Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

-to dread my mother-in-law coming to stay?

32 replies

Jaynee · 21/11/2007 14:41

Can anyone offer me any advice about difficult mother in laws? Mine is very domineering and bossy, somthing I'm not used to with my own mother. She is also very protective of my daughter and sometimes I feel that if I weren't around she would be happy because she'd have her son and grand-daughter to herself. She never compliments my parenting or is interested in anything my daughter does with me and she is always telling me what to do. I am sure she means well but I can't stand it. Tried to stand up to her once but we had a huge row as she is very argumentative!!! I hate confrontation. We live far away so i dread her visits. Has anyone got any coping advice?? I recentlyhad a miscarriage which I'm sure ws stress related and this is my one and only 'issue' and I could do with having some strategies.

OP posts:
Soph73 · 21/11/2007 14:53

Copious amounts of wine normally work for me No, sorry, on a serious note I would ask her advice on everything, get her involved in all the chores & just smile sweetly when she looks at you condescendingly .... then hit the bottle How long´s she staying?

fircone · 21/11/2007 14:59

Buy a copy of The Little House by Philippa Gregory. (prices from 1pm on Amazon marketplace)

It is the BEST story about a vile, domineering mil. I read it twice after I had ds as I found it so pertinent to my situation.

talktothebees · 21/11/2007 14:59

Oooh MILs .....[rub hands emoticon]

When you say protective of your daughter what do you mean? Isn't that your job?

Does you DH stand up for you or is he more the stick-your-fingers-in-his-ears-and-whistle type?

Why's she coming now anyway when you're recovering from a miscarriage?

So many questions....I'm a nosy old boot

frootloop · 21/11/2007 15:06

Its your house and your rules, just remember that fact. just be super syrupy nice and dont give her the satisfaction of thinking she has power over you, if she tries any domineering crap just take a deep breath and tell her no, if she tries argueing give as good as you get, don't back down and make sure you get DH on your side and promise to back you up if MIL starts up.

you will find it so empowering to stand up to her and if she sees you as a strong confident woman she will probably back down as she sounds like a bully

i was a bit like that around my ILs at first but soon realised that if i didn't grow a backbone they would walk all over me for ever. i stood up to them and now they tiptoe around me because they know i won't put up with their snide remarks or underhand behaviour ever again.

act strong and confident, even if you are churning inside with nerves, don't let the old bag push you around in your home. good luck

purpleturtle · 21/11/2007 15:09

YANBU.
Mine's coming this weekend.
I'm dreading it too.

quirkychick · 21/11/2007 15:28

YANBU!

My MIL is a PITA too but DP is very supportive of me and DD.

The best tactic is to be firm but coldly calm. If and when she does something you don't like treat her like a difficult toddler and don't engage in an argument but say what you want to say calmly and firmly. The 'broken record' technique is good. Just keep repeating your point of view rather than getting heated - then she hasn't won and got the reaction she wants. The rest of the time, syrupy sweetness. It will annoy the hell out of her.

Good luck!

RubySlippers · 21/11/2007 15:36

are you responsible for entertaining her the whole time she is with you?

I think your DH needs to spend time with his mum as well

take advantage - go out with your friends whilst you have an on-tap babysitter, have a facial, an hour long bath ... doesn't have to be a totally negative experience

purpleturtle · 21/11/2007 15:37

Any tips for calming them down though? Ds2 is used to a fair amount of freedom to roam in the house. He's fine on the stairs, and my finely tuned mother's ear knows precisely which kitchen cupboard he has turned his attention to, even if I'm on MN. My PILs, on the other hand, tell him all the time "you'll fall", "oh no, not in there", "where are you going?" and close doors. I know they mean well, but it's difficult to ask somebody to leave their grandchild alone. Especially when they react like sulky children if you try.

(I really should get off MN. I've hijacked every MIL thread going today. Maybe I should start my own.)

rebelmum1 · 21/11/2007 16:10

Ha ha I'm in the same boat. Mines a nasty piece of work, bossy, sour, talks behind you're back domineering. Thinks she knows best about dd and doesn't think I'm looking after her. I could go on... My advice to you is don't take it personally! You can't go head to head, she has one trump card your dh, he will side with her and you will look petty. Big smiles and a secret stash of your favourite tipple in the pantry

rebelmum1 · 21/11/2007 16:12

What ever you do don't take her into your confidence, don't disclose even the slightest weakness. You need a shield of steel!

aramintavanhamstring · 21/11/2007 16:26

I predict several YABU from people with nice MIL's any minute now followed by 'I hope your DIL doesn't have the same attitude in the future!!!!'

All I can say is that in my own little world, I have withdrawn from the problem. My dh takes the kids up country to see his parents and when they come down here, I go away for a little holiday if my dh won't take time off work. Strangely, since taking this stance my dh has made sure that he about to entertain his family whilst I provide the meals and drink a lot of wine.

The big mistake, I believe, is ever falling into the role of the entertainer-of-dh-parents in the first place.

manchita · 21/11/2007 16:33

I would make an effort to compliment her, be nice and reassuring and thank her for her suggestions. I think then maybe she will be a bit easier with you. Maybe she feels you disapprove of her.
She is family now and not going anywhere! She is also an important person in your daughters life- having a close relationship with her will be fantastic for your daughter as she grows. Maybe arrange for them to have a day out together- great for you and dh!
She could also babysit whilst she's with you. It takes the pressure of dh too if you really make an effort.

manchita · 21/11/2007 16:35

Also, you say she lives far away- I guess you don't see her much then, so surely making an effort isn't so hard.

rebelmum1 · 21/11/2007 16:37

Ohmigod! i have just realised that my DP's folks are coming midweek coinciding with a day off of mine! Suggestions anyone?? Bearing in mind he has been fabulous with my demented mother for the last 2 weeks. Also bearing in mind I have successfully averted 3 prior visits by not answering the phone ..

rebelmum1 · 21/11/2007 16:40

ah ha! I will go out on an errand and leave dd in their capable care!!

manchita · 21/11/2007 16:40

As above,rebel mum. I really think it's not worth getting into conflict with in laws (if at all poss)esp if you don't see them that often.
Maybe you should all go out for lunch, people are better behaved outdoors.....

manchita · 21/11/2007 16:41

Just remember, you are doing it for your children....

rebelmum1 · 21/11/2007 16:46

You haven't met mine manchita, she has threatened to cut dp off when he met me, slags him off to me, calls her other son fat, keeps arranging occasions for both his ex and him to be together without me, undermines me all the time, my dd was very ill and she undermined me to dp in an awful way. Personally I haven't got into any conflict but strongly support avoidance methods.

rebelmum1 · 21/11/2007 16:47

I just

manchita · 21/11/2007 16:56

Well, rebelmum(like your name by the way)I understand how you feel then. I think it's up to your dp to tell them he is not interested in seeing his ex anymore, and that they need to stop talking about both of you to the other one and undermining your relationship.
Is he the type who will do that or does he not realise quite how bad they are?
Why did they threaten to cut him off when he met you?

rebelmum1 · 21/11/2007 17:13

Because he wouldn't give the whole house as opposed to over half of it to his ex. Mainly because she just revels in that sort of stuff, she just cosies on up to you all nice, digging and trying to get some misery, or juicy titbit or other out of you, she's like a savage dog with a bone. No he thinks she means well! He isn't blind to her flaws and does spell things out to her to the point that she thinks I'm putting him up to it which makes her worse

Jaynee · 21/11/2007 21:07

Thanks for the advice guys, and you are right Manchita, I should be able to make the effort once in a while but she's a very difficult character and two faced. Goes to church once a week and then slags everyone off for another week. She 'told' me she's coming for a week so we'll see. I never get a look in with dd when she's around. Does that annoy anyone else? Feel like a spare part. Am prepared to accept it to a point but she even starts trying to re'arrange my childcare arrangements!

OP posts:
quint · 21/11/2007 21:15

Stand up to her - don;t let her make you feel like a spare part - she's your daughter and its in your home, make a stand!

WinkyWinkola · 21/11/2007 21:30

Everything about difficult MILs lets us know how not to be behave when our DSs get married.

I always feel toxic and depressed after my MIL visits. She bitches about almost every family member we ask after. It's not nice. And it's not nice for DH to see that his mum is in fact a bitch who prefers to say nasty things about people. We tend to keep quiet and not say much but she still bangs on about people and the wrongs they've done her over the years even children who have apparently wronged her other grandchildren.

Like yours, Jaynee, she would much rather I was out of the picture and she could have DH and my DCs to herself. That's tough really on both you and her. You because that's a pretty sh*tty attitude to have and on her, because it's not going to happen.

I wouldn't bother standing up to her per se. You can quietly be assertive without being confrontational. You can thank her for her advice but you'd rather do things this way. Constantly tell her how well DD is looking, how well she's doing at school etc. If she says anything negative, just ask her if she's saying DD is less than perfect. If she's saying you are less than a perfect mother, then say you'd rather she said nothing if she's nothing nice to say. And especially in front of your DD because you wouldn't dream of slagging off family in front of your child.

Bear in mind she's probably difficult because she feels threatened by you and what a great job you're doing with your child.

It's tricky I know. And all this BS about you married your husband therefore you married his parents - cobblers. But you just make sure you maintain your dignity and your parenting preferences - you never married to give those up. The rest of it doesn't matter.

manchita · 21/11/2007 21:59

Jaynee, I wasn't suggesting that you married his parents when you married him. Of course you should tell her you don't want to hear her slagging everyone of esp in front of your dc.
I think I was talking from experience when I said just try to get on. I don't have mil around but I do have 5 SIL's who are all quite protective of their brother and are much older than him.
I used to get so angry at the thought that they didn't approve of me or the way I was bringing my children up and yet when I found more self belief and saw us as a strong unit in our own right I made visits from them as comfortable as I could (whilst holding my own in a quiet and assertive way)and things changed.
We don't see any of them that often anyway.
Just trying to be positive!

Swipe left for the next trending thread