Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is being green-fingered a natural talent or can it be learned?

38 replies

forinborin · 10/04/2021 17:36

Not sure whether more relevant to the gardening section, but posting here for traffic, although no one is unreasonable here (hopefully).
Threw away a couple of dead orchids today. No matter what I do to the little buggers, they die. Same with citrus trees, potted flowers... pretty much all houseplants. There was an amazing ficus plant someone gave me for my birthday that seemed to thrive against my best efforts, but I found the reason when attempting to repot it, proudly thinking it probably got too big now - it was fake, just very very well made.
I read books on the topic, browsed hundreds of websites, bought additional special grow-lighting (don't know what people must think - it probably looks like a cannabis farm from outside). Not a slightest difference.

Meanwhile, one of my friends grows amazing fruiting lemon trees from lemon seeds, and pineapple palms from the supermarket pineapple tops. Every plant in her care seems to turn into a jurassic version of itself. She swears there's no secret and she never reads instructions or waters on a calendar - she just instinctively feels when she needs to water / feed /replant, and that's all. She is very generous with sharing cuttings / offshoots from her home jungle, but when I ask for instructions, she has no clue other than "stick it in the soil and wait, don't forget to water". Grin

So my question. Do you think one can become green-fingered through study and self-improvement? Because I am inclined to believe now it must be a natural talent, and I am simply beyond any help.

OP posts:
cakewitch · 10/04/2021 22:56

My mother , in her time could have grown something beautiful from a shitty stick... im trying hard to be like her. She made it look effortless. It takes a lot of hard work, a lot of googling and an awful lot of patience.

MoiraRosesWigWall · 10/04/2021 23:44

I have two orchids that are thriving, but my peace lily hasn't flowered in years Confused I think it's important to find the plants that suit you

Saz12 · 11/04/2021 09:49

“Right plant in the right place” I think. So if you want a plant for a corner that never gets direct sun, that’s going to be s very different plant from the one you’d choose for a south-facing curtainless windiw.

forinborin · 11/04/2021 09:56

She like just looks at a dying plant and it springs back to life🤦
The same with my friend. She had rescued an orchid from me before the pandemic which had all roots rotted away and the leaves were partially swollen and floppy, partially dried. I was going to throw it away.

I saw it on the background on zoom call a couple weeks ago, it looks like one of those fake orchids for home decor - massive, with three flower stalks.
I already ordered pothos Grin let it be the first step towards building self-confidence.

OP posts:
Thisisworsethananticpated · 11/04/2021 10:30

There was an amazing ficus plant someone gave me for my birthday that seemed to thrive against my best efforts, but I found the reason when attempting to repot it, proudly thinking it probably got too big now - it was fake, just very very well made.

That cracked me up
How did you not realise it’s fake Grin

It’s always hit and miss
Outdoor plants are easier
Indoor plants do not overwater
Indoor plants are trickier

peak2021 · 11/04/2021 10:33

I wonder if it is something where you can get to a certain level but not any further if you were not born with a natural talent. Say the difference between a GSCE and a degree, to use an analogy.

OP I don't think it does not mean you cannot have a beautiful garden, just because you are cannot be successful with certain plants.

Needhelp101 · 11/04/2021 10:40

Sorry OP, but the fake ficus did make me laugh 😂

I think it could be said that I have green fingers but I do study a lot -i absolutely love house plants and have loads. Location and correct watering are key (more house plants are killed by overwatering than underwatering). For plants that aren't desert plants, like cacti and succulents, you'll need humidity with a plant mister.

Try a snake plant or a spider plant. They're pretty unkillable and spider plants make lots of babies too (and both are good at oxygenation).

forinborin · 11/04/2021 10:41

@Thisisworsethananticpated

There was an amazing ficus plant someone gave me for my birthday that seemed to thrive against my best efforts, but I found the reason when attempting to repot it, proudly thinking it probably got too big now - it was fake, just very very well made.

That cracked me up
How did you not realise it’s fake Grin

It’s always hit and miss
Outdoor plants are easier
Indoor plants do not overwater
Indoor plants are trickier

It had real sand / gravel on top of the pot... and even real ficus plants do have that plasticky look about them, don't they? And it was really well made, with individual variation on leaves and stuff....

OK, there's no excuse that doesn't sound bad Grin

OP posts:
Cherrysoup · 11/04/2021 11:26

Get an aloe Vera. Impossible to kill. I can’t be bothered with house plants normally but this one refuses to die. It’s in a big pot, I ignore it til it goes brown then it revives with water. Never fed it. I only have it for the healing properties, I react badly to mozzie bites and burn easily so find it useful.

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 11/04/2021 11:28

@SchrodingersImmigrant

I think it's bit of both. I have amazing outdoor green fingers. I am a mass murderer inside😂

I agree with pp. You picked bitch plants! Get pothos! Perfect starter.

Also, stop caring so much. Too much care kills them😂

Same. My outdoor garden is lovely. Indoors, I’m a disaster.
ceilingsand · 11/04/2021 13:32

I'm awful with indoor plants and ok with the garden. Although I haven't killed this for a decade, and it's enormous:

https://plantboutique.co.uk/shop/popular/calathea-medallion?gclid=EAIaIQobChMI6Mwhpn27wIVxsLVCh3y2Af0EAQYAiABEgIoSSDBwE

Saz12 · 11/04/2021 13:51

Indoor plants are trickier than outdoor - those that like indoor light-levels generally come from jungly environments so want really high humidity: houses are just too dry for them. If you can keep them on a tray with pebbles on it and water just covering the base of the tray that helps (so the pot is on the pebbles, not in the water).
Almost nothing likes the temperature changes and draughts of being on a window ledge.
A lot of orchids don’t grow in soil (they grow on mossy tree branches) and photosynthesis via roots as well as leaves. The roots will rot very very easily and they like it humid.
A lot of house plants are grown very intensively in nurseries (artificial day length, added co2, misting systems, etc) and when they’re transported to the shop they’ve got a huge shock, then in the shop they’re not looked after that well, and ten when you get them home they’re all set to become very ill.

Most flowering house plants you buy are intended to be thrown away after they’ve stopped flowering because it’s actually quite hard to induce them to flower.
Citrus are just bastards.

FlossieTeacakesFurCoat18 · 11/04/2021 14:49

Are you sure the orchids were dead? Mine looked dead for ages between their blooming seasons then they'd come back with beautiful flowers (until I did kill them leaving them in an unheated house in winter for 3 weeks 😳)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page