Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make her go?

10 replies

wherearetheturrets · 01/08/2022 08:18

Apologies for length, have tried to be concise!

Dd is 10. Her dad lives about 3 and a half hour drive away and has done since she was born (I lived in his town and then moved back home near my family just before I found out I was pregnant). We have managed this as best we can - they Skype 3 times a week and she spends half of every school holiday with him, except for the half terms when she’s there for the whole week as it’s far to go for just half a week.

Dd has pretty much always complained about going. It’s not because she has a bad time but she’s always struggled with leaving me. We’ve tried to implement things to help with this (taking something of mine with her, taking photos, got her a phone a few years ago so she could message and call me whenever she wanted to). She has found it easier since having a phone and being able to contact me and will FaceTime me most mornings, but still a few days before she’s due to go she’ll start saying she doesn’t want to go and why am I making her etc.

It’s really hard as I feel guilty for ‘forcing’ her, but her dad is a decent dad and he loves her and he makes consistent effort to have a good and close relationship with her despite the distance. He deserves a relationship with her as much as any decent dad does. He’d love to be able to do ‘normal’ contact but it’s just too far. Plus he doesn’t drive (his mum does all the driving for their contact). It’s not really possible for him to come here as he absolutely cannot afford to pay to stay somewhere, and staying at ours isn’t really an option as my dp and dds dad are civil but not at all comfortable with each other and we have a small flat.

Up til now I’ve always told her it’s important that she has a relationship with her dad, and that he loves her and wants to spend time with her and that’s a good thing, and that she’s too young to fully understand the consequences of not going to visit. But it’s horrible to effectively disregard her feelings. Aibu doing this?? How do I deal with it? At what age do I prioritise her feelings and allow her to not go?

To avoid drip feeding, I’ve also not long had a baby (dd2 is nearly 6 months) so dd1 is also now having to leave her sister to go and visit her dad, which is obviously adding to her reluctance. Since dd2 was born she’s only visited her dad for a week over Easter (they didn’t do feb half term as baby was due, and didn’t do may half term as we had something planned and her dad didn’t want to do less than the full week) and now will be going to his for a solid 3 weeks.

Thanks in advance for any advice or suggestions.

OP posts:
HairyKitty · 01/08/2022 08:21

I wonder if the reluctance isn’t to do with leaving the new baby, but leaving you with the new baby. She’s certainly far too young to be making decisions about contact with her dad, you are right that it’s your job (and his) to make this work so that she can keep both parents on her life.

KangarooKenny · 01/08/2022 08:21

Is there a reason why he doesn’t drive ?
An no, you shouldn’t make her go. I was the child who didn’t want to go and stay at my DF and his new pregnant partner’s house. I hated sleeping there, I wanted to sleep at home.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 01/08/2022 08:28

I think you’re right to make her go and spend time with her Dad. Looking back, I’m glad that I was made to go and see my Dad even when I’d complain that I didn’t want to.

Three weeks is a long time though, and I don’t think that’s fair to her. It’s quite a big deal to be away from home for three weeks, and it’s not your dds fault that her parents live so far apart and that her Dad can’t drive. It seems like this arrangement is for the convenience of the adults involved, rather than being in your dds best interests. She may be more inclined to go if it were just for a week at a time and that way she’d get more than one opportunity to see her dad over the six weeks holiday.

wherearetheturrets · 01/08/2022 08:34

@KangarooKenny he doesn't have a driving licence and can't afford to get one, or run a car

OP posts:
wherearetheturrets · 01/08/2022 08:41

@ClocksGoingBackwards you're absolutely right, but it's a pretty big inconvenience for the adults involved. Dds nana is the one who has to drive pretty much 8 hours there and back, twice for one visit. If it was broken up she'd have to do it 4 times, and it's not my place to ask that of her. We have done that a couple of times when I've driven for one of the trips (stayed with friends for a week and driven dd both ways), but now I have dd2 its much more difficult. Dd2 isn't good in the car for shorter drives, and it's a long drive :(

OP posts:
wherearetheturrets · 01/08/2022 08:44

Probably a part of it @HairyKitty but she does specifically say she doesn't want to leave her sister and she does really love her and love spending time with her so it's probably a bit of both

OP posts:
Motherhubbardscupboard · 01/08/2022 08:56

One of my DC is at university 3 hours away and we regularly do day trips, I don't think it's such a distance that it needs a full week's stay and certainly not a 3 week stay. Is there no public transport option, or can't you meet halfway sometimes?

Italianmamami · 01/08/2022 09:05

We used to do this as a child and then looking back as adults we realised why my mum pushed us to go every weekend. We resented her at the time as we just wanted the home comforts but it got easier when we made friends in our area. Maybe ask what activities they do and if she has any friends. Ask dad about putting her in some group clubs as that friendship group may help her settle and have something to look forward to. There are many activities on during the summer holidays in each area. I think dd has gotten out of routine, this is her first trip back to dads and she has seen that if something comes up dad goes on the back burner and can be rearranged. You may need to be more consistent with the arrangements and show her that going to dads is part of the routine and shouldn’t be changed. She will learn as she gets older (3 siblings) as we did that actually she isn’t just spending time with her dad but also his family and that it’s important, having a good father role model is important for girls. I will be honest I know many who didn’t and have some issues(not the case for all).

Shinyandnew1 · 01/08/2022 09:11

I would strongly encourage her to go. Three weeks is a very long time though-if she’s not been much this year, I’d suggest going with a week and I’d offer to meet the dad/nan somewhere 1 and 3/4 hours away. A services/park/NT place that your DD can both have a play in together or some lunch-make a day trip out of it before you head home. The nan driving an 8 hour round trip is really hard.

whiteroseredrose · 01/08/2022 09:29

I would also make her go, but maybe just for 2 weeks.

This was me back in the 1970s, before the M62. My poor dad had a 3 hour drive each way.

For the same reason, I couldn't have 50:50 time because of the logistics so I went for half of every holiday. Switch over time was always difficult as you get used to different family values, but I did get to know my dad and his side of the family properly. They are her family too.

In some ways I am quite different to my DM's family. I am more like my DF's. It is good to know where you come from.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page