Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Friend” Sabotaged my crush - and I didn’t realise until years later

43 replies

ShuffleShuffleSpin · 14/05/2022 17:08

Over 10 years ago while I was a student, a boy and I liked each other. We were drawn to each other and things were still in a delicate stage, but the mutual attraction was very strong.

I had a jealous roommate who thought that boy was cute. (She told me so). She was jealous of many people, and she often tried to start arguments.

One evening, my roommate came up to my room around 8/9pm while I was in my pjs. She said something very vague and confusing about how someone downstairs in our dorm was saying our group of friends should get to know theirs. I asked who and she said “I will tell you later”. She gave me a talk about how she thought we should just concentrate on spending time with our own friends. It was all so vague I had no way to know what she really meant, but I had a strange, sinking feeling. When she came back up she said “there, I think he understands”. I wondered who she meant - I asked - I wondered if it was the boy. She would not tell me.

The next morning I learned (from a real / honest friend) that boy had his friends had invited all of us out. She asked “why didn’t you go?” And i explained I didn’t even know about it.

After that, the boy stopped seeking me out. Rushed by me in the hallway. I wasn’t sure why. What had happened? I was young, naive and trusting. We had such chemistry. I always thought we would reconnect, but we never did.

I hadn’t thought of this in years, but it came back to me recently. All I had remembered was how much I had liked that boy, and I always wondered why we faded away from each other - I forgot about the friend - now, looking back in maturity, I know my roommate must have sabotaged the relationship. I have no doubt. Back then I didn’t really believe people could be so unkind, but now I know better. She misrepresented me completely and it was so unfair. I would have loved to go, to get to know that boy better. It’s so wrong of her.

I now have clarity. I don’t feel closure though. I hate that I was misrepresented and the guy was obviously hurt by what was said judging from what I remember about how he responded when he next saw me. This sad story bothers me. Would I be unreasonable to contact some of my old friends to try to gain closure? I feel most people wouldn’t be so bothered.

OP posts:
sonjadog · 14/05/2022 18:23

I think you just chalk it up to being young and immature and move on. It wasn't really your friend's fault either. You thought something was up on the evening but did nothing, you knew there was a misunderstanding the day after but didn't try to talk to him, you thought this guy might be "the one" at the time but didn't even try to send him an email. These are all more significant reasons for why it didn't work out that that your friend didn't tell you he wanted to hang out that one evening. It probably wouldn't have worked out anyway as you were so passive. This is entirely normal for relationships when young and immature, so don't beat yourself up about it. Just learn the lesson and don't let the same happen now.

CPL593H · 14/05/2022 18:26

Honestly, things are never "in a delicate stage" if a bloke is keen on you, it really, really isn't. Also, if keen, your flatmate could have told him that you dressed as a Teletubby every Sunday and it would have made not a scrap of difference.

Please don't contact your old college friends to discuss this. They will think you are bonkers. Forget it/him/her.

Chikapu · 14/05/2022 18:27

Would I be unreasonable to contact some of my old friends to try to gain closure?

I think you would yes, it's highly likely they won't even remember it. Have you had any relationships since this non-starter?

Crimeismymiddlename · 14/05/2022 18:31

Op, let it go. He was not even your boyfriend. It’s not like a great romance, he did not even ask you out on a date.

FiveNineFive · 14/05/2022 18:31

Has nothing of interest or importance happened to you in the last ten years?

AllyCatTown · 14/05/2022 18:34

What's going on in your life now that this has resurfaced?

This!

If you were really into him I don’t get why you didn’t just say something to him about you not being told about being asked out. Then he might have mentioned lies or what not which was said to him.

Plus you never were in a relationship with him so you’ve no idea if you were even compatible.

Just let it go. I sometimes waste headspace on things like that from the past but it’s usually a reflection on my current mental state. You won’t get closure on lots of things in life and just need to deal with it.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 14/05/2022 18:41

I hope your communication skills have evolved since then, OP. It all just screams out that at that time you let life just happen to you and you were a passive observer, ignoring any conversations you didn't understand instead of asking for clarification. Almost like a toddler observing. Life is short, you have to grab it with both hands, make sure you understand situations instead of playing silly guessing games. You can't float around hoping nice things will happen to you.

There are ways to gain closure but it isn't contacting your old friend to ask why she "sabotaged" a potential relationship. YOu'd come across as mad. Instead I'd probably try and contact this uni crush on social media, casually say you're feeling nostalgic about uni days so thought you'd see what various people were up to. If you ended up having an online conversation and find out he's single I would jokily say "I had the biggest crush on you at uni ha ha", and just see what happens.

Aprilx · 14/05/2022 18:44

You don’t even know if she did anything or any conversation happened! This was a non event at the time, if he was interested in you then he wouldn’t have been so easily dissuaded. It was a non event then and even more of a non event now.

HostessTrolley · 14/05/2022 18:47

Look him up on social media, you might have mutual friends. Drop him a line, ask him how he’s doing and say you were randomly thinking of him the other day….

presuming that either you’re single or your current partner wouldn’t be hurt by you contacting someone you had feelings for

GatoradeMeBitch · 14/05/2022 18:54

It isn't mad to go over things from your past. We'd have to be robots to only ever think about the present.

I wouldn't poll all your old friends. Try and find this man on FB and send him a friend request. Say something came up recently to make you feel curious about what happened back then and did he remember what your friend said to him.

But sometimes the closure is already there. If this boy liked you enough (unless he was painfully shy) he probably would have wanted to speak to you before cutting you off. Instead he took someone else's word. It doesn't suggest much strength of character.

BeverForget · 14/05/2022 18:58

If it is more than three years ago, forget it.
It never happened and never will.
Be happy with where you are now.

lindy72 · 14/05/2022 19:12

I really feel for you, sounds very similar to a situation I found myself in many years ago but the guy in question pushed through the barriers put up by my so called friend and I STILL wimped out...just saying maturity in the moment is the hardest thing to achieve when you are young and hindsight is super rose-tinted.

In my twenties it burned through me I wish I could live my life knowing what I will know when I'm 30....Well when I was 30 I met my husband and the collective knowledge of what I went through up until then made me the person that navigated the relationship as an adult.....

BBQBoke · 14/05/2022 19:34

I had a similar thing happen, my best friend (at the time) used my phone to text him that I didn't want to see or contact him anymore, and that was that. Very confusing at the time as I had no idea she text him as she deleted it from my phone. It was several months later when I found out and realised what she did. I think it was the betrayal of my friend that stung more than the guy though. There's nothing wrong with wondering 'what if' as long as you don't allow it to consume you.

MichelleScarn · 14/05/2022 19:41

So had you and him ever spoken on your own? Did you have his details or social media?

CaitoftheCantii · 14/05/2022 19:55

I had a similar upbringing, OP, you waited (and waited) for the bloke to do the approaching and the asking… and trusted your friends to be loyal to you…

in the gentlest way possible, don’t try to go back - they have likely moved on so far in their lives, they won’t be able to give you any closure. It is an awful feeling when you realise that you have spent so much time thinking about what might have been, but they have not thought about you once in 10 years…

youwouldthink · 14/05/2022 19:55

In the words of The Beatles - Let it Be!

RedHelenB · 14/05/2022 21:46

Yabu. If there was really chemistry then it would have worked out, he'd have actually spoken to you rather than " friends"

ShuffleShuffleSpin · 15/05/2022 16:27

Thank you everyone for your replies. And for not judging me for what feels like such a silly thing to be stuck on at the moment. You’ve asked what I’ve been up to since then. I’ve gotten an education, gotten married, and have children. I have a lot to be grateful for. I did have an extremely rigid upbringing with extreme and unreasonable rules around romantic relationships. It took me until my mid 20s to really start dating and forge my own path. I’m wondering if reliving this memory now has something to do with that. I haven’t really thought about it for years but for whatever reason it has hit me hard. Thanks again. The advice to leave the past in the past is good.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread