are. You know you're not allowed to jump a red light!!!" and an hour later came round to your house and removed your car for a week. Would you think that a useful and obvious punishment? What would you have learned...? The police are unfair, Draconian and probably not to get caught next time... ?

  2. ran a red light and the police stopped you at the time and said "there was a child about to cross the street that you could have run over" and had you see and talk to the child who was crying and scared about what nearly happened.
    What would you have learned? Your actions have real consequences and that you can make mistakes and rectify the situation and understand why you should think twice about jumping that red light....

Dontlickthebin · 30/11/2023 22:17

OP it's a few months down the line - did things get any better?

I'm having similar challenges with my 3yr old DS and could really do with a happy ending to give me hope!

Sunny866 · 30/11/2023 22:33

I could have written this myself! @dAnkl how are things now? I have a 3yo at home who just won’t listen to basic instructions and I have a 4 week old now too. 3yo has been like this for a while so I don’t think it’s anything to do with gaining a sibling or attention etc.

Ange1233556 · 30/11/2023 22:48

Nevergonnastop · 11/03/2023 23:24

He follows instructions / boundaries etc there

but it sounds like he doesn't have any at home. You definitely need to be tougher with him, he needs consequences.

This is completely wrong. It’s very normal to be “good” at school and wild at home. It’s a good thing! It means he is confident at home that he is unconditionally loved and can “act out”. He spends all his time at pre school behaving - it’s normal to relax when you get home (if you feel safe).

Ive got 3 boys and had epic meltdowns. Mu youngest is 3 and cried for 20 mins as I opened a door to let the cat out. He wanted to open it apparently. I got down on his level and told him I was sorry I didn’t know and that I loved him and then went about the kitchen cleaning. Not completely ignoring him but just saying - “oh it’s cold today isn’t it” and “shall we get a snack, I’m hungry” just general chat and he seems to calm down. Then when calm we have a cuddle and I ask him if he’s ok now? It’s a tough age

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread