Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sugary snacks on school trip???

33 replies

TurkishDeelite · 10/02/2008 23:01

My dd in reception class went to see a panto with her school a few weeks ago. Because of the timings etc. they were going to be late for lunch so the PTA decided to provide a snack on the way back. They were discussing whether to give Kitkats or chocolate biscuits etc. when I suggested the children could be given bananas instead as a much healthier snack. I really don't understand why they should be offered foods with no beneficial nutritional value. PTA agreed and said they would offer them apples, bananas and oranges for a selection. One lady at the PTA said her daughter would not eat ANY fruit, and she was not very happy with my suggestion, and she said she would give her daughter a Kitkat in any case, to take with her and eat on the way back...

When I asked my daughter what she had for a snack she said she had a chocolate biscuit! Appearantly they were also offered chocolate biscuits along with fruit! When even adults struggle to make the right nutricional choices I don't think little children can be expected to pick a fruit instead of a choc biscuit. I feel very upset about this! Am I being unreasonable???

OP posts:
PeachesMcLean · 10/02/2008 23:05

If they have a chocolate biscuit AND some fruit, is that a problem? Did they not get both?

paros · 10/02/2008 23:08

Ours arnt allowed to take chocolate or sweets on school trips .

TurkishDeelite · 10/02/2008 23:08

As far as I understand they had to pick something, either a fruit or a choc biscuit.

OP posts:
PeachesMcLean · 10/02/2008 23:10

Well if it was a choice of one or the other, then no, yanbu at all.

However, i'd be very happy for DS to have a choccy biscuit and an apple.

PTA woman insisting on kitkat is weird though.

smartiejake · 10/02/2008 23:11

Listen I'm all for a healthy balanced diet (dd1 is the only child I know who, as a toddler, had a tantrum in the vegetable aisle as she demanded brocolli I already had at home!)When dds have friends round for tea they are always presented with a huge plate of salad/ crudites to accompany their tea(which is only eaten by my dds)
But for goodness sake! It was a Panto! Are kids not allowed a few treats these days? Or do all the snacks have to be healthy? What next?
Muesli bars in a party bag!

unknownrebelbang · 10/02/2008 23:14

YABU.

It was a school trip.

You're fortunate that the PTA were able to provide a (any) snack.

TurkishDeelite · 10/02/2008 23:16

Treat and snack- to me they are two different things. And yes, my daughters do get a "treat" quite often. I just like to know and to a certain degree control what she eats and when she eats it. I am after all her mother, and she is only 4.5 years old.

OP posts:
snice · 10/02/2008 23:23

I'd like to see a group of 4/5 yr olds trying to eat oranges on a coach! Can imagine why they might have gone for the easier option of giving them all a biscuit.

TurkishDeelite · 10/02/2008 23:26

Oh by the way- they were offered a snack only to keep them going till they got to the school, where they would eat their lunch.

Some comments here indicated they would be happy with a combination of fruit and choc biscuit. This wasn't the case.

OP posts:
TurkishDeelite · 10/02/2008 23:28

Snice- can you imagine them eating an apple? How difficult would that be? Or perhaps peeling a banana may be easier than peeling a Kitkat?

OP posts:
snice · 10/02/2008 23:30

Funnily enough I can -which is why I said orange

FAQ · 10/02/2008 23:30
TurkishDeelite · 10/02/2008 23:37

I really can't understand why one may prefer bus tidiness over her childrens health?? ) Never mind- I got my response, albeit it wasn't what I was expecting!
Thanks for all your responses...........

Good night all!

OP posts:
FAQ · 10/02/2008 23:39

~So you really think that ONE chocolate biscuit is detrimental to a child's health

seeker · 10/02/2008 23:43

I don't think once chocolate biscuit's going to do much harm.

Scramble · 10/02/2008 23:43

FGS it is one choccy biscuit on a one off school trip.

My DD gets a packet of crisps at the kids club she goes to for a snack, OK its not the healthiest snakc in the world but hey who cares, it is a treat.

Why do people get soooo up tight about all this, I am quite happy that they are being looked after and fed something and having a good time , good enough for me.

unknownrebelbang · 10/02/2008 23:45

I'm amazed the bus company allowed children to eat anything on their bus!

notjustmom · 10/02/2008 23:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Scramble · 10/02/2008 23:51

I worked in a sweet shop and toy shop within a visitor attraction popular with school trips, you would all keel over and have palpitations at the junk they buy and consume on school trips, they probably know better than to tell you the truth.

So when they say they bought a wooden ruler and a note book with the name of the place on it but lost it, what they mean is they bought £1.50 worth of sweets and scoffed it onthe bas home. .

Desiderata · 10/02/2008 23:52

Isn't Turkish Delight a sweet ..... ?

Why don't you call yourself more approrpriate to your ideals, like FiveADay ...

Sorry, but I just can't get worked up about all this evangelist shite. It's just a bloody KitKat.

Desiderata · 10/02/2008 23:53

something more appropriate

But you know what I meant.

Scramble · 10/02/2008 23:54

What about HolierThanThou

Desiderata · 10/02/2008 23:59

Good one, good one

TurkishDeelite · 11/02/2008 00:00

Just asked for your learned opinions- please don't get so worked up!!

OP posts:
Scramble · 11/02/2008 00:03

You came, you asked, you smiled.

Nobodys worked up .