Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have pushed the dog with my foot

101 replies

AGreaterGrate · 13/06/2022 20:39

I did not kick it, or hurt it, but pushed the barking, growling, yapping thing away with the side of my foot as it kept biting towards my ankles.

I'm SO fed up of dog owners not controlling their dogs!

I'm a runner and will go out of my way to give dogs lots of space, I stop and walk if one is wearing an 'I'm nervous' vest, I never run up behind a dog and their owner, I love dogs and have fostered many so I recognise when a dog may be triggered by a runner and I give space/start walking/Cross over the road etc.

But it's always little yapping ones on extendable leads, IF they're on lead at all, and owners not giving a crap, as they run towards me, with zero recall, nipping at my ankles. Yes, I will push your dog away if it's not under your control.

OP posts:
Manekinek0 · 14/06/2022 12:26

I am a small dog owner, I love my dog, but if he ever tried to attack someone in public I would expect them to kick him.

waveyourpompoms · 14/06/2022 12:27

YANBU and were very kind only pushing. I would certainly have been more forceful if a dog was harassing me.

MushyPeasPrincess · 14/06/2022 13:24

NoRegretsNoTearsGoodbye · 14/06/2022 11:41

I’m starting to develop a real phobia of dogs because of the rise in dog ownership - so many out of control dogs around now. And all those owners of big dogs having a go at small dogs are crazy - small dogs yapping at your heels are really fucking annoying but NOTHING in comparison to the sheer terror of having a large or medium sized dog barrelling towards you that you know could seriously maim you or your child. It’s terrifying.

And yes don’t get me started on “they’re just being friendly!” 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

HmmHmmHmm

I'm not crazy. Thanks. I'm a responsible owner of a large dog who keeps him on his lead. As does everyone I know with a large breed. We live rurally so active breeds are common but are usually well trained and in leads due to closeness of livestock most of the year round.

Unlike most of the small dogs we see.
They cause the problem with my dog.

rnsaslkih · 14/06/2022 13:48

Whilst the problem is the owner not having control, I don’t really think it’s a good idea to do this. A nudge could look like a kick.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 14/06/2022 13:55

rnsaslkih · 14/06/2022 13:48

Whilst the problem is the owner not having control, I don’t really think it’s a good idea to do this. A nudge could look like a kick.

It's the owners fault if their dog gets kicked. If it's under control it's got no chance of getting kicked.

SirChenjins · 14/06/2022 13:59

ChenPup is always on a tight lead - he only gets off lead if there are no other dogs or people about and even then it's for very short periods as we're working on his recall.

However - we use shared trails and we have had cyclists and joggers (runners - they're not jogging) barrel up behind us, and as someone who's partially deaf it can very disconcerting, esp when they run or cycle very close to us on a trail when they can't be heard. I will always apologise profusely if he barks or jumps (on his tight lead) in fright, but I do wish people cycling or running would be aware that they're sharing a narrow path with walkers and small children who might not be able to move immediately and slow down a bit when they can't get a clear sight ahead - or they can, but there are people walking.

Pruella · 14/06/2022 14:11

I do wish people cycling or running would be aware that they're sharing a narrow path with walkers and small children who might not be able to move immediately and slow down a bit when they can't get a clear sight ahead

This I absolutely agree with - I can’t stand it when cyclists or runners ding or shout and expect you to leap out the way. If I’m cycling where there are also pedestrians I slow right down.

Stroopwaffels · 14/06/2022 14:26

Come on then @VeniVidiWeeWee , enlighten us. What should OP have done? Stopped running? Smiled sweetly while the dog jumped up at her and the ineffectual owner tried and failed to control it?

We have ALL come across this type of dog and this type of "he's only playing" shit owner. CONTROL YOUR DOG. It is your JOB as an owner to stop your dog interfering with anyone else.

NoRegretsNoTearsGoodbye · 14/06/2022 15:16

@MushyPeasPrincess i didn’t say you were crazy I said having a go at small dogs is crazy. I hate all out of control dogs but large out of control dogs are terrifying - and sadly my experience around here is that there are far too many that are not kept under control.

i wish dog training was mandatory - so many of them nowadays are a tragedy waiting to happen 😢.

Greensleeves · 14/06/2022 15:20

YarnHoarder · 13/06/2022 22:16

While I think YANBU I can see how some dog owners would take any contact with the dog as a sign to take the same approach as the dog.

I owner a medium/large sight hound who thankfully has a very low prey drive considering and is more likely to run alongside a cyclist/jogger looking concerned and trying to get back to me. My last dog however (she was a larger sight hound) saw everyone and everything moving at speed as fair game and would've made an amazing police chase dog, would've caught and detained every single criminal she was set upon. It sounds like you're a more considerate jogger/cyclist than many round here as they approached from behind silently and when I asked them to stop/slow they'd just continue while I frantically tried to put her on the lead and get her to one side so they could pass without her chasing them.

It's a hard balance to strike when there's people competing for the same space but you're not wrong to defend yourself.

Holy fuck the entitlement is strong with this one!

Runners (and some cyclists) are usually timing their runs and striving to improve on them. No, they bloody well don't want to slow down or stop while you get your unruly dog under control in a public place. If it can't cope with normal human activity without being a nuisance, it has no business being off lead in the first place.

SirChenjins · 14/06/2022 15:24

Greensleeves · 14/06/2022 15:20

Holy fuck the entitlement is strong with this one!

Runners (and some cyclists) are usually timing their runs and striving to improve on them. No, they bloody well don't want to slow down or stop while you get your unruly dog under control in a public place. If it can't cope with normal human activity without being a nuisance, it has no business being off lead in the first place.

Any runner or cyclists who is striving to improve their time by barrelling along a shared path can do one. Find a dedicated cycle or running track, or toad, and strive to improve your time when you’re not going to cause an injury to anyone who can’t get out of your way in time. Entitled? Oh, the irony.

SirChenjins · 14/06/2022 15:25

Roads, obvs - the toads have done nothing wrong

Greensleeves · 14/06/2022 15:27

SirChenjins · 14/06/2022 15:24

Any runner or cyclists who is striving to improve their time by barrelling along a shared path can do one. Find a dedicated cycle or running track, or toad, and strive to improve your time when you’re not going to cause an injury to anyone who can’t get out of your way in time. Entitled? Oh, the irony.

We're not talking about "barrelling into" anybody though, are we? Running around other people so as not to have to stop is perfectly reasonable. This poster is complaining that runners won't actually stop and wait while she gets her poorly-disciplined dog onto a lead so it can't chase them. Why the hell should they?

SirChenjins · 14/06/2022 15:38

If a cyclist (or runner) is striving to improve their performance then unless their performance time is really low then they're going to be going at a fair old lick - and certainly won't be able to stop in time if a child runs out in front of them or an on-lead dog on a shared path jumps on them.

Owners of off lead dogs with no recall and cyclists/runners who expect everyone to move out of the way immediately for them are all going to the same special place in hell.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 14/06/2022 15:39

rnsaslkih · 14/06/2022 13:48

Whilst the problem is the owner not having control, I don’t really think it’s a good idea to do this. A nudge could look like a kick.

Meh, it's the owners fault if their dog gets kicked IMO, and I say that as a dog owner and professional dog walker.

If you can't control your dog in public, then you need to expect other people to use whatever force necessary to keep your dog away from them. People have the right to run/walk/cycle around without being pestered by your dog, and they don't know if your dog is just going to sniff their ankles, or if they're going to jump, scratch or bite them.

My dog would chase a runner or cyclist so I keep him on the lead unless he's somewhere like the beach where I can see far enough ahead of me to call him back if necessary.

SirChenjins · 14/06/2022 15:40

The OP does not seem like the latter and so she will be saved from the fiery pits - but there are plenty that are.

Greensleeves · 14/06/2022 15:42

SirChenjins · 14/06/2022 15:38

If a cyclist (or runner) is striving to improve their performance then unless their performance time is really low then they're going to be going at a fair old lick - and certainly won't be able to stop in time if a child runs out in front of them or an on-lead dog on a shared path jumps on them.

Owners of off lead dogs with no recall and cyclists/runners who expect everyone to move out of the way immediately for them are all going to the same special place in hell.

Most people who are running in public parks in the daytime do have very low performance - it doesn't mean they aren't striving to improve, nor does it mean they should have to stop and wait while some idiot with an untrained dog gets it under control. Using parks for exercise is one of their primary functions - of course nobody should have to move out of the way for a runner, the runner should run around other people and not inconvenience them. I am a shit runner, really slow, but I am slowly getting better - there are several parks near me that are shared perfectly amicably by walkers, runners, dog owners, families etc. I haven't seen anybody rudely barging into anybody else, and would take a dim view of anyone who did. Runners should be considerate of other people and if they need to overtake, they should be the ones to move off the path, not the people walking on it. But they shouldn't have to stop altogether because some fool has got an off-lead dog that will chase them if they don't wait for her to fumble about getting it on the lead.

MarshaBradyo · 14/06/2022 15:50

re pp and wanting runners to stop or tell people they are approaching doesn’t mean they want to barrel into anyone instead

Just that they don’t want to stop or have to say anything, just to run at own pace which is normal

Expecting people to alter their running etc so pp can get dog on lead isn’t going to work. The dog owner should work out other solution

SirChenjins · 14/06/2022 15:52

No, of course they shouldn’t have to wait for an owner to get their dog under control - but if they’re on a shared path (which is what my post was about then they need to be mindful of their speed and the space they give other path users, which they don’t always do. Both types of shared space users are a total menace.

YarnHoarder · 14/06/2022 15:52

SirChenjins · 14/06/2022 15:38

If a cyclist (or runner) is striving to improve their performance then unless their performance time is really low then they're going to be going at a fair old lick - and certainly won't be able to stop in time if a child runs out in front of them or an on-lead dog on a shared path jumps on them.

Owners of off lead dogs with no recall and cyclists/runners who expect everyone to move out of the way immediately for them are all going to the same special place in hell.

I've also explained that if I see or hear anyone coming I will put the dog on a lead and move out of the way. It's when they're already passing me without any warning and I'm not able to grab the dog in time that I ask them to slow/stop to keep everyone safe. Will 5 seconds of my grabbing my dog while you jog on the spot really impact you that much that? As I said, it was thankfully rare this occured. I want to get out of your way and keep my dog, myself and you safe, please give me a few seconds to do that.

This dog has now died, it's no longer an issue with my current dog due to her temperament and life experiences. I would have had the same issue if the dog was on a long lead and allowed to roam (again, I'm walking them off the beaten track away from as many people as possible) and someone cycled/ran by at speed, she could easily have tripped someone is this scenario. It's the opportunity to get my dog in the safest position for everyone involved when I've been unable to plan ahead as I was unaware you were there.

The OP doesn't seem to have the same issues of being considerate to other trail users here and I fully support them in defending themselves when her cautious and understanding approach has failed.

FrecklesMalone · 14/06/2022 15:55

Lacedwithgrace · 13/06/2022 21:19

YANBU. I've used my crutch before to stop a little dog getting near. I held back from thumping them with it but I put it on the ground to block it's path, no different to using a foot.

I read that as crotch 😁

SirChenjins · 14/06/2022 15:59

FrecklesMalone · 14/06/2022 15:55

I read that as crotch 😁

That’s one way of stopping them, I guess 😂

Greensleeves · 14/06/2022 16:02

YarnHoarder · 14/06/2022 15:52

I've also explained that if I see or hear anyone coming I will put the dog on a lead and move out of the way. It's when they're already passing me without any warning and I'm not able to grab the dog in time that I ask them to slow/stop to keep everyone safe. Will 5 seconds of my grabbing my dog while you jog on the spot really impact you that much that? As I said, it was thankfully rare this occured. I want to get out of your way and keep my dog, myself and you safe, please give me a few seconds to do that.

This dog has now died, it's no longer an issue with my current dog due to her temperament and life experiences. I would have had the same issue if the dog was on a long lead and allowed to roam (again, I'm walking them off the beaten track away from as many people as possible) and someone cycled/ran by at speed, she could easily have tripped someone is this scenario. It's the opportunity to get my dog in the safest position for everyone involved when I've been unable to plan ahead as I was unaware you were there.

The OP doesn't seem to have the same issues of being considerate to other trail users here and I fully support them in defending themselves when her cautious and understanding approach has failed.

No, that absolutely isn't good enough. If your (former) dog wasn't properly under your control while off-lead - which she wasn't, was she - then she shouldn't have been off-lead in a public space. Nobody should have to stop and wait while you get your dog under control. Nobody should have to put up with being chased by an unruly dog because they didn't either announce themselves to a complete stranger or stop and wait while you put it on a lead. You, I'm afraid, are a nuisance dog owner.

adlitem · 14/06/2022 16:05

@YarnHoarder If your dog wasn't safe in proximity of others (why she wasn't if you had to restrain her if people pass her) she shouldn't have been off the lead at all in areas that others are using.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 14/06/2022 16:49

@Yarnholder you shouldn't have you dog off lead if it is going to chase. Full stop.

And this comes from someone who always walks their dog off lead. He stops and drops on command