Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this a reasonable price for a christening cake?

96 replies

Sofiegiraffe · 14/12/2021 16:46

Asking because I genuinely have no idea about these things, I've never ordered a bespoke cake before.

I've been quoted £70 as a minimum price for an 8 inch one tiered cake that serves 25 people.

Does this sound about average?

OP posts:
caketiger · 14/12/2021 17:20

*bang

Anomelettefortheroad · 14/12/2021 17:20

I paid about that for an 8", 4 tier cake and it served way way more than 25 servings we were eating it for days!

Sofiegiraffe · 14/12/2021 17:48

So ... an interesting development. I sent the same images of roughly what I wanted to 2 cake makers to compare price (2 tiered cake personalised with daughter's name and date of christening). The original person who said £70 minimum for 1 tiered has quoted me £160. Based on the same image, a second person has quoted me £95, and says it will serve 30 people. Such a discrepancy in price!!

OP posts:
lisaandalan · 14/12/2021 22:32

Yes sounds about right. X

lisaandalan · 14/12/2021 22:41

Waitrose do lovely cakes made to order starting from £25.
I've added a couple of pictures but there's quite a few to choose from.

Is this a reasonable price for a christening cake?
Is this a reasonable price for a christening cake?
Notjustanymum · 15/12/2021 06:18

It depends on the type of cake. If it’s a rich fruit cake complete with marzipan and icing, then it should serve 25 and £70.00 is a reasonable price. If it’s a sponge cake it will serve 12 max and £70.00 is a rip-off!
Costco celebration cakes are great birthday sponges to send into school for a child, but I wouldn’t make one the centrepiece for a Christening…

DDivaStar · 15/12/2021 06:26

I always use Waitrose or m&s for cakes. I can't justify the price and have rarely found the taste better from independent makers.

Capricopia · 15/12/2021 06:34

Yeah, sounds normal!

Scarby9 · 15/12/2021 06:36

I used an M&S rich fruit cake (delicious) with plain white icing. Cut a hole in the cake and inserted a smal vase (Colman's mustard jarr the ideal size and invisible) of sweet peas for a summer party - it looked beautiful.
Colin the Caterpillar on the side for fruit cake haters...

Panacotta · 15/12/2021 06:37

Go on your local FB / parents / community page and ask for local recommendations for cake bakers op. You should get loads of options then.

FrankGrillosWrist · 15/12/2021 06:41

Just buy a nice cake from the shop, test it out first though. As soon as you mention wedding, funeral, or christening … in your case, the prices rocket. Plus these so called professionally made expensive cakes often taste awful. I’ve never tasted Costco or M&S, but if ever I buy a birthday cake it will be from Lidl or Morrison as they’re far tastier than anything else I’ve ever tried.

Gretaburley · 15/12/2021 06:48

@thatsallineed

I must be missing something here. The ingredients for a nice 8" sponge cake plus fondant icing would be not much more than a fiver.

I'd want gold leaf on it for £70.

You have no idea. I spend at least 5 hours making and decorating a 1 tier cake for a celebration. At nmw my time alone would be £47.50 And obviously there’s all the equipment that bakers invest in.

This is why I only make cakes for friends.

DockOTheBay · 15/12/2021 06:49

@Chely

Sod that, I get ones from costco for under £20 and they're huge
That wouldn't be a bespoke cake then would it.
DockOTheBay · 15/12/2021 06:55

Sushi ingredients cost £5, why would i pay to go to a sushi restaurant?
Massage oils cost £5, why would i pay to go to a spa treatment?
Hairdressing scissors cost £5, why would i pay to go to the hairdressers?
Cleaning materials cost £5, why would i pay for a cleaner?

Hmm maybe you're also paying for the person's time, skill and premises like in all paid for services.

cookiemonster2468 · 15/12/2021 06:57

@Sofiegiraffe

Just shown my teen DD the Costco one and she said it looks "naff" Hmm I think it's alright for £15! I might be swayed ....
Well yes there's a difference between a Costco cake and a bespoke one made by a professional. Obviously this is reflected in the price.

I think the price you were quoted is reasonable. You just have to decide what you want.

cookiemonster2468 · 15/12/2021 07:02

@thatsallineed

I must be missing something here. The ingredients for a nice 8" sponge cake plus fondant icing would be not much more than a fiver.

I'd want gold leaf on it for £70.

Yes, you are missing something - the amount of time and care that goes into baking and professionally decorating a bespoke cake.

If it takes 5 hours, at an hourly rate of even £11 an hour (very low for a professional baker) that leaves £15 for professional quality ingredients, fondant and decoration, gas/energy to bake the cake.

Sure, you can make a basic sponge cake at home for a fiver, but it won't be as good as the one you get from a professional in either taste or presentation.

People decide what they want to prioritise and spend money on for special occasions but £70 is a fair price for a professional quality bespoke cake.

Bloballbovish · 15/12/2021 07:20

@thatsallineed

I must be missing something here. The ingredients for a nice 8" sponge cake plus fondant icing would be not much more than a fiver.

I'd want gold leaf on it for £70.

The ingredients for a sponge might be a fiver, but given it serves 25 it must be tall, so that'll take loads of buttercream, which is expensive, easily £4 just for the butter then about £4 for the icing sugar. Fondant, if its tall, probably about £3-4 for the plain white ready made stuff. More for coloured - even if self-coloured as the gels aren't cheap. Then a sturdy cake board - not a flimsy supermarket one, and a box to put the cake in.

I'd say £15-20 without factoring in any decorations. For ingredients alone. I do know, as I made a cake for a friend lately (not for her, but for her to give as a gift) and I costed up ingredients because I made it as a favour but she had to cover costs. Hers was dearer as it involved a few colours, so about another £5 for colours gels.

Then if you add up time to cook several cakes for layers, clean up after them, make buttercream, crumb coat them, buttercream cover or fondant cover them clean up after all that. That's at least 3 hours. Any decorations would be extra time. So even just 3 hours at £10 is £30. But £10 an hour is a low wage for a skilled creative task like that so really it should be more.

So £45-50 so far, for the main ingredients but no decorations plus cheap labour. Decorations would obviously take more time as well as ingredients. Far above what you're scoffing at 'barely more than a fiver'. A proper baker will also need to cost things like rent for cooking space, utility bills, equipment cost, insurance, time spent conversing with customers, buying supplies etc into their business model.

Some people really have no clue as to the value of a bespoke cake.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 15/12/2021 07:31

I agree that is bang on average. I also agree Costco cakes are vile, they have really sweet American style frosting, not icing.

"I must be missing something here. The ingredients for a nice 8" sponge cake plus fondant icing would be not much more than a fiver.

I'd want gold leaf on it for £70."

You are paying for the artistry as well as the ingredients. Artists can sell their work for millions yet paint is quite cheap right? A quality cake requires consumables like a box to transport it, cake board, possibly a topper. A professional baker will also have overheads such a gas/electricity, insurance etc. They also need to earn at least minimum wage for their time.

icedcoffees · 15/12/2021 07:36

@thatsallineed

I must be missing something here. The ingredients for a nice 8" sponge cake plus fondant icing would be not much more than a fiver.

I'd want gold leaf on it for £70.

What about time. The cost of the gas/electric to run the oven. The skill involved in making it. The cost of all the insurance and hygiene certificates you need to bake professionally from home. The equipment - oven, bowls, mixers - they don't come cheap and will need replacing regularly if you do it for a living.

Would you bake a cake for someone, giving up a 4-5 hours of your time, for £5? How would any baker make a living doing that?

Lunariagal · 15/12/2021 08:07

@thatsallineed

I must be missing something here. The ingredients for a nice 8" sponge cake plus fondant icing would be not much more than a fiver.

I'd want gold leaf on it for £70.

This is the reason I don't make cakes for a living.

The first large cake I made for a friend's daughters birthday was 12" Square, with buttercream and fondant. The ingredients, plus a board / box cost me £45.

tangyandsalty · 15/12/2021 08:17

@Sofiegiraffe

Just shown my teen DD the Costco one and she said it looks "naff" Hmm I think it's alright for £15! I might be swayed ....
You can buy cake toppers from eBay if you want to decorate a shop cake.
tangyandsalty · 15/12/2021 08:18

@thatsallineed

I must be missing something here. The ingredients for a nice 8" sponge cake plus fondant icing would be not much more than a fiver.

I'd want gold leaf on it for £70.

You're paying for the hours the person will take to make and decorate the cake.
flowersforbrains · 15/12/2021 08:32

Sounds about right. I see a lot of wedding/celebration cakes that are beautiful with clearly a lot of love and effort put into them.

The Costco cake just looks cheap and nasty.

There are always people who come on these threads and say they could knock up a cake in 20 minutes with £5 worth of ingredients from Tesco. I'm a florist and also see threads like this about wedding flowers using gold plated roses and tripling the price when someone mentions the word wedding. I'm of the opinion to tell them to crack on and do the work themselves. Having baled out a few brides over the years, I wouldn't recommend it.

ZenNudist · 15/12/2021 08:36

Id say £45-50, £70 expensive. Are you London?

M&S very tasty and they used to do a lovely noahs ark.

Sofiegiraffe · 15/12/2021 09:08

@ZenNudist

Id say £45-50, £70 expensive. Are you London?

M&S very tasty and they used to do a lovely noahs ark.

Not London - north east.
OP posts: