Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to use a Frida Baby Windi Gasspasser?

40 replies

Lasoupe · 17/04/2022 10:38

I've seen so many mixed reports online about safety but my baby has such bad wind right now and can't nap. We're on our second day with this. She has allergies and may have a problem with her kidney so reluctant to use gripe water or Infacol. Has anyone used the Windi gasspasser? Are they okay?

OP posts:
LaSoupe · 17/04/2022 11:48

[quote MolliciousIntent]@steff13 generally as a rule, Americans get told they need an awful lot of random stuff like this. Some of it is just plastic nonsense - wipe warmers, nappy cream spatulas etc - and some of it is a lot more invasive, like this thing. There are also loads of procedures that happen as standard to new babies in the US that don't get done elsewhere as they're outdated practices, like bathing newborns instantly. I think it's because of the for-profit system - people want to feel like they're getting bang for their buck.[/quote]
Frida Baby is Swedish, not American.

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 17/04/2022 11:56

[quote LaSoupe]@SoupDragon Obviously not, or I wouldn't be considering it. I'm not an idiot - I've tried all the conventional methods but this wind is so stubborn and causing so much pain that I would have considered using it if lots of people on here had said they'd tried it successfully.[/quote]
Er... OK.

MolliciousIntent · 17/04/2022 11:57

@Lasoupe I'm aware, I was responding to a conversation about how these types of products appeal to Americans.

LaSoupe · 17/04/2022 12:02

@Shehasadiamondinthesky

Well it's got great reviews, I wouldn't rule it out but I'd ask my health visitor first. I've never heard of it, had to look it up. We used to use flatus tubes for adults back in the 80's when I was a nurse - they've all been replaced by medication now because adults aren't keen on them, embarrassing I guess.
I'd never heard of this. Did a quick Google search and can see you can still buy them for children. I'm guessing the Windi thing is similar, but I'll wait to speak to a professional.

www.pediatriconcall.com/medical-equipment/tubes-catheters/1/flatus-tube/9#:~:text=It%20is%20reusable%20rubber%20tube,wash%20with%20soap%20and%20water.

OP posts:
Lolalovesmarmite · 17/04/2022 12:05

I wouldn’t use this. It seems incredibly invasive. There’s a difference between using a rectal thermometer when a child is ill and routinely and unnecessarily putting a foreign object into their rectum to try and speed up a natural process. And before anybody says anything, yes I have had two children who both had terrible wind and colic. I have spent huge amounts of time bicycling legs, doing tiger in the tree and googling colic/wind cures. Even at my sleep deprived, screamed out most desperate, I would not have entertained using one of these.

LaSoupe · 17/04/2022 12:08

@MolliciousIntent I'm just surprised by how many people are instantly against it. If it's safe and effective (and that's what I'd want to ascertain), why would it be an unnecessary gadget? Normal wind releasing methods are only partly effective in my experience. If this was better, well documented, and safe, I'd absolutely use it instead of persisting with bicycling legs for ages with no return.

But since it's not apparently widely used (yet?), I'll hold off.

OP posts:
MolliciousIntent · 17/04/2022 12:15

[quote LaSoupe]@MolliciousIntent I'm just surprised by how many people are instantly against it. If it's safe and effective (and that's what I'd want to ascertain), why would it be an unnecessary gadget? Normal wind releasing methods are only partly effective in my experience. If this was better, well documented, and safe, I'd absolutely use it instead of persisting with bicycling legs for ages with no return.

But since it's not apparently widely used (yet?), I'll hold off.[/quote]
When you have trapped wind, do you stick a tube up your arsehole?

If you wouldn't do it to yourself, don't do it to your baby. If your child is in pain, seek medical advice.

LaSoupe · 17/04/2022 12:22

@MolliciousIntent I guess that's maybe the difference - I totally would if it was on the market! I have IBD so know what agonising wind feels like. According to a previous poster, this was used by nurses for adults until medications became more common. Personally, I'd prefer the non-medicated way, but clearly I'm in the minority here!

OP posts:
LaSoupe · 17/04/2022 15:26

Update for any future googlers:

I eventually used the gasspasser thing after my baby continued to seem to have trapped gas. She was struggling to sleep and was hugely overtired as had been like this for two days. I researched it first and found some evaluations. One of them, on Science Based Medicine, said that it probably wouldn't help but wouldn't do any harm if only used occasionally (only occasionally because babies need to build muscles and get used to passing wind themselves). I also found repeatedly good reviews, both reviews of purchases and a thread on Reddit. The only bad reviews I found said that it did nothing, so I thought I'd give it a go, especially as I researched the flatus tube things for adults and found it's a pretty tested way of relieving wind.

My husband and I got the nappy ready and used Vaseline to lubricate it a bit, like a rectal thermometer. We were really worried about hurting her, but it went in easily and she was not at all bothered by it. We slowly turned it round a bit and then all this wind just came out, so much wind (also some poo, like the packet said might happen). She instantly seemed relieved and is now sleeping in my husband's arms. So, all I can say is that it seemed to work, my baby did not seem at all bothered by it, and she is now sleeping after being unable to sleep for two days.

For any future googlers, apparently you are not supposed to use it that often, though, so that the baby's body learns to manage wind on its own. For us, we tried it because our baby was so bothered by wind these last two days, far more than normal. We don't be using it again unless we are desperate.

It seems to have been an unpopular idea, but all I can say now that I've done it is that I am glad I tried it. Obviously, each to their own, but wanted to post for anybody else trying to find real experiences of it like I was.

OP posts:
Bunnybingesoneggs · 17/04/2022 15:59

What next dinky spoons for baby constipation?
Confused

DD0 · 15/10/2022 04:28

For anyone that stumbles across this thread for research purposes...

If you have got to the point of getting this far, just do it.

I would recommend a different brand (Babybliss Lufti) but nonetheless this little contraption has changed our life.

We have previously ended up in hospital with facial swelling due to baby screaming in such severe pain. Like a lot of other posters on this thread thought it was a horrific thing to do to your baby and totally wrong. I reached breaking point and thought surely its worth a go.

We call them the little farty tubes of joy.

I'm posting at 4:23am as although we don't use them often, tonight is a night they are needed and I have run out. I have spent hours and hours doing bicycle legs and all sorts of crazy positions and although I have got some farts out, she is still just so uncomfortable. Usually only need to get some air out before rempving the tube and getting her nappy done up quick as there is usually a very messy explosion coming shortly afterwards!

Ordered on Amazon for same day delivery so just got to keep my eyes open and hope it either passes soon, or wait for my Amazon driver to come and save the day!!

Wifflywafflywoo · 15/10/2022 06:07

@DD0

I feel your pain. We do a position with our DD that we call poo seat. Basically we sit at the edge of the sofa, sit her on the edge between our legs facing away from us using our tummy to support her. Then we pull her legs up like a frog so shes in a sitting position with knees above hips. It works everytime and is comfy. Happy to dm you a pic as my description is rubbish!

Hope your LO feels better soon

SunflowerDuck · 15/10/2022 06:35

What tf have I just read?!?!

Jodie123123 · 27/10/2022 13:18

The Windi is a absolute game changer. Give it a go and I promise you your baby will be so relieved and happy. My 5 week old hadn’t pooped for days - we used this, it takes 2 seconds, as soon as we used it trapped gas was released and instantly lots of poop came out! She’s now so smiley and her stomach is no longer hard and she’s gone for a lovely sleep. I promise you it is not dangerous if done correctly! Read all the reviews about it especially on Boots.com and rethink - your baby doesn’t deserve to go through unnecessary pain when this sorts it right out!

TempleHill · 05/01/2025 19:59

Our maternity nurse swear by it. It works like magic. I don't know why people are so against it. DCs do not seem to mind.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread