Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want my sister to leave him???

10 replies

Leona93 · 23/03/2022 10:42

My sister is 31, almost 3 years ago she started dating a guy (35ish??), let's just call him Z. There were some red signs from the get-go. He has 3 kids from an ex, their relationship is very bad. From name calling, to her pushing him and scratching him, yelling right in front of the kids etc. The point is, the ex is fairly unstable.
He is a coke-addict, sober for the past few months, trying to get his life on the right track. He works on and off, skipping when he doesn't feel like going in, then panicking about not having heating in the house and my sister is left to try to figure out the solution. He does name call her when he is angry and gets furious with her over his own stupid decisions. His oldest son was diagnosed with cancer a few weeks ago, which is of course a huge stress source, but since it's been found that the type he has is 90% fully treatable, and he is responding really well to treatment. The biggest problem in the situation is that he is extremely selfish and verbally assaulting. He is into racing (he races himself), and despite not having money to spare he spent his last bit of money on entry fees. The day after he had to bring his son to his weekly chemo and wanted my sister to get out at a petrol station and give him cash for parking fees. She said she'd have to go to the ATM because the petrol station would only give 50 notes and she doesn't have that much on her card. He threw a huge hissy fit over how she doesn't care and that he has no time to go to the ATM before the appointment. Dropped her off at work, then left. He started then texting her, calling her a cunt, a bitch and all sort, then she told him he was being selfish wasting the money when he knew they needed it next day... He started panicking when he arrived and begged her to pay for the parking through her phone - which she ended up doing because the oldest kid would be very sick after his treatment and didn't want him to suffer his father's decisions consequences of having the car clamped and having to take a bus home... As soon as she did so, he started telling her how she is the best and he loves her etc. The next day she came over and told me he was so very sorry about his behavior, but the thing is this happens way too often. She expressed a few times that she wants to leave but she is scared that Z goes back to taking drugs and the kids suffering the consequences... AIBU to tell her she needs to get out asap? It is a verbally abusive relationships and I can see it turning into more... I will show her the replies to this thread, hopefully it will help her come to a decision.

OP posts:
LabelMaker · 23/03/2022 10:57

Hi if you're reading this OP' sister. This is not a life to be trapped into, try contacting woman's aid If you need help to leave.

ISayItLikeItIs · 23/03/2022 11:03

She is in an abusive relationship and its hard to get out of but if she keeps getting sucked in its only gonna get harder. She needs to leave now

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 23/03/2022 11:23

Re your sister: Find sources of help, what she would be entitled to in terms of benefits. Have you got space for her at your place? What needs to happen to get him out of hers?

Re: the children. Does she have dc with him? Does he have full custody of them?

Re him. Not your responsibility. He is responsible for his finances and his behaviour. You are not a therapy dog.

Leona93 · 23/03/2022 11:38

@StrictlyAFemaleFemale

Re your sister: Find sources of help, what she would be entitled to in terms of benefits. Have you got space for her at your place? What needs to happen to get him out of hers?

Re: the children. Does she have dc with him? Does he have full custody of them?

Re him. Not your responsibility. He is responsible for his finances and his behaviour. You are not a therapy dog.

She is on Jobseeker benefit as is. We have a free room, so does my parents, she's been offered and took the offer a few times but always moved back. They live at his place. She doesn't have any children with him.
OP posts:
incognitoforthisone · 23/03/2022 12:43

YANBU to want her to leave him, although obviously it's not a decision you can make for her.

FWIW, I suspect he is very much not as sober as he has told your sister he is. He's behaving very much like someone who is hoovering coke up his nose on a daily basis and I suspect that's where a lot of his money's going. I don't think her leaving him is going to send him back to using drugs, because it's unlikely that he ever stopped using them in the first place.

His children are not your sister's responsibility and, gently, I think you need to tell her that. The kids have an unstable mother and an arsehole father but that's as much the case now as it would be if your sister left him. I strongly suspect she is either making excuses to herself for not leaving, or that he has cast her in the role of his protector and stabilising influence and she is so used to doing everything for him now that he has convinced her he'll wither and die if she leaves him. He won't, though. He'll carry on being exactly the same dickhead he is now.

Does she have kids? Does she want kids? Because if she does, this is absolutely not the man to have them with. She's ruining her own life and her own future.

Ponoka7 · 23/03/2022 12:49

Obviously she needs to finish it. I wouldn't be so quick to call his ex unstable. People who have been abused, or are being emotionally abused often come across as unstable, but it's just lashing out at their abuser.

DeliaOwens · 23/03/2022 15:10

OP. If your sister could see the situation rationally, you would not be here asking questions.

The logical answer is, she should pack her bags and go as, he should not speak to anyone like that. No one wakes up in the morning, hoping the person they live (and who supposedly loves them) speaks or acts this way. It is dehumanising behaviour.

However, life is too complex in most cases.

If your sister is reading this, please know you are not alone. This man is chipping away at your self worth, and eventually there will only be a husk left. Only YOU can determine your worth and you perceive your worth too low currently!

You need to forget what you feel and remember what you deserve!

Xpologog · 23/03/2022 17:13

OP’s sister: This man is using you. Both as a source of finance to him and a verbal punchbag. If you stay here will use and a use you more—- because with each day he’ll learn he can take as much as he wants from you — there are no consequences for him.
You are not his keeper, no his therapist. He will make out you’re wonderful, the best, can’t live without you so he can take, take, take.
Once there’s no more to take his verbal abuse could well turn physical.
Walk away and if you are concerned about the welfare of the children, call Social Services.
But walk away. Now.

thepeopleversuswork · 23/03/2022 17:18

He sounds absolutely appalling and yes she should leave. I’m surprised you feel the need to ask. More to the point does she want to?

Goldfishmountainclimber · 24/03/2022 12:40

To OP’s Sister: you must walk away from this relationship. You deserve so much better than this man. It will only get worse if you stay.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread