Mumsnet Logo
My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

Can someone explain in laymans terms what is happening with the BOE/pension funds on Friday?

398 replies

Silverin · 11/10/2022 21:38

There seems to be a lot of panicked talk in the financial media about pension funds potentially collapsing and the BOE needing to step in to help them but this support being stopped on Friday.

As a layperson, I would like to understand what is going on - what are gilts, what did the BOE do/not do and what are the risks to pension funds that could cause a collapse on Friday?

OP posts:
Report

Andypandy799 · 12/10/2022 07:33

lovescats3 · 12/10/2022 07:24

Understand this - keep voting Tory and this is what you will get- inept selfish people running the country

Look I’m not going to argue about party politics but what makes you think labour are any better?

I have had the unfortunate experience of having to fight our local government for gentrification and guess what they think nothing of the little people. Our local Labour Party is as bad as putin!

Full of misogynist men who bully women, getting back handeds and looking after there mates. Every politician makes me repulsed as they are horrible people.

Report

lannistunut · 12/10/2022 07:48

Andypandy799 · 12/10/2022 07:33

Look I’m not going to argue about party politics but what makes you think labour are any better?

I have had the unfortunate experience of having to fight our local government for gentrification and guess what they think nothing of the little people. Our local Labour Party is as bad as putin!

Full of misogynist men who bully women, getting back handeds and looking after there mates. Every politician makes me repulsed as they are horrible people.

Because the Labour party is in the economic mainstream. What Truss is doing is genuinely mental. She's the Tory equivalent of Corbyn.

Rishi Sunak said Truss would fuck the economy, he was right.

What is happening now is extreme and the only winners will be the already very wealthy, like the top 5%.

Report

lannistunut · 12/10/2022 07:50

And I really don't think any local party of any colour is 'as bad as Putin' @Andypandy799 that comment is both offensive and embarrassing.

Report

1245J · 12/10/2022 07:57

RedToothBrush · 12/10/2022 06:17

Vote of no confidence in government is the most obvious answer. Which tory backbenchers support. This is different to the 1922 Committee route which took out Johnson. The problem for the 1922 route atm, is the party rules don't allow for a challenge to the leadership in such a short period. Truss currently has immunity. They could change the party rules but this requires a vote and is time consuming. This situation is much more urgent and needs action on Wednesday not next week.

If the pm fails a vote of no confidence in the Hoc, she has the choice to either resign or a ge is called. If the PM resigns without calling an election then there is a period within someone must be put forward someone who can claim the support of the house ie get a majority of MPs to support them - this is usually along the lines of having the support of majority party but it doesn't have to be. In theory it can be a cross party government. (see WWII). The Tory party could put up a temporary leader if the members agree to it (with the view to having a leadership contest which is a risk to the markets in its own right as the government is effectively in limbo until conclusion of that with the temporary leader somewhat handicapped over making significant decisions. The markets won't like this uncertainty and lack of anyone in real control) or they could simply agree on a single candidate to be PM without the need for an internal party election.

Problem with this is, atm, a GE means tories voting to make themselves unemployed. Which is why most won't take the risk. And the Tory party is so factionalised it would be incredibly hard to come to agreement on an annioted successor to Truss. You really can't rule out Johnson in this scenario btw - he is perhaps the only person I think the party will think can pull it off.

Good analysis RTB.

We really are in a period similar to that between 1990 - 1995. This time the events are ordered differently. The damage has been done before the General Election. Two more years for that damage to unwind and play out.

Major inherited the PM role when Thatcher resigned. In 1992 when he won the GE he famously said "I have my own mandate. I have my own mandate." I cannot even start to think this could happen to Liz Truss.

Labour need to come up with a plan. They are not the party of default. Neil Kinnock proved that.

