Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“But I don’t care about birthdays…”

9 replies

Aperolsprizter · 20/08/2022 16:00

Just interested to see what people thought here.
group of five friends, three single, one in LTR, one in a shorter term relationship but partners are friends with the group too (ie will come out for dinner / drinks / holidays etc.

four out of five birthdays cycle around and effort made for all - for example everyone buys each other presents, everyone makes effort to go to drinks or organise them, one friend is good at flower arranging and does bouquets for everyone - standard sort of thing (not excessive, not a lot of money spent but effort made IYSWIM).

last friends birthday is at end of July. For context, which I think is important, this friend is one of the single ones. It’s decided presents won’t be bought as it seems daft (just exchanging the same sorts of gifts back and forth).

BUT also, no effort made to come to drinks - they are arranged but no one can make it aside from one other. Notably less fuss made, friend ended up spending birthday with the one other friend (for disclosure this is me) and had a nice time but obviously felt a bit miffed.

the attitude is not everyone cares as much about birthdays as each other - but I feel if it’s decided to tone it down, you do it at the end of a clear birthday cycle so it’s not just one person left out? (All birthdays apart from hers are in March/ April so it can clearly be done as hers is the last if that makes sense).

anyway it’s caused a rift in the group and I don’t know how to rectify it. Yes we are adults not primary school kids and I feel happy making the effort, but it does feel very unfair AND I feel people in LTR may forget how it feels not to have that one other person making a fuss as a guarantee?

OP posts:
misskatamari · 20/08/2022 16:05

Yeah, I think that’s pretty hurtful. It makes sense to tone it down etc, but with a fuss being made for such recent birthdays, the kindest thing to do would be to celebrate your friends equally, and then tone down when it comes to next year.

Obviously everyone is grown up etc, but I can understand the hurt feelings if you’ve literally celebrated all your friends and bought gifts a couple of months ago, and then they all decide not to bother with you.

Anyone who can’t see that is severely lacking in empathy. This is one of those situations where really, friend A is annoyed and other friends should take a look at their actions and, whether intended or not, realise they have hurt her, hold their hands up and apologise.

ErrolTheDragon · 20/08/2022 16:11

the attitude is not everyone cares as much about birthdays as each other - but I feel if it’s decided to tone it down, you do it at the end of a clear birthday cycle so it’s not just one person left out?

YANBU. Or, if someone doesn't care about birthdays as much as others might, then of course they can say so and not do much when it's^^ their birthday.

perimenofertility · 20/08/2022 16:29

This is sad, I've been that single friend who no one made a fuss of. Luckily you made the effort at least.
You say it's caused a rift - do the others want to heal that rift or do they not recognise the problem?
If everyone wants to heal the rift, an easy thing to do would be to organise an activity or event, then declare it a treat for July-birthday friend "since we were all busy at the time and missed your celebration" - that sort of thing.
If the others are not bothered by the upset caused then perhaps time to let it go and let the "group of five" drift into more casual friendships.

diddl · 20/08/2022 16:39

the attitude is not everyone cares as much about birthdays as each other

But seemingly they all did until this last person's bday?

So no flowers, no presents & only you made it to drinks?

Has anyone had a change in circs so that they can't afford & everyone has decided to go with that?

Has she been treated badly on other occasions?

Rowen32 · 20/08/2022 16:40

Yeah, that's horrible.. Who decided presents wouldn't be bought? The obvious thing to do if someone had an issue was bring it up at the start of a new year, it's very hurtful..

Aperolsprizter · 20/08/2022 16:41

Thanks all for your kind replies.

it’s a hard dynamic to explain - it’s almost as if suddenly the previous efforts have been forgotten and put down to a “well, you WANTED to do XX” . It almost feels a bit like they are guilting her for wanting the effort - “I thought you didn’t give to get back” sort of thing.

the thing is, she is generally the one to make cakes, to book tables at popular bars, to ensure she’s there If it’s inconvenient and now i don’t know how to make them see that she’s not acting like a princess for wanting it? But also it’s nuanced because asking for it does seem like that?

OP posts:
Aperolsprizter · 20/08/2022 16:43

Also re presents etc - I am also a single party and got a present, booked drinks and we also went for lunch (we work close together) so she was sorted in that sense from me. It’s more that the others just sort of decided individually it wasn’t happening this year witn them. What I’m struggling to make them see is that clearly SHE cares about birthdays, we’ve all made that effort for each other before and therefore it’s more compounded that it’s her who is missing out

OP posts:
Rowen32 · 20/08/2022 17:42

I guess you can't make them see what they don't want to see or don't care to see.. Let your friend pull back if she wants and see if they make an effort to be friends with her still, maybe this was a way to exclude her/ghost her..

diddl · 20/08/2022 17:58

So she usually has made effort & expected effort back?

And they didn't want the effort making (but didn't decline)?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread