Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To accept the money ?

76 replies

army2426 · 28/11/2021 11:43

Long story short, me and my husband separated earlier on this year. At the time, a lot had happened and the relationship was strained. I wasn't happy anymore and decided to call time on it. Shortly, before we separated my brother very kindly gifted us a lot of money. My husband has always had a thing about money and a lot of it I think is he likes control over it as he's very insecure. Don't get me wrong, he worked extremely hard to provide for our family and was generous and never withheld money but I feel as though he almost felt demasculated by it. I cannot work as we have a child with special needs so I think he's always been quite proud that he has worked so hard to solely provide for us.

When we separated, we decided to sell and split the house 50/50 and I gave him half of what was left that my brother gave me after I'd spent some on the house and also we brought a vehicle when we were together.

Anyway, fast forward to now - were trying again, We have both realised that we do really love each other and we'd like to try again. Whilst we were separated he brought another house using the money from what I gave him from my brother. As I cannot work my brother has kindly offered to go on the mortgage with me as well as put some money into the house so that we can get something suitable. Me and husband have agreed to not live together for a while as to not to confuse kids and to be sure we can move past the last year. He also wants the security of having his own place should it happen again, which I agree is a sensible idea.

The last few days though he's been saying he wants me to decline the money from my brother, said it's pushing him out and that I should just have him on the mortgage and get a much smaller house than what I've been looking at. The houses I'm looking at are not large, 3 bed semis ( I have two dc ) but house prices are sky high at the moment and the area we live is more expensive but I'd like to stay around here as my dd has just started school here. He's suggesting I go 15 miles or so out so that I can get a cheaper house. The issue i have is that my ds isn't at school at the moment and the drive every morning would be a pain, plus i like my daughter would be around her school friends etc. He has said it isn't fair I get help and he's had to provide everything for himself and that I should do it on my own like he has. My feelings are difference is, I have a disabled child that likely won't be leaving home, I want stability for us.

As things are still early days with sorting things out im torn as if it goes tits up again. I'll be in a house / area I don't want to be in.

I've said moving forward, if things work out we will give my brother the money back and sort something for us.

I just don't know if I am BU having this money or whether he is 🤷🏽‍♀️

OP posts:
CoffeeBeansGalore · 28/11/2021 12:37

He wants this
He also wants the security of having his own place should it happen again, which I agree is a sensible idea.

So why shouldn't you have the same?

GoodnightGrandma · 28/11/2021 12:43

@RedDeadRoach

If i was your brother id be royally pissed off that money id given to you had been given to your dh when you split up. Your brother is incredibly kind to still want to give you money after that.

Your husband has his own best interests at heart. Don't trust him.

I agree.
ThinWomansBrain · 28/11/2021 12:45

you "really love" this controlling twat? why?
You're not properly together, yet he is trying to control you, where you live, your finances and potentially cause a rift between you and your incredibly supportive brother.
Not to mention squirreling off a property of his own that you have no say in.

Ourlady · 28/11/2021 12:45

What a conniving bastard!
Have you asked him why it's okay for him to buy a house with YOUR brothers money but not okay for you to do the same.

Thursdaymiami · 28/11/2021 12:53

WTAF AM I READING

You don’t work and you have a disabled child and yet you split everything 50/50

You only separated and did not divorce so he still has a claim on everything else you get gifted from now on in.

He has a totally separate house he paid for with your brothers money, and he wants you to move to a more crap area and a more crap house because he thinks you’re SPOILT.

You are married to an ABUSER. Anyone who could take 50% off a disabled child of theirs and want them to have a more shit life is a real cunt.

WAKE UP - GET A DIVORCE
get more than 50% and everything else you’re entitled to, do you have a pension????????? Does your H? What are you going to do in old age when you’ve nothing to your name and you’re now looking after a disabled adult.

This is all levels of fucked up

Booboobadoo · 28/11/2021 12:54

You've done the hard bit already with separating - don't undo this by throwing away you and your DC's chance to be settled. When he says, 'move somewhere that's less convenient for you and DC, spend more of your brother's money on me, don't have a home that is your own' - do they sound like the words of a man that cares about you? Buy the home that suits you and DC and tell him to get fucked. You're putting his wants above your DC's needs.

Travis1 · 28/11/2021 12:55

Red flags all over the place. He’s ‘done it on his own’ with the money from your brother 🙄 I’d be seriously reconsidering the trying again to be honest. He’s not bothered about inconveniencing or cause if problems for you and the children. Just that everything meets his perception of ‘fair’

QueeniesCroft · 28/11/2021 13:03

I'm sorry, but this reconciliation isn't going to bring you happiness. You need a lawyer, a divorce and to go after every last penny you can get, for the sake of your children. If that includes part of the new house he has bought, then go for it.
He is not on your side. I reckon he has had some advice about the likely financial outcomes if you divorce and wants to avoid losing too much in a settlement.

HestersSamplerofCarrots · 28/11/2021 13:03

So….. he took half the money your brother gave you, took half when you split up to invest in a house, won’t give it back now that you’re back together but has a chip on his shoulder about you accepting help from…..your brother in order to invest in a house.

And you’re getting back together with this prize catch because….?

Oh, and you admit that he has form for being controlling about money. Which he’s continuing with. He’s not changed has he?

MysteriousSoup · 28/11/2021 13:04

@Morechocolatethanbarbara

So your ex is happy to spend your brother's money on HIS house, but he doesn't want you to spend your brother's money on your house, for you and your disabled DC so you can be close to school??

Honestly, you need to put yourself and your DC 1st. Take your brother's kind offer and really think about whether you should be in a relationship with a man who wants to make your life harder and not easier/more comfortable.

This Wise words
Thursdaymiami · 28/11/2021 13:15

Also if you’re going to be this naïve about him then FFS don’t let your poor brother lose even more of his money when your H divorces you eventually

Chloemol · 28/11/2021 13:18

He gets no decision in this

He is keeping his house in case it doesn’t work, you do as he asks, it doesn’t work out and you are 15 miles away from where you are now

Your brother has kindly offered to help, let him, do what you want,, stay where you want to be should it not work out

Why should your ex be protected in case it doesn’t work out but not you

If it does work out you can always sell both properties and buy together again

But personally his behaviour about this, his lack of understanding about how you need to be where you are now, and how is is only prepared to protect himself if it doesn’t work is a big red flag to me and i would be rethinking

Bogofftosomewherehot · 28/11/2021 13:20

@Morechocolatethanbarbara

So your ex is happy to spend your brother's money on HIS house, but he doesn't want you to spend your brother's money on your house, for you and your disabled DC so you can be close to school??

Honestly, you need to put yourself and your DC 1st. Take your brother's kind offer and really think about whether you should be in a relationship with a man who wants to make your life harder and not easier/more comfortable.

this! He is ridiculous and trying to control.
Do what is right for you and stop considering making your life more difficult just to keep him happy.
Llmcg · 28/11/2021 13:22

Why do people not know the difference between brought and bought it's so basic

Bogofftosomewherehot · 28/11/2021 13:25

@Llmcg

Why do people not know the difference between brought and bought it's so basic
@Llmcg - Yes, that may be the case but it's hardly the point here. Be kind - or scroll on.
Gliderx · 28/11/2021 13:30

Give your children the best life possible.

Has your Dbro considered buying the house in his own name and letting you and DC live in it so your husband doesn't have a claim to it if you later divorce?

Shoxfordian · 28/11/2021 13:31

Don’t get back with him; big mistake

gamerchick · 28/11/2021 13:37

@army2426

He thinks I'm spoilt and have no value of money as he's always provided and now my brother. It annoys him - and whilst I see what he's saying, ( although before we had kids I worked full time and paid all my bills etc on my own ) but as you said I just see it as making me life unnecessarily harder ? I don't choose not to work. I can't - in unemployable due to my sons appointments, hospital admissions and now his refusal to go to school or even leave the house.
It doesn't matter what he thinks. You're playing the cards you've been dealt. As we all do.

You've been offered a lifeline out of his little controlling petty crap. Take it. What exactly is he going to do?

saraclara · 28/11/2021 13:37

Please don't get back with this man. He was perfectly happy to take your brother's money for his own needs, but now won't let you take some for your needs and the needs of your disabled child? After he accepted an entirely unfair settlement when you separated?

Take your lovely brother's offer, but ensure that it's absolutely fully protected from any future claim from your partner.

But again, this man is proving how selfish he is. So just don't get back with him. You can do better.

saraclara · 28/11/2021 13:39

think about whether you should be in a relationship with a man who wants to make your life harder and not easier/more comfortable.

100% that. And for goodness' sake, then come to the right decision.

DontBeCatty · 28/11/2021 13:48

Your husband lacks logical thinking skills.

Tricked2003 · 28/11/2021 13:49

If he feels so strongly about it he can return your brothers money that he used to buy a house!!!
Do not let him call the shots, protect yourself.

FlowerFlour · 28/11/2021 13:51

@Gliderx

Give your children the best life possible.

Has your Dbro considered buying the house in his own name and letting you and DC live in it so your husband doesn't have a claim to it if you later divorce?

This. You are still married so your husband will have a claim on any house you buy. Luckily this means you also have a claim on 'his' house. Divorce him and get every penny you can, for the sake of your children. 50/50 when you are a carer for your disabled child is a ridiculously unfair split.

How does your brother feel about your husband using brother's money to buy a house just for himself? If I were your brother I'd be so pissed off. That money was to help you and your children, not purchase a shag pad for some grabby arsehole.

Your husband does not have your best interests at heart. He wants you and the children to be reliant on him, except he's not reliable so if you do that you'll be screwed. Protect yourself.

Porfre · 28/11/2021 13:52

Stop "being kind" and put yourself and your kid first.

If he wants this to work he'll have to deal with this. It's his choice.

You put yourself first

Thursdaymiami · 28/11/2021 13:54

I hope he’s paying for child maintenance