Report

Buggsilla · 12/10/2022 07:57

Can you explain what you mean please @lannistunut 'Because the Labour party is in the economic mainstream'

Report

Phineyj · 12/10/2022 07:58

@Bookclub99 and others, I'm so grateful! I've found your detailed explanations really helpful. I'm an Economics teacher and now I feel prepared to debate with my brightest year 13s. I've always found the financial markets topic the hardest to teach because it's all so technical and real life diverges from the syllabus and textbooks with us lot limping along behind!! (and being buttonholed by colleagues wanting investment advice...)

Report

Buggsilla · 12/10/2022 08:01

Jewel1968 · 12/10/2022 06:32

Thanks to all of you explaining this so well and simply. Professor Feynman would be pleased.

My question is - do you think it's a problem that so many of us don't really understand how all of this works? Do you think if we all had a better understanding of how capitalism and all the little mechanisms within worked it would influence anything?

I think we need a basic economics tv show where the money flow is explained in a digestable way, so we can all understand the ramifications of different actions.

Report

cakeorwine · 12/10/2022 08:04

The whole stock market itself seems dodgy.

Leveraging.

Offering deals to bet on the differences between stocks etc

Report

MarshaBradyo · 12/10/2022 08:06

Bookclub99 · 11/10/2022 23:30

This is what is happening:

A Gilt is debt issued by the UK. When the Treasury needs to borrow money, it issues a Gilt (effectively an IOU note) to investors. For example, if the Treasury issued a £100 4% coupon 5-year Gilt, it would receive £100 from an investor and give them in exchange an IOU note in which it promised to repay the investor £100 in 5 years time and in the meantime pay them £4 of interest each year. The investor doesn't have to hold the IOU note until the Treasury repays the debt at the end of 5 years. It can sell the IOU note to other investors or buy more IOU notes from yet more investors if it wants to.

For reasons I won't go into here (because it will take ages to explain) defined benefit (aka final salary) pension schemes need to invest the money they will ultimately use to fund their members' pension payments in Gilts. Lots and lots of Gilts. So many, in fact, that they borrowed money to buy those Gilts. For example, if a pension scheme had £100, it went and borrowed an extra £200 and invested £300 in Gilts. Borrowing money to invest in something magnifies gains and losses. In the example given above, if you had invested just the original £100 and your Gilt investment lost 20% of its value you would have lost £20, leaving you with £80. However, if you borrowed £200 and invested £300, then you would have lost £60, leaving you with just £40 once you had paid back the £200 you borrowed.

For yet more reasons I won't go into (because I lack the skill to explain this in layman's terms), when interest rates rise, the price of Gilts falls.

The Bank of England sets interest rates and uses them to control inflation by increasing them when inflation threatens. Because of a mix of Brexit, Covid shutdowns in China and Russia's invasion of Ukraine, there have been supply shortages of certain things (e.g., oil/gas because of the Ukraine thing). This has led to inflation because when things are in short supply their prices increase.The Bank of England has raised interest rates to combat this inflation. This led to the price of Gilts falling. A lot.

Then old Truss/Kwarteng come along and announced a load of tax cuts. Tax cuts are inflationary because people have more money to spend, further driving up the price of those things in short supply.

This meant the Bank of England had to raise interest rates even more. The price of Gilts fell further. A lot further.

Now back to those pension schemes. They are making huge losses on their Gilt holdings. Because they borrowed money to invest in those Gilts, their losses have been magnified, and the people who lent them the money are now demanding they pay it back, so the pension schemes are having to sell Gilts to repay the money, further driving down the price of Gilts... it's a vicious cycle.

To help the pension schemes, the Bank of England offered to step in and buy Gilts. By buying Gilts, the Bank of England drives their price higher, thereby stemming the pension schemes' losses and arresting that vicious cycle. However, the Bank of England really doesn't want to do this. The reason why is because the Bank of England has to print money to buy the Gilts. Money printing is inflationary... so will ultimately drive interest rates higher (to control the inflation), which will force the price of Gilts lower, so the Bank of England has to print more money to buy more Gilts to save the pension schemes... and so on. Another doom loop. That is why the Bank of England put a time limit on buying Gilts - they wanted to do just enough to buy the pension schemes some time to stablise themselves - then stop to avoid the doom loop scenario. That time limit expires this Friday.

People thought the Bank of England might extend the time limit because the pension schemes are still in a huge mess, however the governor has just said that won't happen (presumably because he wants to avoid the doom loop scenario). So now everyone is shitting themselves.

It's all horribly messy. I don't know how this will be fixed, but the only realistic options are: 1) the Bank of England capitulates and starts buying Gilts again (this isn't a good answer because of the doom loop issue), or 2) Truss/Kwarteng reverse all their stupid tax cuts and resign.

If neither of those two things happens some pension schemes may make irrecoverable losses which would mean they wouldn't have enough money to fulfil the promises they made to their members. The only way to fix this would be for the pension scheme employer to put money into the scheme (some won't have enough), for the government to put money into failing schemes (i.e., a bailout) and/or the pension schemes break their promises to their members and don't pay them as much money as they said they would when the members retire - likely a combo of the three.

I have t fully read yet but can I ask if Truss and Kwarteng go or the mini budget is reversed how much does it solve the issue?

Report

MarshaBradyo · 12/10/2022 08:06

Btw thanks for the info

Report

RedAppleGirl · 12/10/2022 08:07

lannistunut · 12/10/2022 07:48

Because the Labour party is in the economic mainstream. What Truss is doing is genuinely mental. She's the Tory equivalent of Corbyn.

Rishi Sunak said Truss would fuck the economy, he was right.

What is happening now is extreme and the only winners will be the already very wealthy, like the top 5%.

Listen up everybody the GLOBAL financial markets are in turmoil right now. No government has a magic bullet to insulate this or any other country from this bear pit.
Money has been cheap, and all assets, liabilities, all financial instruments are being evaluated. Some have been found to be worth less than they thought.

Change of government, maybe. Energy prices aren't suddenly going to drop or food prices aren't going to drop because Labour is in power.
Energy.
Pensions.
Food.
Homes.
Makes one wonder what's next on the hit list to create panic in the population.

Report

BarbaraofSeville · 12/10/2022 08:08

Buggsilla · 12/10/2022 08:01

I think we need a basic economics tv show where the money flow is explained in a digestable way, so we can all understand the ramifications of different actions.

But unless it was combined with some sort of celebrity reality competition set in the jungle or on an island that necessitates the wearing of swimwear, almost no-one will watch it apart from the people who already understand a lot of what is covered anyway.

Report

Buggsilla · 12/10/2022 08:11

I think part of the difficulty is that our world is so heavily intertwined. For those talking about pensions upthread, I wonder if you've thought about how pension funds invest in bubbles around the world? I was shocked to hear recently how the Chinese manufacturing sector (anything to do with fitting-out homes) is on it's knees. Not only because they're now bulldozing apartment blocks but the wiley housing construction sector created investment products to drum up further capital. The Chinese manufacturers bought into these heavily because everyone wanted a slice of the housing boom. Now manufacturing in some areas has fallen off a cliff, those companies are also indebted with unsellable financial products. Without a doubt, this will leak out elsewhere around the world when the truth about where pensions invested comes out.. I think we're in for a spectacular crash next year.

Report

StatisticallyChallenged · 12/10/2022 08:13

BarbaraofSeville · 12/10/2022 08:08

But unless it was combined with some sort of celebrity reality competition set in the jungle or on an island that necessitates the wearing of swimwear, almost no-one will watch it apart from the people who already understand a lot of what is covered anyway.

A version where people are in swimwear, then lose their swimwear and end up naked when they get it wrong wouldn't be the worst analogy to be fair 😂

Report

Buggsilla · 12/10/2022 08:15

'I have t fully read yet but can I ask if Truss and Kwarteng go or the mini budget is reversed how much does it solve the issue?'

The markets might quell a little but we're in for a massively bumpy ride because we have Covid to pay for and many of these issues (Russia's war/ China's economic crisis) are outside our borders.

Report

DorritLittle · 12/10/2022 08:15

1jan2020 · 11/10/2022 22:33

What I would love to know is - will all this affect interest rates and therefore mortgage rates?

Yes it will. We were trying to remortgage before the mini-budget and hoping for a 3.4ish% 5 year deal. The deal went up to 4% on mini-budget day and then immediately up to 6% the next day.

Report

Words · 12/10/2022 08:16

Place marking.

Report

Pinkcadillac · 12/10/2022 08:18

Why is this happening to pension funds only, and not to all other investment funds? Are they the only ones borrowing to buy gilts?

Report

KettleOn919 · 12/10/2022 08:19

How is this going to affect those of us still paying into DC workplace pensions? Should we request to switch our funds so that they don't keep pumping such a large proportion of each contribution into the rapidly failing gilts?

Report

Andypandy799 · 12/10/2022 08:21

lannistunut · 12/10/2022 07:50

And I really don't think any local party of any colour is 'as bad as Putin' @Andypandy799 that comment is both offensive and embarrassing.

You have no idea and I’m not going to explain it all on here.

Why would a councillor have an illegal gun then? To threaten and intimidate? For security?

Report

deeperthanallroses · 12/10/2022 08:22

@Pinkcadillac not any pension funds- defined benefit pension funds. These have committed to a certain level of payment to their members on retirement and need to structure their investments to deliver that amount of cash to distribute in 20 years, 30 years etc. it’s critical they invest in products that guarantee they can meet those commitments. Defined contribution pensions are where you pay £x or x% of your salary and you get on retirement whatever the market return of your cumulate input is- could be low, could be high, so the fund does its best to invest across the markets and that’s what they give you. They don’t need these long term fixed return products.

Report

Bookclub99 · 12/10/2022 08:22

Jewel1968 · 12/10/2022 06:32

Thanks to all of you explaining this so well and simply. Professor Feynman would be pleased.

My question is - do you think it's a problem that so many of us don't really understand how all of this works? Do you think if we all had a better understanding of how capitalism and all the little mechanisms within worked it would influence anything?

I think it's a huge problem. Our children should be taught in schools about capitalism, how financial institutions and markets function, and what caused past crises. This stuff really matters and can hugely affect our lives. Not least because a lack of understanding of the financial ecosystem can allow unscrupulous politicians (ahem, Farage) to whip up anger against the wrong targets.

Report

StatisticallyChallenged · 12/10/2022 08:23

Pinkcadillac · 12/10/2022 08:18

Why is this happening to pension funds only, and not to all other investment funds? Are they the only ones borrowing to buy gilts?

Lots of investment funds aren't allowed to hold leveraged positions or use derivatives, so even if they hold gilts and have therefore lost money they don't have immediate need to cough up wedges of cash to cover margin calls.

A basic investment fund also doesn't have the liabilities that a pension does - they aren't committed to making payments to pensioners, they're mostly just investment vehicles where the investors take the risk.

Report

Bookclub99 · 12/10/2022 08:24

@Pinkcadillac it is happening to other people with leveraged Gilt positions, but pension funds have been by far the biggest buyers of these strategies.

Report

MarshaBradyo · 12/10/2022 08:25

We can learn but still it’s incredibly complex. On watching the movie I mentioned below (and the book) not even the players in the system know the risks they are bringing about.

There are brilliant scenes where they interview people making the money who are clueless re the issues they are helping cause

Then once you stamp one fire out - CDOs etc in that case you get what we have here. People are trained to find money and make more - it’s a leaky bucket and fixing one part another spouts

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

Sign up to continue reading

Mumsnet's better when you're logged in. You can customise your experience and access way more features like messaging, watch and hide threads, voting and much more.

Already signed up?